5 ms·
Sen. Wyden proposes bill that could jail executives who mishandle consumer data
- joatmon-snoo 8y agoOfficial press release: https://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/wyden-releases-discussion-draft-of-legislation-to-provide-real-protections-for-americans-privacy https://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/wyden-relea... Links below are from the above Text of the draft: https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Wyden%20Privacy%20Bill%20Discussion%20Draft%20Nov%201.pdf https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Wyden%20Privacy%2... Official sparknotes: https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Consumer%20Data%20Protection%20Act%20section%20by%20section.pdf https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Consumer%20Data%2... Official 1-pager: https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Wyden%20Privacy%20Bill%20one%20pager%20Nov%201.pdf https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Wyden%20Privacy%2...
- joatmon-snoo 8y agoSuper nice to see legislation being proposed about this. Miscellaneous thoughts: - S7.b.1.D seems nice, but I can't help but wonder what it means to "verify" a consumer, and the potential for breaches that this poses. - S7.b.1.A "establish and implement reasonable cyber security and privacy policies, practices, and procedure" devil is in the details here, particularly what "reasonable" is defined to be - S6.b.1.B (paraphrasing, because the original text is a clusterfuck to comprehend, and I think I've got it right) companies must respect a consumer's opt-out, unless they allow a consumer to pay a fee, capped at the estimated value that the company would get out of said consumer's data I have no idea how S6.a.1 is going to go: "implement and maintain a ‘‘Do Not Track’’ data sharing opt-out website— (A) that allows consumers to opt-out of data sharing, view their opt-out status, and change their opt-out status; " No policy expertise here, sadly, so I have no idea how this will fare. As a techie, good first step.
- techntoke 8y agoWyden has been doing a great job lately keeping current with changing technology: https://gizmodo.com/sen-wyden-urges-dhs-to-adopt-new-encryption-tech-to-pr-1830001179 https://gizmodo.com/sen-wyden-urges-dhs-to-adopt-new-encrypt...
- IBM 8y agoCount on Wyden to propose the legislative equivalent to Do Not Track. Fortunately, the politics has moved away from an an-tech industry friendly bill.
- slededit 8y agoSeems to be the only solution in the USA. Throw people in jail. Both parties seem to agree on this, they just argue who specifically should get sent.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoSending rich people to jail is the only real punishment, because fines don’t matter for rich people and large corporations. ING was fined almost a billion euros in the Netherlands for willfully and knowingly laundering money for many years. A month after paying the fine they already made enough profit to have earned back that money. So who cares about the fine? It’s just the price of doing things. Same with fines for rich persons. Who cares about a fine for parking in the wrong spot if it is the equivalent of 10 minutes work. But if you’re poor that fine represents perhaps a whole working day, which is a lot, and thus fines work for poor people. The solution is of course to make fines depend on your income and wealth. So Jeff Bezos will pay 10 million for a traffic ticket, and Joe Schmoe who earns minimum wage perhaps 50 dollar.
- orblivion 8y agoIt depends if the fine is commensurate with the damage done and goes toward correcting it. That may arguably be the case for parking tickets. It could just as well act as a convenience fee for rich people.
- slededit 8y agoIts pretty clear that America is the country it wants to be despite protests to the contrary.
- mtgx 8y agoThere's certainly the case of sending too many people to jail for harmless stuff like smoking marijuana. But there's also the case of sending way too few "white collar criminals" to prison, too. Too often they get away with their company paying a sub-1% of their annual revenue fine for a multi-year violation affecting millions from which they made billions of dollars. Virtually no personal accountability for the executives either. Worst case scenario, they get a golden parachute on their way out if the scandal becomes a big enough PR problem for the company.
- jacquesm 8y agoIn other news, Mark Zuckerberg just resigned as Facebook CEO. For companies whose shareholders are not executives the executives will now have an incentive not to mess up. The problem is that executives rarely have enough overview over what is happening at the lowest layers of a company to ensure that data leaks could not happen, they might want to set the tone and environment but that by itself is absolutely no guarantee. Though it is good - and probably effective - that it isn't just the shareholders of a company that are punished (they have even less insight!) through fines, I highly doubt that jailtime is the right solution. Personally I'd rather work with the carrot than the stick: Any employee that comes forward with reports of mishandling of consumer data or the failure to report a data leak should be awarded a %age of the fines levied. That way there is a much bigger chance at actually learning about these things happening, where they happen and companies with a sick culture would still end up being reported on.
- setr 8y ago>The problem is that executives rarely have enough overview over what is happening at the lowest layers of a company to ensure that data leaks could not happen, they might want to set the tone and environment but that by itself is absolutely no guarantee. But given the law and personal risk, they’re now incentivized to find a solution to that problem (in the same fashion that employee coming forward creates a PR risk). If this weren’t a possibility, and a viable one at that, then data leaks would be an inevitability, and it wouldn’t be sensible to fine the company (they can’t get insight into the matter, so they can’t do much to stop it from occurring; you’re going to fine them for succumbing to a natural disaster?) If you don’t expect top-down insight to be possible, then I’m not sure how your carrot would plug the leak. It would announce it and let people prepare for the damage, but not stop it fron occurring again (the only people with insight are middle and lower; the lower you go, the less affected by the fine). But ofc it is possible, and it is sensible to fine the company, and I don’t see why it wouldn’t be sensible to expect a c_o to have some insight into the matter. Ofc such a strong punishment as jailtime, on any data loss is too much, but data loss after not reaching some defined minimum standard of protection (essentially leaving it in a state where loss is expected) for the type of data? It seems reasonable to enforce larger punishments against the people in charge of ensuring that those minimums are met. Eg if security audits aren’t ever done, its negligence. If the data is important or even just large enough, its criminal negligence. tldr; your carrot has the same dependency as the stick: if one can hope to effect change, the other should too. (which is more fair/effective is a different matter)
- Cyclone_ 8y agoJail seems a little extreme, the punishment doesn't fit the crime here.
- Apocryphon 8y agoPowerful corporate elites need a deterrent. If only more financial evildoers had joined Bernie Madoff in prison after 2008.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoMoney, and not $2 million settlement fine after spending $20mm on lawyers for 4 years. Take EVERYTHING from them, clawback. And fine companies 10-20% of their REVENUE. Announce rev share with any whistle-blower, just give proof to DOJ and get 25% of the fine.
- jbob2000 8y agoThere are two outcomes to this: 1, where quality executives say "fuck this" and the only people who hold the roles are fall men for invisible puppet masters. or 2, the role is split up over a bunch of departments so nobody can be held responsible. The side effect of this is that the products the company produces become much more expensive.
- Apocryphon 8y ago1. The law, and its enforcers, are presumably flexible enough to not simply prosecute the figureheads, but any accompanying accomplices as well. Puppets can be made to accept plea bargains and squeal. 2. Corporations are people, my friend, and should be punished accordingly as persons, if there isn't an actual human that can be made liable. And given the current fracases over outsourcing, immigration, big box chain stores, vertical integration, monopolies, ad-funded tech, etc., etc., it isn't simply to shoot down a proposal simply because "the products become much more expensive." Not even the public is as simply mollified by cheaper goods as they were a decade or two ago.
- ArrayList 8y ago
- dbg31415 8y agoI think you need a few prongs, but not keen on CEO jail time. CEOs likely don't have enough visibility into day-to-day to have an impact on data security. They set the tone, but they won't have time to personally validate the work is being done to proper security standards. Few ideas, to be used in conjunction: 1) Fine the shit out of violating companies. Base fines with the same aggressive tactics they use to compute fines for piracy -- leak 1M records, pay $100 x 1M in files. And have to set up identity protection for your consumers -- all that good stuff. 2) Reward good behaviour. Set a third-party standards, if a company submits to that, and passes, give them 1 strike per year where they don't have to pay the files. Worried about how to set these? Don't me, EY or Accenture or Deloitte will set fairly comprehensive standards, as long as they are allowed to charge for the audits. 3) Protect whistle blowers and offer rewards. If you go through proper channels, you won't be fired. And if your company fails to act, and then you narc on them, you should get a bonus. A massive fucking bonus. You see shady, you report shady, you get a hero's bounty.
- tzs 8y agoThe jail time is only for people who know that the required annual data protection report the company files with the FTC does not comply with the requirements of the law, but certify to the FTC that it does.
- tzs 8y agoI'm a bit unclear on the criminal penalties section. (I'm using the draft linked in joatmon-snoo's comment) There is an annual report that the company must file with the FTC. That report must be accompanied by a written statement from the CEO, the chief privacy officer, and the chief information security officer certifying that the report fully complies with section 5(a) of the Consumer Data Protection Act. The criminal penalties for those three officers arises if they so certify the report knowing that the report does not comply. What confuses me is that there are two levels of possible penalties. The first level is if one of those officers "certifies any statement as set forth in subsections (b) and (c) of this section knowing that the annual report accompanying the statement does not comport with all the requirements set forth in this section". That can subject them to up $1 million or 5% of their largest annual compensation of the past 3 years (whichever is bigger) and/or up to 10 years in jail. The second level ups those limits to $5 million, 25%, and 20 years. The conditions for the second are word for word the same as the first level except the word "intentionally" is inserted before "certifies" so it becomes "intentionally certifies any statement..." instead of "certifies any statement...". I'm having trouble seeing how an officer could run afoul of the first without running afoul of the second. How do you certify the report without intentionally certifying it? At first I thought the distinction was going to be whether or not the officer knew the report was bad, but no, both cases require that the officer knows that the report is bad. The lower penalties are for certifying a report you know is bad. The higher penalties are for intentionally certifying a report you know is bad, so the distinction is whether or not the certification is intentional.
- thechao 8y agoNegligence. Well-written law always includes the notion of mens rea: did you do it on purpose, or just do it? As an analog consider the difference between manslaughter & murder.
- tzs 8y agoWhat's confusing me here is that I'm having trouble seeing how it is possible for a CEO or other officer to unintentionally produce a statement certifying that the annual privacy report meets the legal requirements. Suppose Alice is the CEO and Bob is the CPO. Their minions produce the annual privacy report, and give it to Alice and Bob to certify and send to the FTC. Alice and Bob both know that the report does not meet the legal requirements. Alice and Bob nevertheless both certify it and it is sent to the FTC. I don't see what Alice and Bob could do different from each other that could lead to one of them being liable for "intentionally certifying" the bad report and the other being liable for merely "certifying" it. Compare to, say, killing a pedestrian by driving through a crosswalk that you know is occupied. It would then make sense to distinguish between • driving through a crosswalk that you knew to be occupied, and • intentionally driving through a crosswalk that you knew to be occupied. You could do the former by seeing that the crosswalk is occupied, intending to stop when you got closer, getting distracted by something, and losing track of where you are. The intentionally modifier makes sense there because you can unintentionally drive through a crosswalk that you know is occupied. With certifying a report...what? You were not planning on signing the certification, but your secretary accidentally put it in a pile of things awaiting your routine signature and you signed it without realizing what it was?
- onetimemanytime 8y agoNot gonna work. The CEO can't know everything, and unless people testify against him (they'll avoid paper /email trail) he'll plead ignorance. It's 38 pages and if it passes it will 380, everyone will want their 2 cents in it. Hold companies responsible with 10% of their revenue as fines--for first time violation. In cases of absolute negligence and or malice jail C level execs. But just because Google gets hacked, we can't jail their CEO.
- titusjohnson 8y agoNah, lock up the CEO. Who cares if they can't know everything, that's not a good excuse. If the company is so big that the executive team can't keep a firm grasp on what's going on, then maybe it's too big to exist. Locking up executives (a risk for which they are richly rewarded already) puts a natural cap on how large a corp can get.
- nil_pointer 8y agoThis effort is welcomed! Sen. Wyden is doing a great job pushing this.