10 ms·
> Most successful deplatformings are Pyrrhic victories We have reasonable (not perfect!) empirical evidence that this is not the case[1]. It appears that toxic
by woodruffw 8y ago
> Most successful deplatformings are Pyrrhic victories
We have reasonable (not perfect!) empirical evidence that this is not the case[1]. It appears that toxic and hateful movements can only resist disapprobation when they develop a sufficiently large, sufficiently public (in the visibility sense, not the publicly-owned sense) channel. Continually disrupting those channels works.
[1]: http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf
- stcredzero 8y agoFor awhile, the Soviets could "deplatform" people from their lives entirely by threatening them or sending them to the Gulags. They held things together for many decades through that continual disruption. Yes, you can coerce people with your advantages, and it will work for awhile. You can even create enclaves where you can keep undesirables out. But no, that never wins in the end.
- woodruffw 8y ago> For awhile, the Soviets could "deplatform" people from their lives entirely by threatening them or sending them to the Gulags. They held things together for many decades through that continual disruption. I take the scarequotes there to be you admitting that gulags aren't really deplatforming -- it's a government terrorizing its citizens. Nobody in this conversation is interested in building gulags or putting the undesirables in them. > Yes, you can coerce people with your advantages, and it will work for awhile. You can even create enclaves where you can keep undesirables out. But no, that never wins in the end. I don't understand this reasoning. I've presented some research indicating that banning hateful online communities actually does have some kind of positive effect, and your response it that it "never wins in the end"? What is the "end" here? Do we have any sort of evidence or overarching political theory that suggests that it doesn't win in the end? Most of us are on board, intuitively at least, with the notion that you can't have both a dictator and be a democratic republic. Why are we so hesitant to accept that other entities fundamentally conflict with the notion of liberal democracy?
- stcredzero 8y agoI've presented some research indicating that banning hateful online communities actually does have some kind of positive effect I'm sure that you can find a Soviet study indicating that certain of their programs had an effect against Bourgeois oppressor thinking and activity for some number of years. Why are we so hesitant to accept that other entities fundamentally conflict with the notion of liberal democracy? Conditioning a society to accept the practically suppression of free speech fundamentally conflicts with the notion of liberal democracy.
- woodruffw 8y ago> I'm sure that you can find a Soviet study indicating that certain of their programs had an effect against Bourgeois oppressor thinking and activity for some number of years. Again, no gulags here. Just Twitter, Reddit, and bad clones of the aforementioned. It's also worth noting that the Soviet Union, at its best, simply was not a liberal democracy. The position that I'm taking is nonsensical outside of a liberal democratic context, so comparing it with various inhumanities under a non-democracy is unconvincing at best. > Conditioning a society to accept the practically suppression of free speech fundamentally conflicts with the notion of liberal democracy. We're talking about the scope and structure of liberal democracy itself, a discussion that's been going on for as long as liberal democracies have existed (others have brought up Popper, but Popper cribbed the idea from Immanuel Kant). There's no conditioning going on.
- stcredzero 8y agoThere's no conditioning going on. The general population that grew up online in web forums is very much conditioned to accept totalitarian dictates about who can say what, where. Even to the point where they concoct ideology about it. a discussion that's been going on for as long as liberal democracies have existed The US government coming in and telling a private entity, no you must tolerate free speech on your property is historical fact and precedent. There is a lawsuit where a company owned this mining company town, including all of its roads and sidewalks. A Jehova's witness won a lawsuit on the basis of the First Amendment, enabling her to walk about that town and distribute her pamphlets. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBozijndSLc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBozijndSLc Originally, it was widely recognized by US jurisprudence, though property rights and freedom of association are important, the First Amendment was even more important.
- CamperBob2 8y agoBecause being banned from Twitter is totally like being sent to a gulag.
- stcredzero 8y agoGranted, I'd rather you only take my speech than my physical freedom and my life. However, if society starts taking away practical freedom of speech, who is going to speak up? Why wouldn't the big companies and the government just pressure Google and Facebook to get everyone to shut up about it? This is why freedom of speech is foundational.
- MrLeap 8y agoI appreciate the fight you're fighting, friend. Free speech has become inconvenient, so long live the tyranny of the feudal corporation apparently? It's pretty gross.
- wetpaws 8y agoWhen people say toxic, it usually always a synonim for "things I don't like"
- claudiawerner 8y agoI've usually seen it as a synonym for disruptive, hostile and rude communication in a generally bad mindset; this is the impression I get when it's used to describe gaming communities for various popular games (in particular LoL and Overwatch).
- int_19h 8y agoIt didn't work in Europe. Just look at AfD. That in a country that goes so far in suppressing "toxic and hateful movements", its courts have the power to ban political parties, if their platform deviates too far from the norm.
- 8note 8y agoI think Germany would be significantly more NAZI today if they hadn't been deplatformed after the war. not deplatforming didn't go too well in the US. look at all the white power folks who are showing up, even though they kept their platforms after the civil war.
- guitarbill 8y agoThe point he's making is it might be better to talk about it, instead of declaring it taboo. AfD is literally "Alternative für Deutschland". They aren't great, but enough people are voting for them because the other parties won't tackle thr issues they care about. As for "all the white power folks", they may be loud and they may be a convenient boogeyman, but how many are there really? And isn't it better to know they exist, than have such speech stifled, only to have it surprise you e.g. at the next election? (Talking about the AfD here, before you draw too many parallels)
- int_19h 8y agoMy point is that all the deplatforming that Germany does - which is extreme for a democracy - was still not enough to actually prevent parties like AfD. Everybody knows what they stand for, but in a free society, you can't imprison people for wink-wink-nudge-nudge. For political censorship to be actually effective, it must be much more oppressive - of the kind seen in authoritarian countries. But then, of course, if you implement it, you end up living in one. And if you don't, then what's there is just security theater.