11 ms·
In Soviet Union, Optimization Problem Solves You (2012)
- dang 8y agoDiscussed in 2015: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10679582 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10679582
- baursak 8y agoFor those more interested in this, there's a follow-up to comments, which results in this (still on-going?) exchange: - The original article (linked by OP): http://crookedtimber.org/2012/05/30/in-soviet-union-optimization-problem-solves-you/ http://crookedtimber.org/2012/05/30/in-soviet-union-optimiza... - A comment made by Paul Cockshott (a Marxist economist and computer scientist, most known for "Towards New Socialism" book): http://crookedtimber.org/2012/05/30/in-soviet-union-optimization-problem-solves-you/#comment-416201 http://crookedtimber.org/2012/05/30/in-soviet-union-optimiza... - Shalizi's response to Cockshott, among his other responses to other comments: http://bactra.org/weblog/919.html http://bactra.org/weblog/919.html - Cockshott's response to above: https://paulcockshott.wordpress.com/2018/06/25/plan-balancing-algorithms-reply-to-some-criticisms/ https://paulcockshott.wordpress.com/2018/06/25/plan-balancin...
- petermcneeley 8y agoCentral planning is the response to Von mises argument about economic calculation in socialist countries. https://wiki.mises.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem https://wiki.mises.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
- kingkawn 8y agoIf you link to the wikipedia article instead it actually discusses criticisms of Von Mises instead of simply supporting it without counter-argument: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem
- jayalpha 8y agoThe funny thing about Mises is: He understood socialism and its' problems much better than capitalism. He never understood capitalism but got stuck with his understanding in something reflecting a middle-ages barter economy.
- UncleEntity 8y agoCitation please?
- jayalpha 8y agoNo English citation available. But this English article implies basically the concept: https://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-02-12/limits-to-growth-at-our-doorstep-but-not-recognized/ https://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-02-12/limits-to-grow... "Unfortunately, the problem this appears eventually to lead to, is collapse. The problem is the connection with debt. Debt can be paid back with interest to a much greater extent in a growing economy than a contracting economy because we are effectively borrowing from the future–something that is a lot easier when tomorrow is assumed to be better than today, compared to when tomorrow is worse than today." Capitalism is a debt based economy, requiring to pre-finance industrial production. In the end, the debt pressure drives the whole process. Something Mises, who never worked in a company his whole life, fundamentally did not understand. He thinks you have to "save" to "invest" later.
- UncleEntity 8y ago> He thinks you have to "save" to "invest" later. Because that's the truth. You can't just produce "things" out of thin air so the idea that you can finance future production without (someone, somewhere) deferring present consumption is not really valid. All interest is is an incentive for people to defer present consumption for a higher level of future consumption. Unless, of course, you just print up a bunch of money and then you aren't exactly "borrowing from the future" but taking from the current holders of the currency through lower future consumption due to inflationary devaluation of the currency [--edit--] and also taking from the current holders of the currency by artificially driving up current prices. And that Robinson Crusoe bloke stuck on an island...
- averros 8y agoWhat von Mises has proven logically in 1920 (and the practical experience has confirmed it later over the course of 20th century - repeatedly, dozens of times, in different countries, with different cultures) is that a centrally planned (i.e. socialist) economy ALWAYS SELF-DESTRUCTS. It has nothing to do with computers and collection of information and planning algorithms. The issue (completely misunderstood by the author of the article discussed) is that the very fact of coercing people destroys information about their subjective utility functions which could only be gleaned by observing FREE exchange. No amount of fancy software or social engineering will fix it. Garbage in - garbage out. Socialism is a very bad idea. No ifs and no buts about it. And, yes, Marx was a kook. His entire economic and social theory is a humongous monument to the principle of logical explosion: if you start with nonsense (labor theory of value), you end up being able to derive anything from it. (The fact that labor theory of value is nonsense is easily established by observing "value" created by someone digging a hole and filling it in - any number of times, so as to put in arbitrarily large amount of labor).
- fouc 8y agoIt may not matter if you start from good first principles or bad ones. Deriving a system from logical reasoning seems to always fall short in reality. (At least for natural languages as opposed to something like mathematics).
- averros 8y agoGhm. Mathematics and sciences are rather successful in reality. Natural language can be used in a rather rigid and formal manner - and mathematical language can be used carelessly and in error. (In fact, using natural language carefully may be preferable to playing with formal symbols - as it makes gaffes and logical gaps more visible to the readers.)
- claudiawerner 8y agoNot to speak for or against Marx's law of value, >The fact that labor theory of value is nonsense is easily established by observing "value" created by someone digging a hole and filling it in - any number of times, so as to put in arbitrarily large amount of labor Is rubbish. In fact, if you read less than the first chapter of Capital Vol. 1, Marx specifically rebuts this argument on the third page, in which he restricts himself to 'socially useful' labour performed at the rate necessary to complete it. Not even anti-Marxists use this argument any more because it simply doesn't hold for Marx's theory, nor even Smith and Ricardo's. Mises himself doesn't use this argument.
- Animats 8y agoHe sets up his own straw man, and demolishes it. Big deal. If you really had to solve this problem, you'd need to divide it into sub-areas, like "clothing" and "heavy machine tools", and solve it hierarchically. The solution will be somewhat suboptimal but should come close. The trouble with a capitalist model is that it's a huge collection of feedbacks and delays, so it oscillates around some optimum. That's a basic result from control theory. Delay causes instability. The USSR's Gosplan had a monthly reporting cycle and a yearly planning cycle. That was pre-Internet and too slow to work. WalMart has a daily reporting cycle (probably faster now) and a weekly planning cycle, and runs a consumer economy bigger than the USSRs. Not that industrial optimization is the controlling issue today. That's a problem for when you don't have enough manufacturing capacity. We're past that.
- avivo 8y agoI think this frame of market capitalism as a set of feedbacks and delays is crucial. Though I expect that there will just be different ones with alternative systems in practice.
- petre 8y agoThe reporting was mostly BS or too late or they tried to adjust reality to meet their quotas. They doctored the numebrs to look good. When only the state has a stake in all of companies and everybody is an employee of the state, there is zero interest for things to work out the way they were intended to. And this is why capitalism works better practice: because it encourages individual enterprise while it also encourages cooperation amongst individuals when things get rough. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandora%27s_Box_(TV_series)#Part_1._'The_Engineers'_Plot' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandora%27s_Box_(TV_series)#Pa...
- 7sidedmarble 8y ago>When only the state has a stake in all of companies and everybody is an employee of the state, there is zero interest for things to work out the way they were intended to. This can easily be rephrased to: "when all the major politicians have stakes in all the major companies, there is zero interest for things to work out the way they were intended to." And now there's no actual argument to what you're saying. Both systems have flaws. That does not prove one's better, you need more then that. Seeing the flaws is the first step to asking yourself the question, "is there a better way to do this?" Do you think we're better off because our corporate funded politicians have all the power, and we're just living in their fiefs? Is that the sign of a good system? Capitalism uses minor successes in it's lower classes like bread and circuses. They're distractions. Don't say to yourself, "at least I'm not starving in some South American country", ask yourself "why can't we all be doing better?" Is this system really the best mankind can do?
- rileyphone 8y agoWhat the author fails to address is the most recent research into the planned economy that Towards a New Socialism advocates. It advocates for an economy that is still socialist in nature (in seeking to eradicate the commodity form) while still aggregating opinion into production as market forces do. This is accomplished by using a labor token while using market forces to influence prices and planning. Sure, it can't be optimised perfectly, but neither can our current one, and that is never the goal of a socialist economy anyways.
- davidgould 8y agoI'll add that the book Red Plenty is entertaining and thought provoking and quite fun to read. The historical and cultural scenes depicted are interesting as well however you feel about the case for central planning.
- js8 8y agoIt seems to me, contrary to what is often claimed, the problem of central planned economies (not just state-wide ones, but also company-wide ones) is too much optimization at the expense of robustness. In top-down planned systems, there is always somebody who says something like "we only need this one thing for everybody". For example, in communist Czechoslovakia, there was only one factory designated to produce certain electronic chips. But then everybody becomes dependent on that one factory, and if that one factory slips in schedule, everything that depends on it will slip. There is a fundamental trade-off to be made. You can have an efficient system but it's robustness (ability to withstand a failure or adapt to change) will be very low. But the planners are often willing to take risk of being less robust for the sake of efficiency, because it usually gives you a free promotion in human status hierarchies. (If you ever worked in a large company, I am sure you can recognize the above effect, somebody hyper-optimizing through a mandate, and it has 2nd order effects in decrease of efficiency.) Compare that with market economy, which actually has huge overabundance of production capacity, and multiple producers of almost everything. This is less efficient but works really well in practice. (However, it has the other kind of problem; there is no way the free market can recognize that there is too much companies, without the agony of "malthusian" overcrowding and associated nasty effects such as more stress for everybody. Things like bullshit jobs are probably an end result.)
- eesmith 8y ago"too much optimization at the expense of robustness" That is not unique to central planned economies. Consider how the 2011 Thailand floods lead to a global shortage of hard disk drives, or the saline solution shortage in the US when the plants in Puerto Rico were damaged by Hurricane Maria. I think the author expressed it clearly that the planning algorithms depend on linear programming, and that non-linear effects - and I believe 'robustness' counts as such - are beyond what can even hope to achieve. The author also points out: > If it’s any consolation, allowing non-convexity messes up the markets-are-always-optimal theorems of neo-classical/bourgeois economics, too. (This illustrates Stiglitz’s contention that if the neo-classicals were right about how capitalism works, Kantorovich-style socialism would have been perfectly viable.) Hence why capitalist systems may also have robustness problems. "You can have an efficient system but it's robustness (ability to withstand a failure or adapt to change) will be very low." I think that's an observation in how centralized systems are implemented. I don't see why robustness can't, at least in theory, be included as part of the optimization process. Beyond the factors highlighted in the essay, of course, like the inability to decide how to weight those factors, and the non-convexity.
- peisistratos 8y agoIn the three decades Stalin was general secretary, the Soviet Union had enormous economic growth. Russia went from being a backward peasant country ruled by a czar, to being the first country to send a satellite to space. Its success and its example were what was feared. While unemployment was 25% in the US in 1933, the USSR was charging forward, and US and European firms and workers were going there to work. On Stalin's death, Khrushchev announced economic growth was no longer a priority, and other such policies, and stagnation set in. China also had enormous economic development under the communist party from 1949 to 1978, and from 1978 to now (although the party took a right turn under Deng Xiaoping in 1978, to where some question if China was socialist after then). The average inflation-adjusted hourly wage in the US is below what it was 45 years ago, leading to anti free trade Trump and Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio Cortez. Also Corbyn, Syriza, Brexit, ping-pong from Lula to Bolsonaro, TARP bank bailouts plus the carbon externalities destroying the planet. Of course, I don't think a traditional Marxist worldwide communist revolution of factory workers led by Leninist parties will happen. The present economic system might be eradicated though. It has not been all that long since European kings were having their heads chopped off or were being bayoneted to death in basements.
- averros 8y agoOf course, the Stalinist "economic growth" was built on the bones of millions forced into slavery. Do you really consider this kind of growth desirable or sustainable?
- claudiawerner 8y agoNot to excuse the brutalities of the Stalinist regime, but isn't our own economic growth built today on almost intolerable conditions in sweatshops, child labour and qualitatively bad ways of living life in various parts of the world and even closer to home?
- v_lisivka 8y agoNo. :-/ Can you provide examples of recent innovation, which was performed using child labor and caused significant growth of economy?
- atemerev 8y agoFor me, the principal problem of central planning is that you cannot plan for innovation. Innovation works best in competitive capitalistic environments, where there is a significant prize awaiting innovators.
- claudiawerner 8y agoHaven't there been many innovators and scientists who come from the most unlikely walks of life, and die penniless? Did Einstein, for instance, not have to divide his time between work at the patent office and groundbreaking research?
- v_lisivka 8y agoYou should compare number of implemented innovations and market disruptions instead.
- baursak 8y ago> Innovation works best in competitive capitalistic environments Well, a huge chunk of innovation in capitalist countries happen on university campuses or within government funded organizations like DARPA or NASA, or within communist-like arrangements like Open Source (Linux, Apache, etc). Which are then appropriated by private interests to be monetized.
- SII_of_SII 8y agoOne thing I got out of the article is that an alternate-reality communist economy can be more efficient than a capitalist economy, given a good objective function. The way to do it is to simulate a market economy on your central-planning computer: Simulate a network where each node models a consumer or supply chain unit. This runs the same computation as a market economy, but propagates price signals much faster. It's faster and cheaper to do an RDMA access than to wander around a grocery store comparing the price of bread to rice. The trouble is in formulating a good objective function. Perhaps you can solve the problem of consumers expressing preferences that Cosma discusses in "The Given Assortment, and Planner's Preferences" by imitating a market economy. Each person receives a fixed salary which they spend at state stores. Since this is how the computation performed by a market inputs consumer preferences, this is the input used by the central computer in its market simulation. But the simulation reaches equilibrium much faster than the real market and its objective function is more fair than a real market (since everyone gets the same salary). I suppose there are bigger problems with formulating the objective function than consumer preferences. Creative kinds of economic activity are important and leaders that want to hold control may not allow you to formulate the objective even if you could.
- leghifla 8y ago"I suppose there are bigger problems with formulating the objective function than consumer preferences." Maybe producer preferences? The fact that one prefers to be a mechanic or a nurse does not influence the planning algorithm (AFAIK): people are just pawns on a chess board, like any other resources.
- guiriduro 8y agoIs that necessarily so? You could argue that producer preferences are some kind of soft constraint that can be maximised (albeit subsidiary to the hard constraint solution)
- leghifla 8y agoMaybe, but I struggle to find a way to express preferences without information about price. And it will add a few hundred million more variables into the optimization problem.
- ASipos 8y agoAlso, Scott Alexander on Red Plenty: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/24/book-review-red-plenty/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/24/book-review-red-plenty/
- 7sidedmarble 8y agoStopped reading at: >In certain cases, Russians were very well-incentivized by things like “We will kill you unless you meet the production target”. Come on. Outside of POWs during the war (and that's not what were talking about) no factory workers are getting dragged out back and shot. The story of collectivization on farms is more complicated but it still didn't involve on the spot murder. It's like people watched that movie where the Russians are at stalingrad, and the commisar gives every two men a rifle and shouts "first man shoots the rifle, if the first man dies, the second man picks up and shoots the rifle." -- And then everyone collectively thought "oh, not only is this true but this absolves me of any responsibility to actually learn about the USSR." Read some books, talk to some older Russians. There was some extremely dark times in the history of the USSR. But for a lot of it's history, it was just a normal western-ish country. It wasn't like war time Nazi Germany 24/7. You weren't getting shot for not making enough hinges one day.
- Fins 8y agoUmm, have you ever lived in USSR? Being born in the 80's doesn't count either. There absolutely were times when being a few minutes late to work (not during the war either) would get you a long prison sentence at the very least. Also, it never were "a normal western-sh country". Russia hasn't been, and USSR in toto had no reasons to be either. Works of marxist "economists" shouldn't even be dignified with a discussion, but is is greatly concerning that there is such a thing as whitewashing of the soviet regime, and that it is considered to be far more acceptable that whitewashing nazis.
- unknownkadath 8y agoSo if P=NP, Communism will triumph?
- julienreszka 8y agoNo. There will be a definite proof of it's failure.