3 ms·
> UK gun deaths per 100,000 per year - 0.06 > US gun deaths per 100,000 per year - 4.62 The majority of which, as you point out, are suicides. Also, measurin
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> UK gun deaths per 100,000 per year - 0.06
> US gun deaths per 100,000 per year - 4.62
The majority of which, as you point out, are suicides.
Also, measuring "gun deaths" is like measuring "blue car accidents" an an argument for restricting blue cars. A better metric might be something like "homicide rate" except that then you have to reckon with the fact that the US homicide rate is higher than the UK homicide rate even if you remove the US firearm homicides entirely, proving that the difference has causes other than access to firearms.
The same is true of the suicide rate. Even excluding US firearms suicides, the US still has a higher suicide rate than the UK. Moreover, preventing suicides by restricting access to firearms is certainly not a real solution -- it implies leaving people in such a despondent state that the only thing preventing suicide is lack of means. Addressing the underlying problem is still necessary, but is then also sufficient and obviates the supposed need to restrict access to firearms.
- batiudrami 8y ago>it implies leaving people in such a despondent state that the only thing preventing suicide is lack of means. this is certainly one of the reasons I'm still here today. Not such a bad thing, no?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> this is certainly one of the reasons I'm still here today. The point is that it's not. Getting to the point where access to means is the only remaining form of prevention implies that five other things have already failed in ways that never should have happened. Those things sometimes do fail in practice, but that's what needs to be fixed. Because what about everyone who uses a different means?