3 ms·
Gab illustrates a “catch-22” around setting out to be specifically a “free speech platform”. You initially appeal to the most fringe elements of public discours
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Gab illustrates a “catch-22” around setting out to be specifically a “free speech platform”. You initially appeal to the most fringe elements of public discourse. Your first wave of users are going to be people for whom this has been a problem, and if you’re an absolutist and let them on then suddenly that’s your base.
For me, this is one of the more profound take-aways from the article. This piece is very thought provoking.
- stcredzero 8y agoThe forums for Free Speech in the 60's also came with a lot of what was thought of as perverted toxic nonsense. Some of that is still thought of as unacceptable today.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThere are some very real problems where oppressed people of various sorts have a real need to be able to "speak the unspeakable" in order to sort their own problems. New ideas are also inevitable heretical. Sorting the wheat from the chaff is a challenge. Trying to not throw the baby out with the bathwater is a challenge.
- stcredzero 8y agooppressed people of various sorts have a real need to be able to "speak the unspeakable" There's a difference between letting people express themselves and ratifying hate to fuel more outrage. Doing that is throwing the justice baby out with the bathwater -- also because it's more viral and you make more money and get more political power that way.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm aware. I also know that if you are the oppressed person, it can be hard to sort such things out. It can be hard to figure what is legitimate and righteous anger that is nonetheless Verboten to express and what is merely outrage fuel. It can be hard to find your own voice. It is necessary to have a little latitude when trying to do so. It gets vastly more complicated when you are trying to do that in some kind of group setting. It easily goes bad places.
- stcredzero 8y agoI also know that if you are the oppressed person, it can be hard to sort such things out As a person of color, who has also been the victim of other sorts of impropriety, let me say this: If you want the best and most productive life, you want to get over hate sooner than later. Much sooner. It can be hard to find your own voice. It is necessary to have a little latitude when trying to do so. There is a world of difference between letting people have their moment of realization and righteous anger versus fanning the flames of anger to achieve virality to gain more followers, more money, and more power. I think people can decide for themselves how far down that spectrum various people and movements have gone. It must be called out, as much for the sake of victims as everyone else. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc If you are in the space of anger and hate, then you are not in the space of justice. Anger should just be a waypoint to something greater. Those who tell you otherwise just want to keep you in the space of hate to exploit you.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- guitarbill 8y ago> There's a difference between letting people express themselves and ratifying hate to fuel more outrage Maybe, but then somebody has to make that call and get it right. Who's going to do that? You? The mob? Giving all ideas the same platform and letting it sort itself out isn't the worst strategy humanity has come up with. You might even call it democratic. And I don't remember refusing to judge something being the same as ratifying it, I thought that was tolerance. But I guess you're either with us, or against us - there can be no other option. /s If letting a few people talk about hate is magically going to convince a large majority, either that's condescending or we're fucked as a species.
- teddyh 8y agoYes, the first wave defines the project; if the first wave has problems, the project is infused with these problems. This is true of free software projects also. I have a couple of examples: • The KDE project (to create a nice graphical desktop environment based on the X windowing system) was initially formed around using the Qt library for graphical user interface widgets. The Qt library had, at the time, a somewhat friendly but distinctly non-free license. The first wave of developers on KDE, therefore, were developers who considered proprietary software and/or sketchy licensed to be A-OK.¹ This will probably forever define the development practices of the KDE project. • The Go language is, by many accounts, a very nice programming language. But it was started, and still run, by Google people, for Google purposes, and with Google backing. This means that the first wave of developers were and are those developers who think it’s perfectly fine to work at Google, or to work with Google to further Google’s goals. People who don’t like Google will of course have stayed away from the Go project at the outset, and so the developer elite of the Go project will probably always reflect Google values and priorities. 1. Those developers who did not agree went on to start Gnome, which is in fact the very reason Gnome was started.
- oever 8y agoYou use your hypothesis to prove your point. So you prove nothing. The KDE project is very focused on software freedom and does not consider proprietary software A-OK. This is written in the https://manifesto.kde.org/ https://manifesto.kde.org/
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYeah, that's obvious on the face of it and not what grabbed me. I'm fascinated by the power of positioning of the creators of the project and how easily that can go wrong. That has long fascinated me and this is an incredibly powerful example summed up in a nutshell in the paragraph I quoted, which is a rare thing to see.