6 ms·
Not to put a fine point on it, but "the team at iBorderCtrl" are charlatans. Their system is supposed to detect lying from facial expressions. The only kind of
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
Not to put a fine point on it, but "the team at iBorderCtrl" are charlatans.
Their system is supposed to detect lying from facial expressions. The only
kind of "science" purporting to back this possibility is the work of the
psychologist, Paul Ekman, which is based on flimsy evidence at best. A
gigantic hint that this "research" is a bunch of hooey is his claim to have
identified 29 "wizzards of deception detection" [1]- in very, very literal
terms those are people with the magickal power to tell when someone is lying
just by looking at their face (and magickally perceiving revealing facial
expressions, subconsciously).
The iBorderCtrl system might indeed be replaced by a wizzard, or, why not be
more inclusive, a witch, with a magick wand pointed to the traveller, while
questions are being asked of them. If the traveller is telling the truth, the
wand will jump up, if they're lying it will dive down. The witch is not moving
the wand! She's only channeling the MAGICK!
The same magick being channelled by this revolting misuse of technology for
the most odious purpose imaginable. It is not a coincidence that this
"prototype" is being deployed in Hungary, the country in the EU that has
embraced populist, xenophobic tendencies as no other, having elected a master
of the craft, Viktor Orbán, as a prime minister and head of government.
This is such utter, utter bullshit. I cannot believe that the Commission
agreed to all this. What the fucking fuck.
___________
[1] http://www.communicationcache.com/uploads/1/0/8/8/10887248/on_lie_detection_wizards..pdf http://www.communicationcache.com/uploads/1/0/8/8/10887248/o...
- mschuster91 8y ago> I cannot believe that the Commission agreed to all this. I can. I mean, the driving forces in the EU got extremely xenophobic. Italy is ruled by the fascist Salvini, the PiS in Poland are not far behind Orban, the UK government has been xenophobic for decades, France suffers from xenophobia too (after the terror attacks, though) and our own Horst Seehofer risked collapsing the German government over (literally) 0 migrants (per https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/seehofers-deal-zahlen-der-bundesregierung-zeigen-wie-nutzlos-das-fluechtlings-abkommen-mit-spanien-ist_id_9399400.html https://www.focus.de/politik/deutschland/seehofers-deal-zahl...)... What are human rights, what is democracy worth, when there is no one left to enforce them? The EU won't do shit against Hungary, Poland or Italy (as there is a 100% consensus required!), the US under Trump are going isolationist and trampling on human rights wherever they can, and the UN Security Council is powerless against the stuff that Russia, China, Saudi-Arabia etc. do because there's always a veto power that bails out their "friends".
- tomp 8y agoWhat do you base your accusations of Xenophobia on? I don't think anyone would object to Swiss, German, US, Australian or Japanese immigrants... The issue is inflow of immigrants of different cultures, who don't assimilate - and it's not unreasonable to judge those cultures as inferior and unwelcome (in the EU we don't force our women to wear masks and stone them for infidelity...).
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I don't think anyone would object to Swiss, German, US, Australian or Japanese immigrants... The issue is inflow of immigrants of different cultures, who don't assimilate - and it's not unreasonable to judge those cultures as inferior and unwelcome (in the EU we don't force our women to wear masks and stone them for infidelity...). Since you point out types of immigrants people wouldn't object to, I also think no one would object to Saudi sheikhs if they were to immigrate. I increasingly feel religion and culture is just a proxy for wealth. A lot of people in Poland don't like Ukrainian immigrants either (of which we have plenty), even though they're culturally very close to us. I'm increasingly believing that it's all really about wealth, and the perception of being exploited.
- tomp 8y agoNot sure about this, here in London I don't think people support Saudi sheikhs, despite being generally pro-immigration (possibly in contrast to the rest of the UK). Although you're right that almost no politician would oppose immigration of wealth(y). Edit: Although I do agree that there might be an effect similar to this, I think it was also present in Slovenia versus other Yugoslavian people. I wonder how much it has to do with the perception of wealth directly, and feeling threatened by "inferior" culture - there's probably a correlation, in addition a poor society is percieved as more likely to immigrate in larger numbers.
- mrec 8y ago> (possibly in contrast to the rest of the UK) From polls I've seen, I think most of the UK is pro-immigration. The disagreement is over uncontrolled immigration, which is a bit different. Edit - I'm also in London, and have definitely heard people complaining about rich Saudis buying everything up. (And rich Russians before that.) I suspect there's a useful comparison to be made with US anxieties wrt Japanese investment back in the 90s.
- lumberjack 8y agoMaybe it will be used to justify probable cause. Maybe they pick the people they want to search using other means (digital surveillance) and then create a probably cause using this fake machine.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoHey HN. An update on this. It turns out, iBorderCtrl are using microexpressions, which is to say, Eckman's work. This is from the Commission's website, the link posted here by another user: The unique approach to ‘deception detection’ analyses the micro-expressions of travellers to figure out if the interviewee is lying. http://ec.europa.eu/research/infocentre/article_en.cfm?artid=49726 http://ec.europa.eu/research/infocentre/article_en.cfm?artid...