3 ms·
Not totalitarian (neither of us is in a position of power over the other, and neither of us is advocating for government intervention), and not concocted (these
by woodruffw 8y ago
Not totalitarian (neither of us is in a position of power over the other, and neither of us is advocating for government intervention), and not concocted (these questions belong to a long tradition in Western political thought). If by "conditioned" you mean that public sentiments are changing, sure. But I don't think that demands such a negative description.
The company town case is interesting, but it's just a case. I don't buy that (1) it's sufficiently similarl to the challenges of hate speech on private online venues, or (2) that it constitutes a sufficient body of jurisprudence to make the general subject "historical fact."
Speaking of historical fact: it is not historical fact that the First Amendment was "originally widely recognized by US jurisprudence." In fact, the free expression clauses of the First Amendment barely showed up in America's highest courts until the turn of the 20th century[1]. The first FA case with any modern significance is Eugene v. United States, in 1919.
To be clear: the fact that something's been around for longer than another thing is not a good argument, in my book, for its value. But, in this case, it isn't even factual: both US common law and the judicial canon reflect a far greater emphasis on property rights (and, tangentially, the fleshing out of the federal system) than they do free expression.
[1]: https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/page/first-amendment-timeline https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/page/first-amendment-timeli...
- woodruffw 8y agoPer those two points I made above, I want to address some of the claims made in that video: 1. It's immediately apparent that nobody lives on Facebook, in any literal sense. The host's comparison of Chickasaw and Facebook rests on the implicit assumption that there's something equivalent between being denied free expression in the town you live in (where all your belongings are, &c) and being denied a Facebook account. This doesn't ring true to me -- it's clearly far more serious to be denied free expression in one's semipermanent (real-life!) community than it is on a Facebook server. 2. As the host notes, this case is not active law. More generally, there are some telling omissions in the host's story: company towns and private roads didn't spring out of a pure market, they were subsidized by a roaring post-war defense economy that was being fueled by federal dollars. That fact was undoubtedly bouncing around in the minds of the justices who decided this case.