3 ms·
Oh hey! This looks very interesting! > Transient phenomena associated with forward biased silicon p + - n - n + struc- tures at 4.2K show remar
by carapace 8y ago
Oh hey! This looks very interesting!
> Transient
phenomena
associated
with
forward
biased
silicon
p
+ -
n - n
+
struc-
tures
at
4.2K
show
remarkable
similarities
with
biological
neurons.
The
devices
play
a role
similar
to
the
two-terminal
switching
elements
in
Hodgkin-Huxley
equivalent
circuit
diagrams.
The
devices
provide
simpler
and
more
realistic
neuron
emulation
than
transistors
or
op-amps.
They
have
such
low
power
and
current
requirements
that
they
could
be
used
in
massive
neural
networks.
Some
observed
properties
of
simple
circuits
containing
the
devices
include
action
potentials,
refractory
periods,
threshold
behavior,
excitation,
inhibition,
summation
over
synaptic
inputs,
synaptic
weights,
temporal
integration,
memory,
network
connectivity
modification
based
on
experience,
pacemaker
activity,
firing
thresholds,
coupling
to
sensors
with
graded
sig-
nal
outputs
and
the
dependence
of
firing
rate
on
input
current.
Transfer
functions
for
simple
artificial
neurons
with
spiketrain
inputs
and
spiketrain
outputs
have
been
measured
and
correlated
with
input
coupling.
- darkmighty 8y agoI suspect if you rely on certain analog properties (with some good precision) then the elements won't scale down very well (down to current transistor scale). At the very limit of element size I would think reliable elements inevitably degrade to binary gates, which are the simplest elements in behavior (at one point even binary gates become impossible of course due to phenomena like leakage, quantum tunelling, etc). The brain as far as I understand does so much with large, slow elements (neurons) by having them fill a volume, be sparsely activated (i.e. mostly a huge memory), and other advanced communication methods (temporal pulse position modulation/frequency from spiking? neurotransmitters?). Current ML is more densely activated, high-frequency networks. I'm not sure we could revert to the brain-like architecture unless we could get the cost of sillicon manufacturing several orders of magnitude down, enough that we could just fabricate a large block of stacked complex elements. A large part of the philosophy of nodes would need to be reworked (much lower frequency, lower leakeage, lower power consumption), as processes are optimized for >100MHz freqs; just so internal memory elements would keep at acceptable temperatures. Currently you could fit about 2000 GPUs in a 10cm^3 space (assuming 1mm die thickness), which would cost about $1.5M usd. And couldn't do much, because it would quickly overheat on reasonable loads, and because I don't think we have the technology to interconnect it all.
- dkfellows 8y agoThe brain definitely is able to use not just spiking frequency (which is approximately the same as EEG voltage, though not really) but also spiking patterns to encode information. We've observed some highly interesting phase locked loops showing various higher-order patterns in simulations (we simply don't have fine enough tools to look for the equivalent in the biology). The variation in neurotransmitters allows for different sorts of activation, typically with different physical parameters (size of activation, time over which it decays) and multiple ways they interact with the other neurotransmitters. Sparse networks are not understood to anything like the same extent as dense matrices. And another key property that most ML is missing is large numbers of feedback loops. Again, that makes predicting behaviours extraordinarily difficult.
- p1esk 8y agoAnd couldn't do much It couldn't do much mainly because we don't know what it should be doing (to emulate brain). In this case, the software challenge is far greater than the hardware challenge.