4 ms·
Where in the USA do people think like this? I don't know anyone who does.
by nerdponx 8y ago
Where in the USA do people think like this? I don't know anyone who does.
- swiley 8y agoMost people I've been around think like this. So in Lynchburg and the very western suburban part of Richmond Virginia at least they do. Younger people who aren't in (have graduated) college seem to be a little more reasonable.
- grandmczeb 8y agoI'm not sure if you have a very strange friend group, but I've never heard someone express a similar opinion.
- swiley 8y agoI definitely do, it's not really a location thing.
- eitally 8y ago<waves hi!> As a native Lynchburger who subsequently spent about 15 years in the Raleigh area before moving to San Jose a few years ago, ... I never felt this way growing up in Lynchburg. Yes, Lynchburg is approximately 50% white / 50% black, with approximately 0% any other ethnicity, and the majority of the white population is either exurbs or specific segregated parts of the city. But even though I grew up in Boonsboro I went to RS Payne Elementary downtown and then EC Glass for high school ... in HS, I freely wandered around that part of town after school (usually while waiting for sports practice of some sort). I never felt endangered. Nor, afaik, did my [mostly white] friends. That's a stupid anecdote, but I think it actually used to be better than it is now, and that mass & social media have created so much fearmongering that more people are hyper-insecure and wary of any unplanned interaction with anyone not in their in-group.
- tomjakubowski 8y agoI've encountered this maddening driving behavior in both suburban Chicago and Southern California, often while riding along in the car. I think it crops up anywhere there are shopping centers with huge parking lots though. The parking garages that indicate the number of available spaces on a level are a good counter to this: I find that most able-bodied folks will see the bottom few floors have few spaces open and go for a higher one.
- bluntfang 8y agoPretty much everywhere there's a subset of the population that is ruled by fear induced by the media.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoBut wait, are the SUVs armored vehicles? Why are they getting knifed instead of gunned down? I'm intrigued by this narrative.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe threat model for people who think like this is muggers or drug dealers who come up to you on the sidewalk, not drive-by-shootings from a car. This is mostly inaccurate, but when it comes to peoples' fears, few things are rational. It's probably exacerbated because for people who grow up in low-density areas, the idea that the vast majority of people will just ignore you is a foreign concept. If you're in a small town and you see someone you know & like, you go up to them and chat. If you see someone you don't like, you bully them or get bullied. If you just ignore them, you likely get moved from the "like" to "don't like" category. If you extend this model out from a town of < 10K to a city of 1M, it collapses very quickly, but not before generating some very erroneous predictions.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe suburbs. I grew up thinking that every time you walk through a dense urban neighborhood, you have to be on your guard lest you get knifed or shot or worse. Ironically, I didn't get this from my parents; my mom used to ride the subway alone into Manhattan for junior high, and my dad grew up in Zamboanga City. But when your hometown has only 13,000 people and literally zero crime, you're shuttled by car everywhere, your peers all live in the suburbs too, your only image of the city are the news reports about murders & drug dealing, and your one urban friend is a black dude from Dorchester who regales everyone with stories about how somebody got shot on his front step and that's why his parents insist he wake up at 5:30 AM to get bussed to a suburban school, you get a pretty biased perspective. There's a pretty strong selection bias maintaining this illusion too: people who are still in the suburbs for this reason will never come in contact with urban dwellers who aren't actually murderers, out of fear, and similarly the majority of urban dwellers aren't actually going to move out to the suburbs (and even if they did, their past lives in the city are just abstract tales to people who haven't experienced it). So much like other geographically-based stereotypes (like "immigrants are all bad hombres", "California is falling apart", "suburbanites are all boring Stepford Wives with nothing to do but gossip", "Appalachia is filled with uneducated hicks", and "religious people are wackos"), this remains a stubbornly persistent belief despite the reality.
- teekert 8y agoI once comments this [0], in short, In Galveston Texas walking is by itself considered a threat to normal, driving people! [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8111353 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8111353
- casefields 8y agoGo on Nextdoor and look at the upper middle class and upper class neighborhoods. It’s full of those types.