5 ms·
I don't understand this at all. Google chief executive Sundar Pichai has told staff he supports their right to take the action. "I understand the anger and di
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I don't understand this at all.
Google chief executive Sundar Pichai has told staff he supports their right to take the action.
"I understand the anger and disappointment that many of you feel," he said in an all-staff email. "I feel it as well, and I am fully committed to making progress on an issue that has persisted for far too long in our society… and, yes, here at Google, too."
If someone at the top is sincerely interested in resolving this satisfactorily, why the walk-out? I don't get it.
Are they saying they don't really believe him?
- solipsism 8y agoWords are cheap.
- buboard 8y agoand so are walkouts
- tomjakubowski 8y agoare they? I'm sure someone could put a dollar figure on the productivity lost to Google by this action.
- manfredo 8y agoWhatever loss of productivity would be immensely offset by the optics of taking actions against such a walk out.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSo is grandstanding by people with well paid, cushy as hell jobs who are happy to point fingers. My mother always told me "When you point a finger at others, you have three fingers pointing back at you." What are these people personally doing to ensure that they are respecting women, creating the right kind of social climate at work, etc? Because all the policy in the world can't per se fix a shitty culture. Shitty culture is as shitty culture does and it is perpetuated by every single individual in the organization and their individual choices. I'm not impressed with people who point fingers. They are usually people wanting someone else to fix a problem so they don't have to actually change.
- solipsism 8y agoWhat? You asked, essentially, "why would they walking out if their CEO supports their cause?" Although I thought the answer was a bit obvious, I answered... Words are cheap and the employees want to see action. Your response is to talk about pointing fingers? I don't understand your point. What do you have against Google employees making demands of their managers? My mother always told me "When you point a finger at others, you have three fingers pointing back at you." I'm pretty sure employees know that fingers are being pointed at them. Employees are constantly evaluated, and management places expectations on them (both work related and cultural) that those employees must meet, at penalty of termination. It seems like you're questioning the idea that the fingers should point both ways... by saying that the fingers point both ways.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYes, "words are cheap" is so obvious, it goes without saying. It doesn't add anything substantive to the discussion. So saying that to me really doesn't cast any light whatsoever on this situation for me.
- solipsism 8y agoIf someone at the top is sincerely interested in resolving this satisfactorily, why the walk-out? I don't get it. That just sounds so naive. If I knew what your real disconnect with this was, I'd try to help you understand. Let's walk through the basics: * Employees have a problem with management. * Management says "we'll work on it" like they always do. * Employees may or may not believe, but they want to see action taking place. Employees feel secure enough at their privileged jobs to make a statement by "walking out", with the explicit threat of further action if demands aren't met. * Management encourages the employees... And will have to decide if they mean business, in part based on the walk-outs.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThat just sounds so naive. I appear to be the top ranked woman on HN. I appear to be the only woman to have ever spent time on the leaderboard here (under a different handle). Historical surveys suggest the membership was possibly as much as 98% male at one time. I get nothing but crapped on when I say that. I get nothing but mocked when I suggest that is indicative of personal competence on my part. People mostly admit to recognizing me at all in order to say something dickish. It's relatively rare that I get genuine support. I got to the leaderboard by not grandstanding, not pissing on all the guys here, etc. I'm not naive, though I may well be on my way out the door because I've been thrown off of plenty of other forums for saying "The emperor has no clothes." It's generally a socially unacceptable thing to do. But it doesn't come out of naiveté by any stretch of the imagination whatsoever.
- danans 8y agoRight words are one thing (and welcome). Right actions are another thing (also welcome). disclosure: Google employee
- gretch 8y agosource/disclosure: am google employee, didn't walk though The way it's organized, it's also kind of a social event. Lot of folks didn't just walk out, but went to B40 to specifically walk out there. They probably saw it as an opportunity to meet others and share thoughts on the topic. Find solidarity and get support
- anigbrowl 8y agoTo make this the top priority for the day. You may as well ask why people negotiate anything if everyone has such good intentions.
- steeef 8y agoYes. He can put actions behind his words, or his reply is just hot air. Plus, by endorsing it as a Google-sanctioned event, he's effectively taking power away from those walking out from disrupting normal business as usual (e.g., allowing managers to reschedule meetings).