3 ms·
Then think of how much scientific inquiry has been discouraged because people don't want to work under those conditions. It just weirds me out that the article
by sp332 8y ago
Then think of how much scientific inquiry has been discouraged because people don't want to work under those conditions. It just weirds me out that the article quotes people about terrible behavior from professors, but doesn't put any blame there or with the authorities who could do something about it. It just blames everyone who responds for doing it wrong.
When authorities aren't doing their jobs, we're left with vigilantism or nothing.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoOr, you know, changing the authorities.
- maceurt 8y agoThere is a reason most good justice systems leave a percent of guilty people free, because punishing that last percent of people would mean also punishing a large amount of innocent people too. It is a law of dimishing returns, and I doubt that a mob of people is gonna have better restraint or control that a justice/ legal system will have while also having better detection and punishment of crimes against the society or social convention.
- eiaoa 8y ago>> To try and shame people not to cite or use scholarly work from people with controversy sourrounding them is sinister in its very nature. It is falling to mob rule instead of logic and reason. > Then think of how much scientific inquiry has been discouraged because people don't want to work under those conditions. That's an entirely different issue. What we're talking about here is work that exists, but is not cited due to it's authorship. If Adolf Hitler himself had correctly proven Goldbach's Conjecture, is the proof itself so inseparable from his other actions that it should be rejected with them?
- sp332 8y agoYes, that was a response to "Science should be subject to logic and reason" etc. To your hypothetical example, I think Hitler's reputation is pretty low right now and it's not necessary to deny him citations just so he won't get more cachet. Her article was about professors who are "jerks", "whose academic sexism hasn’t risen to the level of actionable correction".
- belorn 8y agoThe reason is that most of the time we have traded to do nothing in favor of a better legal system. Looking at police records here in Sweden, and it seems that the average reported crime has single digit resolve rate. We could lazily improve those numbers by simply lower the burden of proof and pay more, but through time we have chosen not to. Lets make up some estimated numbers that the average resole rate is 8%. Would we be willing to double the police budget to get 16%, assuming falsely that we are lucky enough that double the budget doubles the result. What if we make assumptions of guilt and raises the resolve rate to 20%, but also increase the false accusations by 2000%? What about a camera in every street, testing the case that camera surveillance decrease crime (just like London). I think authorities are mostly doing their jobs within the limits that we gave them. It can naturally be done more efficient but we are talking about such low resolve rates and that makes it look like they do nothing in most cases.