4 ms·
In your statement, 'all participants' is problematic. Does everyone who works at Google go to Burning Man? Of course they don't. The only venue where the set o
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
In your statement, 'all participants' is problematic. Does everyone who works at Google go to Burning Man? Of course they don't.
The only venue where the set of participants can actually meet the standard 'all' is the business itself or a business event.
The canonical example from history is men getting business done while playing golf at the 'club'. Restrictions on the club (like men only in Atlanta) or ability of other employees to participate (women, disabled) disenfranchised those employees with respect to the kinds of decisions that were getting made on the golf course.
It is inappropriate and it is bad for the company.
- naasking 8y ago> Does everyone who works at Google go to Burning Man? Of course they don't. And if anyone in a group meeting for work purposes doesn't like that venue, then they can say so. > The only venue where the set of participants can actually meet the standard 'all' is the business itself or a business event. No, that's the only venue if you want to restrict the agency of all the adults involved. This isn't necessary unless you think people are too mentally weak to voice their opinions. > The canonical example from history is men getting business done while playing golf at the 'club'. Restrictions on the club (like men only in Atlanta) or ability of other employees to participate (women, disabled) disenfranchised those employees with respect to the kinds of decisions that were getting made on the golf course. Hate to break it to you, this is still how a lot of business is conducted. There's no indication at all that this is "bad for the company". If one of the people involved were a woman, or were disabled in some way, then they are one of the participants that can voice their preference for a venue, and clearly some venues simply won't work for them. I'm not sure if you're aware of this, but people develop the ability to negotiate and compromise by the time they're 10 years old. There's no need to establish a nanny state where venues that disadvantage those that aren't even participants are ruled out from the outset.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI understand your argument and respect your point of view. Hold on to this statement: "There's no need to establish a nanny state where venues that disadvantage those that aren't even participants are ruled out from the outset." When you experience being disadvantaged in your career because you could not participate in a non-business sanctioned event or venue where decisions that affected you directly were being made, then think back to how you feel right now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- naasking 8y ago> When you experience being disadvantaged in your career because you could not participate in a non-business sanctioned event or venue where decisions that affected you directly were being made Except you're now violating the preconditions. People who are not participants can't be disadvantaged. People who are participants have a say in the venue, like I said. So what problem are you trying to solve exactly? "Affecting me directly" is unfortunately vague. There are plenty of business decisions that affect me directly that I have little to no control over, like employee salaries, benefits, work hours, etc. On matters where I can exert some control, then I'm a participant and the rules I list above apply.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI would ask you to trust me when I say that you will know it when it happens.