6 ms·
> I cannot believe that the Commission agreed to all this. I can. I mean, the driving forces in the EU got extremely xenophobic. Italy is ruled by the fascist
by mschuster91 8y ago
> I cannot believe that the Commission agreed to all this.
I can. I mean, the driving forces in the EU got extremely xenophobic. Italy is ruled by the fascist Salvini, the PiS in Poland are not far behind Orban, the UK government has been xenophobic for decades, France suffers from xenophobia too (after the terror attacks, though) and our own Horst Seehofer risked collapsing the German government over (literally) 0 migrants (per https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/seehofers-deal-zahlen-der-bundesregierung-zeigen-wie-nutzlos-das-fluechtlings-abkommen-mit-spanien-ist_id_9399400.html https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/seehofers-deal-zahl...)...
What are human rights, what is democracy worth, when there is no one left to enforce them? The EU won't do shit against Hungary, Poland or Italy (as there is a 100% consensus required!), the US under Trump are going isolationist and trampling on human rights wherever they can, and the UN Security Council is powerless against the stuff that Russia, China, Saudi-Arabia etc. do because there's always a veto power that bails out their "friends".
- tomp 8y agoWhat do you base your accusations of Xenophobia on? I don't think anyone would object to Swiss, German, US, Australian or Japanese immigrants... The issue is inflow of immigrants of different cultures, who don't assimilate - and it's not unreasonable to judge those cultures as inferior and unwelcome (in the EU we don't force our women to wear masks and stone them for infidelity...).
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I don't think anyone would object to Swiss, German, US, Australian or Japanese immigrants... The issue is inflow of immigrants of different cultures, who don't assimilate - and it's not unreasonable to judge those cultures as inferior and unwelcome (in the EU we don't force our women to wear masks and stone them for infidelity...). Since you point out types of immigrants people wouldn't object to, I also think no one would object to Saudi sheikhs if they were to immigrate. I increasingly feel religion and culture is just a proxy for wealth. A lot of people in Poland don't like Ukrainian immigrants either (of which we have plenty), even though they're culturally very close to us. I'm increasingly believing that it's all really about wealth, and the perception of being exploited.
- tomp 8y agoNot sure about this, here in London I don't think people support Saudi sheikhs, despite being generally pro-immigration (possibly in contrast to the rest of the UK). Although you're right that almost no politician would oppose immigration of wealth(y). Edit: Although I do agree that there might be an effect similar to this, I think it was also present in Slovenia versus other Yugoslavian people. I wonder how much it has to do with the perception of wealth directly, and feeling threatened by "inferior" culture - there's probably a correlation, in addition a poor society is percieved as more likely to immigrate in larger numbers.
- mrec 8y ago> (possibly in contrast to the rest of the UK) From polls I've seen, I think most of the UK is pro-immigration. The disagreement is over uncontrolled immigration, which is a bit different. Edit - I'm also in London, and have definitely heard people complaining about rich Saudis buying everything up. (And rich Russians before that.) I suspect there's a useful comparison to be made with US anxieties wrt Japanese investment back in the 90s.
- lagadu 8y ago> I also think no one would object to Saudi sheikhs if they were to immigrate. Considering the amount of distaste for anything Saudi in most people I see across several countries around here I very much dispute that.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIn US maybe, but in Poland, I'm probably the only person out everyone I physically know who is even aware of the story. Here Saudis are mentioned mostly in anecdotes about obscenely rich people and how alcohol finds its way there even though it's technically banned.
- chewz 8y agoWell, there are over 2 milion Ukrainians in Poland most of them working and living legally (with different legal status) so the 'Xenophobic' Poland had quietly accepted twice more refuges (as Ukraine is more or less fallen state like Libya) then Germany which is open to immigration and refugees. Remember that Poland did largest immigration experiment in Europe's history in late Middle Ages and that was a failure. After 500 hundred years these migrants where still living in ghettos, speaking foreign language and preserving their religion. It is pretty much taken as a fact by Polish people that cultural and religious differences cannot be bridged in 500 years.
- damnyou 8y agoThe fact that Muslims aren't as integrated into European society as they should be is 99% the fault of Europeans. Basic stuff like labor market access is crucial for integration.
- malmsteen 8y agoAlso their "desire for education" could play a role somehow. In french migrants suburbs the scools are battlefield because the parents dont teach them basic discipline.
- FiveSquared 8y agoWell ghetto school always have that because they get less funding and their is less teacher and more work for teachers (who are already exhausted)! Plus lead and PTSD!
- tomp 8y agoI agree that's a problem, but to fault Europeans is about as stupid as faulting Muslims for not figuring out how to make new jobs. Even the "worst" immigrants into the US (Mexicans) can find (shitty) jobs (the "best" immigrants - Asians - are a success story in all categories so they're usually ignored in these discussions). But the obvious solutions to this problem, regardless of who's fault it is, is to not import people if you can't offer them jobs/health/education/language courses.
- FiveSquared 8y agoThen offer them the courses then! The EU and the US already do this! And besides, what is the benefit of keeping out potential businesspeople(Sergi was a immigrant and Andy Grove was a refugee), doctors, programmers, and more while birth rates and education stagnate?
- tomp 8y agoWe do! But resources aren't infinite, so there must be limits.