3 ms·
Just because OSI wasn't formed as a legal entity until 1998 doesn't mean that the people involved weren't around and involved in those earlier discussions of "o
by mindcrime 8y ago
Just because OSI wasn't formed as a legal entity until 1998 doesn't mean that the people involved weren't around and involved in those earlier discussions of "open source". All OSI did was formalize what was in common usage. And sure, you can cherry pick a few exceptions where individuals used the term in different ways. That has little or nothing to do with contemporary usage.
And in today's vernacular (dating back to at least 2000 or so) the de-facto definition is the OSI definition. A few lone-wolf dissenters don't change that.
- zzzcpan 8y agoLanguages don't work like that. You don't just come up with a definition and try to force everyone to use it. People learn definitions from how they are used and mentioned in the things they encounter. In reality almost no one is aware that OSI definition exists and those who do can't even remember what it is exactly. So, no, de-facto definition of open source is definitely not an OSI definition, but mostly literal meaning of open source software with most people presuming freely usable software as well to some degree. Take SQLite for example, it's open source, but not OSI open source and everyone is ok with that. Because this is where common meaning is. And trying to claim authority over it just invites bad PR for OSI. I guess OSI is already that irrelevant and it's pretty much consequence free to use a proper common meaning of open source.
- mindcrime 8y agoYou don't just come up with a definition and try to force everyone to use it. Right, and nobody did that. In reality almost no one is aware that OSI definition exists and those who do can't even remember what it is exactly. I haven't found that to be the case. At least not for people who are actually involved in the open source community to any serious level. Maybe for casual bystanders.