3 ms·
Here is the underlying issue. Settled law (settled in the 1800s with mail order catalogs) says the following: - States may levy whatever taxes they want on th
by btilly 16y ago
Here is the underlying issue.
Settled law (settled in the 1800s with mail order catalogs) says the following:
- States may levy whatever taxes they want on their residents.
- States may require companies within the state to collect those taxes for them.
- States do not have jurisdiction over interstate commerce, meaning that they cannot impose requirements on companies in other states. Even if those companies are doing business with customers in that state.
The result is that sales tax is owed for out of state purchases, but is rarely collected. Amazon likes it that way, because it makes their goods cheaper. State governments hate it, because their tax revenues are hit.
North Carolina tried the trick of getting Amazon's sales records. With that, they can go to their private citizens and collect owed but unpaid taxes directly. Amazon is fighting it because they want to remain an artificially cheap alternative. The First Amendment issue was a red herring that they managed to make a good legal argument from.
- shpxnvz 16y agoA minor nit - it's not a sales tax that is due on out of state purchases, but rather a use tax (though it's commonly the same rate as the local sales tax). The issue isn't so much that it's rarely collected, but that purchasers who have a legal responsibility to declare and pay it rarely do because there is (as you stated) no practical way for the state to track such purchases, excepting some obvious exceptions like out-of-state purchased vehicles - many states collect the use tax before they allow the vehicle to be registered. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use_tax
- ars 16y agoHow was North Carolina even was able to take Amazon to court? Don't they have no jurisdiction at all?
- btilly 16y agoFrom reading a couple of articles, it went the other way. North Carolina was doing an audit to verify that Amazon was within state law. They asked for this data as part of the audit. Then Amazon filed suit saying that they had no right to make the request. This makes sense to me. Anyone can make any request of anyone else for any reason. You can't always get your request satisfied, but you're free to make the request. And if the one making the request becomes too insistent (governments are good at that), the final way you can make a "No" stick is to go to court. However the fact that this was argued on First Amendment grounds makes me uncomfortable. What if North Carolina were to be asking about people who ordered, say, electronic equipment? There is no free speech issue with knowing whether you bought a microwave, so this precedent won't help block that request.