9 ms·
Despite concerns, FDA approves new opioid 10x more powerful than Fentanyl
- d--b 8y agoI don't understand, the article states the distribution is very controlled and geared towards the military. The problem with Fentanyl is its widespread prescription by family doctors. If the US doesn't allow its distribution through mainstream channels, it's no big deal. I'm pretty sure that stuff is weaker than morphine, yet morphine is quite available in hospitals... EDIT: ah, apparently it's quite stronger than morphine. The argument still holds. Hospitals do have stronger stuff :)
- arebop 8y agoFentanyl is much stronger the morphine, so if this is 10x stronger than Fentanyl then it is also much stronger than morphine.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoYeah, but what does "strong" mean in this context? If it means you can get the same effect with 1/10th the dose, then you just put 1/10th as much active ingredient in each pill and nothing effectively changes. There's some discussion at the top of the thread that suggests it's more complicated than that, and may make it either more or less dangerous, depending.
- DanBC 8y agoThe other problem with fentanyl is that it is much "stronger" than morphine, and much easier to smuggle into the US. It was until recently legal to produce it in China. This means heroin dealers were buying fentanyl and cutting it with sugars. If they correctly cut it - dilute it - it's bad, but not as bad as when they incorrectly cut it and release product that is too strong. This is one of the reasons fentanyl is killing so many Americans.
- ogn3rd 8y agowtf!
- olliej 8y agoWhat could go wrong? I think a solution to a lot of this would simply be to make the manufacturers of such be responsible for the costs of getting people off them. And the cleanup costs for cities that have to deal with the results.
- Zelphyr 8y agoIs the FDA stacked with industry insiders like the FCC? Is that what's going on here? Or does the DoD have that much influence?
- chelmzy 8y agoWhy would the DoD have a hand in this?
- 0d311 8y agoIn the article, they discuss a few times how a consideration for this drug is servicemen in the field.
- User23 8y agoOf course it is. Regulatory capture is a real thing. While the courts are far from perfect, judges don't routinely "retire" to take multi-million dollar positions with the companies they rule on the way that regulators do.
- etrevino 8y agoThe DoD does have that much influence. If they want it, they'll get it. And if they can't get it through normal channels they'll bend over backwards to try to get Congress to carve out an exception.
- droithomme 8y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- esotericn 8y agoThis article seems pretty low on detail. Almost all of it seems to be talking about, well, not the drug in question. What, exactly, does "10x more powerful" mean? Potency? Presumably it'd then be prescribed in lower doses?
- 13of40 8y agoOne hundredth the size of a grain of salt vs. one tenth for fentanyl? Imagine if a piece of dust from that blew into your eye.
- maverick2007 8y agoThis is probably a stupid question but is it possible for this or for any drug to be absorbed and take effect via the eye? Or does it have to get into the circulatory/digestive system to take effect?
- sb8244 8y agoOne of the classic LSD stereotypes is eye drop. Here's a Reddit thread with the question https://www.reddit.com/r/LSD/comments/5aqp8s/lsd_drops_in_eye/ https://www.reddit.com/r/LSD/comments/5aqp8s/lsd_drops_in_ey...
- mveety 8y agoNo question is stupid! For fentanyl at least that can totally happen. On of the common ways to administer it is via a transdermal patch. It’s one of the major selling points of fentanyl and why people that need ridiculous amounts of opioids because of burns or cancer like it.
- ddingus 8y ago>No question is stupid! Hear, hear! Especially in this context. I have a modest understanding of just a couple of these compounds. And that comes by way of chronic pain people in my life. Over time, doing the work to better undestand these things has paid off. They, at times, get contradictory or just bad advice, or see something that makes them worry, or think they are in danger somehow. It can be hard to get clarity, and know a change is thearaputic vs compliance related, for example. Anyway, I just liked that you said that and followed up with super easy to understand information.
- madengr 8y agoCarfentanil is already 10x as powerful as this stuff, and manufactured by the drum load in China.
- whoisjuan 8y agoThis dissipates any doubt I had about the influence of lobbying. FDA, a federal agency that is fully aware of the harmful and addictive nature of opioids (and its impact on the public health system) approves one of the most powerful opioids ever, disregarding the fact that its unique advantage is the fact that this is a non-intravenous administered opioid... Ohh, and the argument for approving is basically that they believe is good to have more alternatives to existing opioids. Really? Like is not fentanyl strong enough to address every possible medical use case for a powerful opioid?
- chimeracoder 8y ago> This dissipates any doubt I had about the influence of lobbying. Who are you accusing of lobbying here? It's pretty clear from the article that the primary advocate for this drug is the military (DoD). > Like is not fentanyl strong enough to address every possible medical use case for a powerful opioid? Strength is not something that's assessed along a one-dimensional axis, much as popular reporting on opiates and pharmaceuticals would have you believe.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- whoisjuan 8y ago> Who are you accusing of lobbying here? AcelRx, the pharmaceutical company that produces and distributes DSUVIA. You understand how lobbying works right? Even if the Department of Defense is advocating for the use of a drug, they don't have any input on the safety of whatever they are advocating for. This is the role of the FDA. AcelRx happens to have something that the DoD wants so they lobby for its approval. In this case, DoD, FDA, and AcelRX are all different parties but is clear that AcelRX is the only party that will benefit financially from this. Just from an anectodical perspective, so you can understand how this works, check ACRX stock closing price today. It closed 16% up today. Just because the DoD is advocating for this drug, that doesn't mean that there's no pharmaceutical lobbying behind this. By that logic then all defense contractors and weapon manufacturers wouldn't have to lobby as much as they do.
- cperciva 8y agoThe supply of Fentanyl on the streets is not coming from FDA licensed manufacturers anyway.
- onemoresoop 8y agoYes but the doctor prescribes it first. When addicted, and the doctor doesn't want to prescribe it anymore, the street becomes the supplier. Most likely some politician or lobbyist out there is gaining on this whole chain of supply and demand, how else would a stronger drug get approved in the light of the opioid crisis we already can't handle.
- leetcrew 8y ago> Yes but the doctor prescribes it first. fentanyl sold on the street is generally not diverted from prescriptions. fentanyl that you can actually take home tends to come in something like a patch where the drug is suspended at very low concentrations in a gel. illicit fentanyl sold at scale usually comes from illicit labs overseas. > how else would a stronger drug get approved in the light of the opioid crisis we already can't handle in this context, "stronger" simply means more potent by weight. you shouldn't assume that more potent opiates are more addictive; fentanyl is not the drug of choice for most opiate addicts.
- whoisjuan 8y agoThat's not true. Fentanyl gets stolen in medical facilities all the time. There were some pharmacists in Canada some years ago that were stealing the fentanyl themselves and reporting they were being robbed. Of course that was a stupid scheme and they got caught.
- valarauca1 8y agoIf you are interested in learning more the general name for this drug (outside of the US) is ARX-04. The maker has some data that compares it to Fentanyl [1]. Their numbering states that is closer to 100x, and crosses the blood brain barrier in around 6 minutes. [1] http://www.acelrx.com/technology/publications/arx-04/MHSRS%20ProjTeamPresentation%202016%20FINAL%2008_10_16%20MRC-0076.pdf http://www.acelrx.com/technology/publications/arx-04/MHSRS%2... here
- trhway 8y agoanother 100x fentanyl - carfentanyl as gas/aerosol was used by the SWAT team in the 2002 Moscow hostage crisis. 100+ people died from it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_hostage_crisis_chemical_agent#Opioid_version https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_hostage_crisis_chemical...
- vilhelm_s 8y agoInteresting. I'm a bit confused about slide 6, which says that it has a theraputic index which is 100 times better than fentanyl. It cites the reference [1], which indeed has those numbers in it, but the full table there is: ED50 LD50 Theaputic Index Fentanyl 0.01 3.1 277 Sufentanil 0.007 18 26716 The therapeutic index is the ratio of LD50:ED50. This clearly makes no sense, someone must have moved a decimal point, and got a number which is wrong by a factor 10. EDIT: Ok, it seems that it is indeed an error in the cited paper, but the typo is for the ED50 number. In the original source[2] it's given as 0.00071, which agrees with the "10 times stronger than fentanyl" claim in the original article, and gives the correct theraputic index. [1] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1440-1681.1995.tb01945.x https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1440-1681.... [2] https://twitter.com/davidjuurlink/status/859227636400349184?lang=en https://twitter.com/davidjuurlink/status/859227636400349184?...
- post_break 8y agoAll the negativity aside, my mom had a very aggressive cancer. Found in October, she passed in May. She was getting doses of fentanyl and it was the only thing numbing the chronic pain. I'm pretty sure it was a patch like a bandaid. That said I'm glad it was available because she would have suffered even more without it.
- josephv 8y agoFor those of us that have had to use opioids for cancer treatment to the point of being addicted, then kicked the habit after treatment, all of the asinine demonization of opioids is absolutely infuriating. I used ate percs like candy during treatment and rehab, then used fentanyl patches to wean off. It was hard, like really hard, but life is hard. It's not worth it to try and convince anyone that hasn't knocked on deaths door that sometimes you need palliative care in the form of narcotics to make it to your destination, recovery or otherwise. I'm sorry about your mother, she wasn't bad for using fentanyl or anything else. She did great things with her life, you're proof. Don't let the stupid media or internet SJWs try influence you. After my ordeal I haven't watched TV or the news in years and am much happier for it. Family, work, and video games (or hobby of choice) is all a person needs IMO.
- brandonmenc 8y agoI wish I could upvote this more. People demonizing these drugs have obviously never known anyone living with severe, chronic pain.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- conductr 8y agoI agree with this. FDA approval shouldn’t be the issue since it’s safe when administered correctly and has medical purposes. Controlling distribution should be the issue. There almost needs to by a super controlled substance drug class
- 8y ago
- microcolonel 8y agoBefore you rage against this; fentanyl has been an immense asset to medicine, and when dosed correctly it offers much more manageable side effects (and greater control) than many other opioids. Just because the drug is more potent per microgram, that doesn't mean there's some sort of moral failing involved in bringing it to market. When you're in immense pain, and the only safe way to relieve that for you is some potent opioid, I guarantee you will thank people for bringing these things to market.
- sweetcherrypie 8y agoNaloxone is the drug used to block the effects of opioids. LE carry them, but at the cost of $4500 for two injectors. The Narcan spray is slightly lest costly iirc. I'm a uni student working on designing an auto-injector that could be used instead (the medicine itself is very cheap) and potentially to administer epinepherine too (also a case of cheap medicine - expensive administration device). I've made some progress but have no mechanical design experience. I'm not optimistic about the time period needed for FDA approval so I'm really doing it for the learning experience. I'd love some help!
- weisser 8y agoInteresting. My email is in my profile.
- CodeWriter23 8y agoMy suggestion, keep a journal about the process you go through (design, manufacture, ip, regulatory) and publish that when you’re done. This whole area of portable medical devices is in serious need of disruption. Knowledgeable people should be able to enter into this area. Check out the insulin pump hackers if you haven’t already to get a peek at what is possible.
- mv 8y agoIt is absolutely criminal that a <$20 drug can be sold for $4500... Auto-injectors have been a solved problem for decades, and there is nothing special about naloxone vs any other drug. Treating auto-injecting tech as different for each drug only helps drive up prices and keep out competition by making FDA approval very expensive. I hope you are successful getting a generic auto-injector approved, but I don't think your biggest hurdle will be design or engineering. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp1609578 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp1609578
- DanBC 8y ago> Auto-injectors have been a solved problem for decades, And yet we still have stuff like this: https://www.judiciary.uk/publications/natasha-ednan-laperouse/ https://www.judiciary.uk/publications/natasha-ednan-laperous... >(3) In the Emergency treatment of anaphylactic reactions Guidelines for healthcare providers the preferred needle length is 25 mm for adrenaline injectors to access muscle in most people. I heard during expert evidence that Epipen needle length was 16mm - suitable according to the UK Resuscitation Council for “pre-term or very small infants”. The use of needles which access only subcutaneous tissue and not muscle is in my view inherently unsafe. An alternative autoinjector, Emerade has a 24 mm needle. >(4) The dose of adrenaline in Epipen is 300mcg. The UK Resuscitation Council recommends a standard emergency dose of 500mcg. Emerade contains a dose including 500mcg. The combination of what my expert told me was an inadequate dose of adrenaline for anaphylaxis and an inadequate length needle raises serious safety concerns.
- rscho 8y agoFor the record, a large part of anesthesia worldwide is done with that molecule. Potency is not everything, and using sufentanyl in hospital contexts is very much justified. The tablet formula of course makes it far more prone to misuse, though... I can also add that iv remifentanyl is on the market in the US, prescribed routinely, and is much more powerful than even sufentanyl. In fact, so powerful that getting high on it would most certainly kill you, making it pretty much useless to drug users. So again, potency is not everything.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> The tablet formula of course makes it far more prone to misuse, though... The primary danger of fentanyl is accidental use - ie, people consuming lethal doses of fentanyl because their heroin (which is much less potent, by weight) is cut with fentanyl. It's unclear from this article whether that's a risk here, which depends (among other things) on how readily Dsuvia is absorbed through other means.
- DanBC 8y ago> In fact, so powerful that getting high on it would most certainly kill you To be fair, this is what we used to say about fentanyl until recently.
- rscho 8y agoThe problem is that with high potency, you also get more side effects for the same "painkiller" effect (also depending on absorption velocity). Therefore, using something such as remifentanyl in the mix would almost certainly be counterproductive if you are looking for the "high". It would displace fentanyl, and be more risky. And first of all, it is far more expensive than fentanyl.
- etrevino 8y agoIt's worth noting here that not every opioid is metabolized the same. I can't speak for this medicine, but different metabolic pathways are used to process opioids.[1] Having more tools in your toolkit means that you are more likely to be able to treat a patient's pain. That being said, I think that one of the major uses for this drug will be to treat acute pain in chronic pain patients. Those patients aren't opioid naive and may need something that will "override" the tolerance these patients have developed. I'm guessing that they'd also work for patients on the opioid agonist/antagonist Buprenorphine, which is used for chronic pain, but tends to block other opiates. Lastly, while potent, this drug appears to wear off very quickly. That's going to be key here, because it's simply not useful unless you're able to administer a high quantity of the medicine. To boot, I believe that the manufacturer claims that this drug has less cognitive side effects than other opioids. [2] [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2704133/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2704133/ [2] http://www.acelrx.com/technology/publications/arx-04/MHSRS%20ProjTeamPresentation%202016%20FINAL%2008_10_16%20MRC-0076.pdf http://www.acelrx.com/technology/publications/arx-04/MHSRS%2...
- Johnny555 8y agoTo boot, I believe that the manufacturer claims that this drug has less cognitive side effects than other opioids I'd take manufacturer claims with a grain of salt, since their goal (actually pretty much a requirement for a public company) is to sell drugs and earn money, not heal people.
- etrevino 8y agoFair enough.
- jplayer01 8y agoThe last time these companies promised it wouldn't be as addictive as previous opioids, they were pulling numbers out of their ass and straight lying about it. I think we should all be alarmed if they're releasing a new drug that's even more potent.
- 8y ago
- gammateam 8y agoThe FDA approves things based on the purpose they were presented to the FDA/market for. It isn't based on danger, it is based on evidence backed disclosure of the danger. In the specific use the company told the FDA about, it passed, and that will usually happen with some objections or outright denial. The denial didn't happen and that isn't article worthy.
- stevespang 8y agoFDA staff took HUGE bribes on this one . . .
- fromthestart 8y agoI just want to point out that the words "10x more powerful" serve no purpose other than to sensationalize the headline. Potency doesn't matter; pills are mixed with fillers to adjust dosage. Now, if street drugs start being cut with this new drug, that's another story, if the mixing is poor.