3 ms·
> More people (and particularly more cattle) are fed per acre when you use pesticides. This feels like saying we absolutely need multiple GB of RAM to display
by xg15 8y ago
> More people (and particularly more cattle) are fed per acre when you use pesticides.
This feels like saying we absolutely need multiple GB of RAM to display a website because how else would Angular work otherwise?
If the increased yield per acre is used primarily to support todays industrial-scale meat production, maybe we should address the latter first. The way meat production works today seems to have almost exclusively downsides: It's a moral bankruptcy considering current state of research in animal consciousness, it's a health hazard for consumers, it's an inefficient way to consume proteins and as you note, it monopolizes vast parts of crop production.
- opportune 8y agoI agree we overconsume meat and that reducing meat consumption is one of the best ways to start addressing food/environmental issues, but to my knowledge the farmland producing feed or grazing material for livestock is not fungible in the sense that the land could just as easily be used to produce crops for human consumption. That is, you can’t just swap out corn/hay fields for rice and bean fields. I would love to be proven wrong though, it would help me rationalize further reducing my meat consumption
- candiodari 8y agoWe only have a few percent more food production than humanity needs, if I remember correctly. Roundup and other pesticides combined with fertilizer increased yields ... it doubles and triples them, and it prevents famines resulting from sudden insect plagues, which were common (as in every 30 years on average) for most of human history. If these numbers are even close to accurate, eliminating roundup and modern farming would kill BILLIONS of humans. I would love to get more accurate numbers, but what do you intend to do about the little "humans need food" issue in general ?
- heurist 8y agoAs i understand it, there are new intensive organic farming techniques that are practically unknown to big ag and which produce similar yields with higher quality (by not destroying soil and ecosystems every year). I'd counter that the final death toll of Roundup and similar chemicals could be much higher any potential famine caused by abrupt cessation of pesticide treatments. Destruction of ecosystems is an externality which has never been accounted for, and sooner or later someone will pay that bill.