5 ms·
If I start a company that allows users to upload content over the internet, is it your contention that I should not be within my rights to control what is store
by sanderjd 8y ago
If I start a company that allows users to upload content over the internet, is it your contention that I should not be within my rights to control what is stored and who is allowed to use my services?
- stcredzero 8y agoYou wind up in a monopoly, or a near-monopoly position, and you can practically suppress the free speech of people, then yes. There is a lawsuit where a company owned this mining company town, including all of its roads and sidewalks. A Jehova's witness won a lawsuit on the basis of the First Amendment, enabling her to walk about that town and distribute her pamphlets. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBozijndSLc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBozijndSLc Originally, it was widely recognized by US jurisprudence, though property rights and freedom of association are important, the First Amendment was even more important.
- geeostation 8y agowhy is this downvoted? seems very good counterpoint to private companies can do whatever they want. The reality of the free speech online is that US constitution comes stapled with a "Terms of Service" by tech oligopoly
- sanderjd 8y agoI see a tag that says "dupe" on the comment, so maybe that's why. I did see that anecdote about the company town elsewhere in the thread.