21 ms·
The fact that there are rules which have reasons makes them not arbitrary, by definition
by keiferski 8y ago
The fact that there are rules which have reasons makes them not arbitrary, by definition
- Jedd 8y ago> The fact that there are rules which have reasons makes them not arbitrary, by definition Well, perhaps. But two things: 1. rules with alleged reasons (for someone) doesn't mean they're reasonable rules for everyone else, and 2. I initially bemoaned arbitrary parallels with TFA -- not that Amish made arbitrary rulings -- so, as noted, I'm now in the weird position where I'm defending something I didn't claim. (Anyway, you may be assuming arbitrary has a single meaning, that of being a synonym for 'random', which isn't entirely accurate. No two words are 100% synonyms, after all.) EDIT: Actually, 3 things. Amish rules are not consistent amongst all amish, as I noted above -- there's a lot of disparity between different communities, which suggests that the reasons are not especially objective (otherwise they'd all reach the same conclusion), which in turn leads to a conclusion there's some arbitrary (in the personal whim sense) aspects to them.