3 ms·
It absolutely blows my mind that map products ship without street names clearly visible at all times. I agree. The place where Google Maps and, to a slightly
by reaperducer 8y ago
It absolutely blows my mind that map products ship without street names clearly visible at all times.
I agree. The place where Google Maps and, to a slightly lesser extent, Apple Maps fall down is in labeling roads.
I can't count the number of times I've zoomed in on a map and it shows every little sushi joint in the neighborhood, but no street names. And no amount of zooming in or out will fix it.
It's similarly frustrating when Apple and Google show a highway shield instead of a street name in an urban area. Yes, lots of streets in urban areas are also state highways. But the state highway designations only appear in real life every few miles, while the street signs I'm standing under appear on every corner.
But the greatest sin is omission. Each month I have to render about 70,000 maps from towns and cities from the Philippines to Nova Scotia. And every month I spend three days manually placing towns and businesses that exist in no online maps.
And it's not just tiny towns on far away islands. I'm talking about places in Oklahoma and Arizona and even California that either don't exist, or are stupendously wrong.
Sometimes I fantasize about having a full-time job driving around the country fixing all of Apple Maps' faults. But somehow I suspect the pay would be terrible.
- bluntfang 8y ago>Sometimes I fantasize about having a full-time job driving around the country fixing all of Apple Maps' faults. But somehow I suspect the pay would be terrible. I've thought about doing this too, but for hiking trails. I'm sure the pay would be abysmal, but hiking and updating online maps sounds like a blast as a job. I think it could be done fairly well with a simple GPS recorder and serialization, but the biggest challenge would be managing the partnership between the map customers like google and apple.. If anyone wants to fund this and/or has the connections to play sales/product manager, DM me.. :p
- metafizikal 8y agoWhen I was hiking in Big Bend, TX, there was a lady with one of those Google Maps backpacks taking imagery for street view, presumably it was collecting other interesting data as well.
- Thrymr 8y agoThere is a huge amount of this information maintained by land management agencies (see e.g. [0]). Presumably it is even licensed (in the US at least) in a way that commercial companies could use. But Google Maps coverage of trails and even forest roads is terrible. I presume that you're right, the return is too low, but it is sad that no one is picking up this low hanging fruit. Even OpenStreetMap is hit and miss on this public data (partly because of data import wars). [0] https://data.fs.usda.gov/geodata/edw/datasets.php?dsetCategory=transportation https://data.fs.usda.gov/geodata/edw/datasets.php?dsetCatego...
- ghaff 8y agoI conclude that Google has decided once you get off of "normal" roads, it just doesn't care. (One even wonders if Google considers omitting paths that aren't reliable for automobiles to be a feature rather than a bug.) As you say, OSM is better but can't really be depended on.
- bjtitus 8y agoNatural Atlas is trying to do this type of thing by pulling together data from USGS, USFS, etc: https://naturalatlas.com https://naturalatlas.com
- GuiA 8y agoYou can do this right now for Open Street Map :) the pay is terrible ($0), but the resulting data is open! https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Contribute_map_data https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Contribute_map_data