3 ms·
Racket is too powerful to be used by big corporations. The last thing a company wants is to have their rockstar programmer leave behind a terse, arcane, impenet
by chongli 8y ago
Racket is too powerful to be used by big corporations. The last thing a company wants is to have their rockstar programmer leave behind a terse, arcane, impenetrable walnut of an application.
Languages like Java make it much easier to treat your programmers as interchangeable parts.
- squirrelicus 8y agoThis is true issue irrespective of the company's bigness.
- WalterGR 8y agoRacket is too powerful to be used by big corporations. The last thing a company wants... Ah yes, The Slashdot Cynicism. Guaranteed to get a +5 Insightful. What is your experience with Racket? Or failing that, Scheme? Or, failing that, Lisps in general?
- kamaal 8y agoNot exactly Racket. But with Perl. And the same argument. Early 2010's, I remember my company had a fairly fast, stable and small(LOC wise) data feed processing application in Perl. It just worked, barely any bugs, maintained by 2 - 3 programmers. Time came around, and your Director level people realized the teams were too small, programmers were having too much fun and more importantly it made programmers felt valuable and hard to be treated as kleenex. They decided to give some Architect Astronaut love to the application. Then came in Java programmers. Code base size exploded by 500x. Design pattern floods followed. DI to manage complexity which shouldn't have even existed. Hundreds of classes to do things that could be done in hundreds of lines in Perl. Managers routinely boasted how they managed to grow their teams, about their culture, and how big and great their teams were. They could never make it work as well as it did in Perl. I too moved on. But eventually I saw they just shut down the product. No manager likes to see their work less valuable or better than that of a programmer. Languages like Perl, Scala, Clojure, Racket, Common Lisp are never going to see decent adoption in the industry.
- chongli 8y agoUsed it in first year into to functional programming class. We didn't even get to see half the features of full Racket because the class used the student versions. Plenty of my classmates who had been programming in Java for years were getting overwhelmed by it. I know from what I've read outside of that class that Racket is powerful enough to implement any other programming language as a library. A single programmer leveraging all these features can write an application that uses bespoke domain specific languages for every component. This is wonderful for a solo project but good luck passing that on to the new recruit. P.S. guilty as charged. I am an old Slashdot reader.
- fulafel 8y agoThere is life and interesting work in the industry outside the bigcorp java trenches, don't lose hope :)
- chongli 8y agoI'm actually having a lot of fun at my job because I'm not actually a developer, I'm in change management. A lot of our processes are old, clunky, and involve a lot of manual steps. I've been writing Perl scripts to automate this stuff and my boss is loving it.
- quickthrower2 8y agoYou are an "X who programs". Nice position to be in. Well done!