4 ms·
> has similar impacts and risks to the government imposing similar restrictions through the law We can't really compare them to the government until they have
by roenxi 8y ago
> has similar impacts and risks to the government imposing similar restrictions through the law
We can't really compare them to the government until they have a standing army. That said, pure scale does matter. There will debate over whether powerful organisations are currently benign or hostile, but there is no doubt whatsoever that they are a mighty force.
If Google or Facebook ever decides to seriously wake up politically, China's internet strategies will start looking very sensible. I don't agree with them either though.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> We can't really compare them to the government until they have a standing army. While I disagree that the firms in question have government-like comprehensive power, even without their own army, a monopoly or coordinating oligopoly able to lock out new participants on essential communication services would have such power, and be a de facto part of the government, even if they lacked formal command relationship over the armed forces of the host state.
- stcredzero 8y agoThere is a lawsuit where a company owned this mining company town, including all of its roads and sidewalks. A Jehovah's witness won a lawsuit on the basis of the First Amendment, enabling her to walk about that town and distribute her pamphlets. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBozijndSLc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBozijndSLc Originally, it was widely recognized by US jurisprudence, though property rights and freedom of association are important, the First Amendment was even more important.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> There is a lawsuit where a company owned this mining company town, including all of its roads and sidewalks And when a single company has similar control over the internet, even for a particular group of people such that they are otherwise unreachable (as AT&T once did nationalky over telephone communications), Marsh v. Alabama might be relevant (It might not, since active relaying is not the same of not denying access to property, and is itself an issue of the first amendment rights of the party who would be compelled to relay the speech.) That's not the case now, and the Marsh v. Alabama doctrine does not compel internet companies to relay content they don't want to, see Cyber Promotions v. America Online. > Originally, it was widely recognized by US jurisprudence, though property rights and freedom of association are important, the First Amendment was even more important. The issue with regard to relaying is neither a free association nor a property issue, but a free speech/press issue—whether the state can compel a party to actively participate in relaying ideas that they do not wish to participate in.
- stcredzero 8y agoThe distinction between "actively relaying" and allowing through in 2018 is now as empty and outdated as the idea that property rights extended up into the sky, so farmers could charge airplanes for passage. The purpose of such a distinction is simply for people with power to regulate discourse.
- oh_sigh 8y ago> And when a single company has similar control over the internet, even for a particular group of people such that they are otherwise unreachable ICANN?
- dragonwriter 8y agoSure, you'd at least have a debatable case of a First Amendment issue under the Marsh v. Alabama precedent if the federal or a state government was enforcing a content-based deplatforming effort by ICANN. But that's not at all the actual present issue.
- colllectorof 8y ago>We can't really compare them to the government until they have a standing army. In Soviet Union families of political prisoners and people who publicly defended the repressed often found themselves unemployable because of blacklisting. That did not involve any use of military or police force. Does it make it okay? To put it more directly: if a sufficiently large entity can create effects comparable to government repression, why should we reason about those effects as fundamentally different from ones created by the government?
- 8note 8y agoThe US does that too; it's called sanctions, and secondary sanctions.