5 ms·
> “It’s too tall” is a common refrain in public hearings to approve new construction, but I’m honestly puzzled by the obsession with the notion of a building’s
by masklinn 8y ago
> “It’s too tall” is a common refrain in public hearings to approve new construction, but I’m honestly puzzled by the obsession with the notion of a building’s height as a measure of compatibility with its surroundings. I think the importance of height in and of itself is vastly overstated.
That is true, height is often a bad proxy for some other quality you're looking for and which could be solved in original ways besides height e.g. in the north east you'd want enough light to reach the street and avoid gloomy alleys, besides height you could manage it by removing wedges of the building (from a basic cuboid shape), or having a front courtyard or a large atrium, or yes height. Height also becomes a factor of the street width, narrower streets would tend to get shorter buildings.
Furthermore regulating height can be counter-productive: while you want to avoid excessive shade in the north-east, in the south-west you want to do the exact opposite, much like cities of northern africa or the middle east, for an arizonan or texan city to be walkable it needs shade and air flow rather than light: you need buildings tall enough that they protect pedestrians from the sun (without falling into gloom), but you also want them to guide and amplify the slightest breeze.
> 3. Land Use
> Segregation of uses is the most important of those features. The biggest factor that predicts walkability is the presence of actual destinations in walking distance of where people live. The postwar paradigm has been to rigidly control where commercial land uses can go and where they can’t, based on the premise that they are a nuisance in a residential neighborhood—bringing traffic, noise, and possibly crime. Yet all commercial uses are not created equal.
Many places segregate by maximum nuisance rather than specific land use: plots are give an maximum nuisance level, and businesses are charted according to the expected nuisance they produce. Anything below the plot's MNL is allowed and thus your small corner shop or barbershop (low-nuisance businesses) can live in a "residential" area, but a nightclub or a machine shop probably can't.
- graeme 8y agoI know Japan regulates by nuisance. Which other countries/cities do? It seems like a great system. My neighbourhood of Montreal has some of this, but I think a lot is grandfathered in. You can't just open anything you want in any building, even if there's a similar store around the block.
- mjevans 8y agoYes, it's literally my only /faved/ story. http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8540845 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8540845
- bobthepanda 8y ago> hat is true, height is often a bad proxy for some other quality you're looking for and which could be solved in original ways besides height e.g. in the north east you'd want enough light to reach the street and avoid gloomy alleys, besides height you could manage it by removing wedges of the building (from a basic cuboid shape) This is actually why Manhattan's older buildings look the way they do, with a distinctive 'cake tower' look, but the actual fight for sunlight has been a lot more complicated: https://www.citylab.com/equity/2016/12/how-the-battle-for-sunlight-shaped-new-york-city/510917/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2016/12/how-the-battle-for-su... > Segregation of uses is the most important of those features. The biggest factor that predicts walkability is the presence of actual destinations in walking distance of where people live. The postwar paradigm has been to rigidly control where commercial land uses can go and where they can’t, based on the premise that they are a nuisance in a residential neighborhood—bringing traffic, noise, and possibly crime. Yet all commercial uses are not created equal. Most Americans these days live in suburbs, and I can't really think of many that don't adopt rigid single-use zoning.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> The biggest factor that predicts walkability is the presence of actual destinations in walking distance of where people live. Refrigeration. In days past people needed to make regular trips to buy food. We needed lots of stores, butchers, bakers and such within walking distance. (Think a metal shop is a nuisance? Imagine living downwind of an open-air butcher's yard.) Today, largely thanks to refrigeration, we can purchase larger volumes and keep them safely in our homes. So we don't need to go to the store every day, and when we do we purchase more than we can easily carry. This isn't a bad thing. It has freed up countless man-hours increased our dietary options. Not every urbanization problem is about cars.
- mamon 8y agoI actually hate the fact that in USA you can only shop for groceries in a supermarket that is 5 miles away. Problem with that is that if you happen to run out of milk,or salt, etc., you have to plan the whole trip, instead just quickly coming downstairs and buying it in the grocery store that is in the same building as your apartment. Another problem is that instead of buying fresh bread everyday in your local bakery you have to buy this packaged, loaded with chemical conservants shit that supermarkets sell. Grocery store within walking distance should be considered a human right :)
- beat 8y agoThis reminds me of a fight I had with a city council member. A new restaurant going in a very old space (the Town Talk Diner in Minneapolis, with its classic lighted Art Deco door that forces all businesses there to have the same name) wanted a full liquor license. A council member was blocking it because there were too many liquor licenses within a couple of blocks, and there were too many problems with drunken fighting. But those could be traced to a nightclub and a seedy bar. People don't go to a hipster-nice restaurant to get drunk and start fights! Eventually they won, and had a fantastic bar.
- castratikron 8y agoThe liquor rule you're talking about is on the ballot this year. It might be going away. https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2018/09/29/minneapolis-restaurant-alcohol-liquor-restrictions-amendment/ https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2018/09/29/minneapolis-restau...
- beat 8y agoYes, I'm very excited about it!
- kurthr 8y agoWhen the new office workers are going to look down into my hot tub and block my solar for half the day... then yes, the height is a pretty good proxy for the problem... unless they want to have offsets from the property line that prevent almost any significant building size on small lots. The problem is you always have to have a border between low rise and high rise development. The difference between having a 1 story next to you with an 8ft fence and having a 5 story next to you is huge. Also there is no dealing with the new parking issues that will be created unless suddenly people decide they want to ride city busses.
- jacobolus 8y ago5 stories is not a “high rise”. But in any event, if you live someplace with a shortage of housing supply relative to demand, including many people who would be happy to live in studio or 1-bedroom apartments, then it becomes absurd to have most available land zoned to only allow buildings with <2 story single family detached houses on largish lots with strict parking requirements and sad little unused yards in the back, as happens e.g. in San Francisco and many nearby cities. Housing prices get driven up to absurd levels making the whole region unaffordable except to the best-paid professionals. You end up with a large number of 2-bedroom single-family houses occupied by groups of 20-somethings sleeping in bunk beds; workers essential to the basic functioning of society commuting hours each way every day; schoolteachers working extra part-time jobs so they can afford to sleep in someone’s closet; families raising multiple kids while renting a small in-law unit in someone else’s back yard; people forced to move away when they get married because they can’t afford to live anywhere but their current rented multi-roommate spaces, the prices of everything in the economy going up but all of the difference siphoned off by large land-owners, .... Having a few people’s gardens shadowed for part of the day by 3–5 story apartment buildings just isn’t that big a problem in comparison.
- kurthr 8y agoWhat part of San Francisco with 1 story houses are you talking about? I lived there for 5 years and the only ones I remember were in the parks. Even the low density is almost all 2 story just to have a parking space. No, I'm talking about the burbs where they've decided to put 5 story commercial next to city blocks of single family homes on quarter acre lots. 2 stories would be fine... 25% of the houses are anyway. There's always going to be an edge to zoning, but going from 1 story to 5 is stupid. There's no parking, no transit, no shopping, just offices and houses. The commercial was single story and fit into the neighborhood, but now going 5 it's just going to cause problems.
- sbov 8y ago> That is true, height is often a bad proxy for some other quality you're looking Be careful of what you wish for. Because getting at the actual quality you want is part of what makes building in SF so difficult, e.g. the infamous "shade on public spaces" test.
- BurningFrog 8y agoWhat people say in public hearings and what they actually want are separate things. "Height", "neighborhood character" and a few other things are typically things that are legally required for the regulators to consider in their decisions, so they keep being brought up. What people really want is typically just two things (1) keep the value of their homes up through scarcity, and (2) keep outsiders out.
- village-idiot 8y agoI think 1 is generating another housing bubble.
- monkeydreams 8y agoWe regulate what we can measure, because what we can measure we can prove.
- village-idiot 8y agoThe problem of light is often an issue of street angle, not height. A good example is Denver, where they actually changed street angle closer to the river Platte because of light issues, specifically to melt snow I believe.