5 ms·
The inefficiency of market economy is terrible. Also it leads to production of bad products where repairability, quality is sacrificed to reduce costs and incre
by vbezhenar 8y ago
The inefficiency of market economy is terrible. Also it leads to production of bad products where repairability, quality is sacrificed to reduce costs and increase sells (who would make a good light bulb, which will last years if you can make a bad light bulb which will last months and sell dozens of them). I'm living in post-USSR country and a lot of old consumer goods which were "made in USSR" are an etalon of quality compared to modern goods.
I still think that central planned economy is superior to market economy. USSR failed because of human factor and probably because computers were not good enough to produce proper plan on a USSR-scale, but even with those factors it was able to compete with the rest of the world in science, space, military. It's quite fascinating.
- vkou 8y agoThere's some survivorship bias at play here. The crappy, poor quality goods made in the USSR went to the scrap heap decades ago. The stuff you're seeing today lasted the test of time, but a lot of other stuff didn't. Some Soviet categories of goods, and brands were pretty decent. My grandparents' fridge has lasted a good 40 years, without any issues. Their television was broken more then it was working.
- craigkilgo 8y agoA percentage of this effect is due to "restrictions" on manufacturing. i.e. you had to make things with a certain thickness of steel, etc. You see this effect with American goods too. You have avocado green fridges still running for 50 years or washing machines from the 1970's that are still running. Things don't last today because we have paper thin metal and various other cheap parts and there is no incentive to make a washing machine that lasts for 40 years.
- 3rdAccount 8y agoI received an old washing machine when i got married and a new dryer. That washing machine is super heavy, but still working. The dryer is a POS and the plastic knobs have all started failing, so I have to use pliers to turn the knob. I'd pay 2x the price of a standard appliance to get a quality one without question.
- v_lisivka 8y agoBuy used professional model instead. They will last much longer, while cost similar price. But usually, they are very dumb and feature-poor. Also, if you see market for heavy duty products, you can pitch investors and start manufacturing them by yourself.
- 3rdAccount 8y agoI've thought of both of these things before, but don't have the appetite for such a venture at the moment.
- r00fus 8y agoIsn't part of the "50 year old fridges running" due to survival bias? Meaning : you aren't (and probably can't for obvious reasons) counting the vast numbers/majority of the same model of item that are no longer in service.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ekianjo 8y ago> even with those factors it was able to compete with the rest of the world in science, space, military. Competing on a few key sectors is easy when you sacrifice the livelihood of your whole nation, spoil their property, and send millions to the Gulag to deter any political opposition. And the Soviets did not compete in "Science". They competed on military and space exploration mainly, but most of the other areas of Science were left dry by the Soviets, or left to crazy experimentation based on pseudo science in agriculture. Most of the genetic discoveries were done in the US, most of drug development happened in the US, computer development was way ahead in the US as well - there is no world where the Soviets were competitive across the spectrum. And let's not forget that the US continuously shipped grains to the URSS because they could not produce enough food for their own people consistently. You can't do Science if you can't even grasp agriculture. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1979/10/04/huge-grain-sale-to-soviet-union-approved-by-us/41b3bc1d-8f75-4ed6-98db-77556322a3d9/?utm_term=.58b4394f3c2e https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1979/10/04/h...
- coldtea 8y ago>Competing on a few key sectors is easy when you sacrifice the livelihood of your whole nation, spoil their property, and send millions to the Gulag to deter any political opposition. Don't forget that Russia (and thus USSR) started of as a poor agrarian nation to begin with, much behind in industrialization than the US, UK, etc. The pictures of huge queues aside, USSR was a huge jump in standards of living and consumption for millions of people compared to before (which even included a tradition of serfdom). USSR had also started quite early with non-central planning (NEP was a "free market" attempt similar to today's China), but ended it to quickly allocate resources between WWI and WWII to being able to withstand invasion. Quite prescient it was too. I'd say USSR would have done much better without Stalin at the helm, without WWII that had a 30+ million human toll, and with NEP continued (it was stopped sometime in the late 20s). >And the Soviets did not compete in "Science". They competed on military and space exploration mainly, but most of the other areas of Science were left dry by the Soviets, or left to crazy experimentation based on pseudo science in agriculture. Maybe invest in some science history books? The "crazy experimentation based on pseudo science in agriculture" (Lysenko I guess) is a known early example (then again the west had its own share or pseudo science, remember lobotomies?), but they had tons of important scientists and engineers in all fields, much beyond "space exploration and military" -- from Kolmogorov to Basov, and tons of inventions we depend upon today...
- badpun 8y ago> I'm living in post-USSR country and a lot of old consumer goods which were "made in USSR" are an etalon of quality compared to modern goods. Maybe the simpler ones, like blow dryers. Cars made in communist Poland usually broke down within first couple of hundred kilometers of purchase. People used to take a new car to a (private, as in not-state-owned) mechanic, who would dissasemble it and then reassemble, to make sure everything was put together correctly. Not to mention that communist Poland, a nation of 40 million, was unable to design its own car and had to licence it for production from capitalist corporations.
- nine_k 8y agoIf you ever lived in the actual USSR, you must also remember how poor average people were, how hard was it to find and buy anything decent, or simply anything. Including food. Want a piece of meat? Spend two hours in a line. Want a piece of Bologna sausage, or butter? Here's your food stamp for a minimum monthly ration. USSR just did not have enough resources to properly feed everyone using planned economy. It had to admit the very smallest pieces of market economy (sell apples from your orchard, don't go to jail) to keep people somehow fed.
- baursak 8y agoI think there were several different periods where things were not bad, and when things were not that great, like the 60s, 70s, or 80s, and different people who lived in the USSR refer to different periods, so you get people claiming very different things. These data, at least, don't support the claims that Soviets were always starving: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-per-capita-caloric-supply?year=1961 https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-per-capita-caloric-...
- claudiawerner 8y ago>USSR failed because of human factor and probably because computers were not good enough to produce proper plan on a USSR-scale I think this too. There has been recent work by Paul Cockshott (a computer scientist) on new models of central planning with modern computers. I'd urge anyone interested to check it out.
- v_lisivka 8y agoI investigated case with planning in USSR and found that all planing was done by single woman. She got position by "blat" (bribe + protection from someone in power). All planning process was down to increasing of previous numbers by 5-10% once in 5 years. No known computer in the world can fix that.
- baursak 8y ago> I investigated case with planning in USSR and found that all planing was done by single woman. That's interesting. Are you saying that the functionality of entire Gosplan organization from the 1920s all the way to the end was done by one woman? What was her name?
- icebraining 8y agoI believe v_lisivka is talking about a specific planning job in some USSR-era organization, not the whole of the USSR.
- v_lisivka 8y agoNo, I'm talking about GOSPLAN in last 15 years of life of USSR. I forgot name of woman (I did investigation more than 15 years ago), but it was just one woman, protege of Babaian. I forgot details, so maybe it was yearly plan, but idea remains: for last 15 years, USSR was on autopilot and bribes.
- baursak 8y ago
- v_lisivka 8y ago> a lot of old consumer goods which were "made in USSR" are an etalon of quality compared to modern goods You just cannot afford high-quality product.
- icebraining 8y agoI'm living in post-USSR country and a lot of old consumer goods which were "made in USSR" are an etalon of quality compared to modern goods. If you replace USSR with "period up to the late 80s", that statement is repeated in many countries, so maybe the central planning part is not the distinguishing factor.
- Fins 8y agoStrictly speaking, Soviet goods (very few of them, though) were of somewhat decent quality when compared to the cheapest crap made in a non-name sweatshop for dollar stores. Or export to the Eastern Europe and ex-Soviet countries. Even in the space, USSR achieved much more launches than the US for a simple reason -- Soviet satellites crapped out in months instead of years.