3 ms·
I'm usually anti-SJW, but if someone is a sexist ass who doesn't acknowledge women's contributions to the field, why should those women acknowledge his contribu
by ummonk 8y ago
I'm usually anti-SJW, but if someone is a sexist ass who doesn't acknowledge women's contributions to the field, why should those women acknowledge his contributions either?
- justinjlynn 8y agoBecause academia shouldn't be a tit-for-tat game played by people who wish to score points against each other in a game of judge-jury-executioner. If you don't condone a particular colleagues attitudes or actions or reported actions - by all means please do say so in your footnotes and citations. Make sure your colleagues know of your discomfort and that they should also be discomforted by people like that being in a place where they are enabled to contribute to the field - when they should be driven from it. However, under no account should one defraud one's editors and/or reviewers - or your colleagues who trust your work has been reviewed and approved by them. To do so is plainly dishonest and deprives those people of their right to autonomy. You aren't forced to cite, but then they don't have to approve - or read - either. If you have to lie and cheat to people in order to get your way - perhaps what your doing is wrong, because you're certainly doing wrong to those people. At what point do you opt out of a system with which you disagree? Is it morally acceptable to commit an unjust act to achieve what you believe to be justice? Is it acceptable to venerate vigilantism - to be a vigilante? I would say that it certainly isn't - in precisely the same way using unjustly or immorally obtained data is unacceptable.
- manfredo 8y agoFor one, it would further erode society's respect for academia. People already widely suspect that social-justice minded academics see their position to be more like a soapbox from which to preach rather than an means to carry out an objective pursuit of understanding. A deliberate campaign of exclusion of people they don't like would only serve to confirm this view.
- Yetanfou 8y agoFollow your line of reasoning to its logical conclusion and you'll end up with... - men not citing radical anything produced by rabid feminists ("why would those men acknowledge the contribution of a man-hater?") - religious people not citing atheists ("why would those people acknowledge the contributions of an unbeliever?") - atheists not citing religious people ("why would those people acknowledge the contributions of a sky-fairy theorist?") - lefties not citing right-wingers ... - right-wingers not citing lefties ... - ... And 'poof', there goes the scientific method. Don't go down that path, it leads to nothing but destruction.