23 ms·
> One issue that proof of stake proponents often ignore is that proof of stake has its own costs that are roughly equivalent to the dollar cost of PoW. > Also,
by saurik 8y ago
> One issue that proof of stake proponents often ignore is that proof of stake has its own costs that are roughly equivalent to the dollar cost of PoW.
> Also, if the PoS staking rewards are too low, you are vulnerable to the exact same 51% attacks as PoW.
"We all theoretically agree that I could have burned the most oil today (and in so doing, I will not be able to do something I could otherwise have done as my funds are locked up, which feels like a waste)" is a way way way way better scenario than "I guess we will all have to burn a bunch of oil to make sure I'm right (and in so doing we destroy our habitat, which more than feels like a waste)"... it really doesn't matter if it provides a better result than proof-of-work as long as it doesn't provide a worse one and has fewer externalities (if nothing else, as the people willing to play this game at all will have a selection bias for people who don't think the environment is important; we are already at the point where 1% of humanity's CO2 impact is from cryptocurrency mining, which is insane: "the economy is moving 1% slower as we are locking up capital in silly ways" is roughly harmless in comparison).
- gruez 8y ago>"We all theoretically agree that I could have burned the most oil today [...]" is a way way way way better scenario than "I guess we will all have to burn a bunch of oil to make sure I'm right [...]" note this argument only works if the costs of burning oil (habitat destruction) is being externalized. thus, this is more of a problem with externalization than a pos vs pow issue.
- topmonk 8y agoThe realization of that sort of idealism is so far fetched it doesn't change the argument. Sure, you could possibly get the USA to create laws to stop externalizing the costs of co2 production, but everyone, everywhere? Including the most corrupt, war torn, and penniless places in the world? And what about the deep state? They once sold cocaine to us citizens in order to raise money for black ops. Would they think twice about mining PoW?
- cabalamat 8y ago> Sure, you could possibly get the USA to create laws to stop externalizing the costs of co2 production, but everyone, everywhere? If you got 2 out of (USA,EU,PRC) to do it, and those countries all put big import tariffs and other sanctions on other countries that didn't, that would switch over the world economy to lowering CO2 emissions. > Including the most corrupt, war torn, and penniless places in the world? Corrupt and war-torn places still interact with the global economy. Penniless places aren't going to have enough of an economy to emit much CO2. > And what about the deep state? [...] Would they think twice about mining PoW? If there is a worldwide effort to shut down PoW cryptocurrencies, they will become useless and the deep state won't be able to achieve anything with them that it couldn't do more easily by other means.
- topmonk 8y agoI can see your argument up to this point: > If there is a worldwide effort to shut down PoW cryptocurrencies, they will become useless and the deep state won't be able to achieve anything with them that it couldn't do more easily by other means. The whole discussion is about whether PoS is equivalent to PoW in terms of environmental harm, and I'm arguing that PoW is more costly. I don't understand what your general point is. Do you think PoW is more harmful than PoS or not? The parent was saying that it's an externalization problem. I don't think it's realistic to think that the damage to the environment could be charged back to the miner in every case, therefore PoW would always be more dirty than PoS. Could you clarify what your main point is in light of this?
- keymone 8y ago> The whole discussion is about whether PoS is equivalent to PoW in terms of environmental harm it's wrong question anyway because it implies PoW necessarily causes environmental harm. PoW is consumption of energy, just like vast majority of other human activities. consumption of energy is not what harms the environment, at least not as directly as production of energy. the two are only closely related because of unwillingness of political elites to punish harmful producers, because those producers are the political elites or are closely related to them.
- saurik 8y ago> 1% of humanity's CO2 impact is from cryptocurrency mining (I misremembered this by a factor of 10: it is actually 0.1%. But I still find that ludicrously high.)
- keymone 8y agoFirst of all you do realize that nobody is burning oil to mine bitcoin? And if you do but still represent it as such - why are you being manipulative? Second, “let’s all agree I can be in charge of selecting which transactions to process because I have most money, which means I could have spent most energy” is circular system where security of money is paid for using same money. Third, CO2 impact of cryptocurrencies is orders of magnitude lower than CO2 impact of fiat money and military structures required to assert their worth. Things don’t exist in a vacuum and you have to make the right comparisons.
- kiriakasis 8y ago> Third, CO2 impact of cryptocurrencies is orders of magnitude lower than CO2 impact of fiat money and military structures required to assert their worth. And how many orders of magnitude are cryptocurrencies smaller than fiat money?
- keymone 8y agoit’s probably the right amount of orders of magnitude, it’s free market after all, everybody is free to long and short accordingly to their beliefs.