4 ms·
The paradox of thrift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift
by Gibbon1 8y ago
The paradox of thrift
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift
- woolvalley 8y agoIf your putting it in the stock market or loans, doesn't it increase the supply of such things, thus making the return less and making people have to work harder as a result if 'everyone' did this? As far as I can see, it only applies if the cash is inert in a bank account not being loaned out.
- sjg007 8y agoLoan out is fine. The issue is that aggregate consumption and thus demand goes down. People decide not to take vacation etc... not buy the iPhone or not upgrade their car.. things like that. Lower demand means higher prices too.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> not being loaned out. The $64,000 Question is what is the money being loaned out for. If it's bidding up the price of stocks, bonds, and real estate then it takes a leap of faith to assume that will lead to actual productivity improvements.
- simonh 8y agoIt depends on the demand for investment. If there are loads of potentially successful companies starved for resources, more spending on stocks and loans could increase total returns linearly, or perhaps even more. If there’s a glut of money for investment, then that’s a different story.
- opportune 8y agoThis is solved by a well-functioning pension system (although that may also be an oxymoron/paradox of sorts)
- roenxi 8y agoThis paradox is caused by confusing numbers with reality. I have two major criticisms that the Wikipedia article does not list: 1) Firstly, the paradox assumes that maximising total output is an unmitigated good. This is clearly not so - imagine a world where everyone saved outrageously and pared down their lifestyle so much that we needed to move from a from 2 day standard weekend to a 3 day standard weekend. This would have "catastrophic" consequences economically because you lose 20% (1 day in 5) of your economic output, but now everyone has increased their leisure time by 50% (2 days to 3 days per weekend). This is not an objectively bad outcome. I mean, empirically most people don't choose it, but if most people did choose it is not like suffering increases. 2) Someone has defined it such that savings means spending on things that don't cause demand. I don't buy that, because to me "savings" would include, say, investing for retirement by building capital. Eg, maybe a massive great research and development lab for old-people-drugs. That is going to set me up for the future, so I call it savings, but if savings reduces output I assume to an economist it is classified as normal economic consumption.