3 ms·
Weird thought, but I think that with this license MongoDB has managed to attack the OSI without attacking the FSF. To me, this is perfectly acceptable Free Soft
by pessimizer 8y ago
Weird thought, but I think that with this license MongoDB has managed to attack the OSI without attacking the FSF. To me, this is perfectly acceptable Free Software but so strict that it basically reads "do not use this software commercially, it requires you to open every piece of software that any of your employees have ever seen or heard of, including software you do not own. Purchase a license from us." In other words, commercial usage is allowed in the post-revolution Free world that Free Software hopes to bring about, where people have access to the contents of the computers that they interact with, and the freedom to mess with the ones they own.
The Open Source concept, however, is not philosophically based; its primary goal is to allow businesses to collaborate on building blocks, but not to prevent them from taking one of those blocks and carving it into something that they're not willing to share. Since their primary goal is to help business, they can't help but disapprove; since they don't explicitly state this goal, they have no nominal basis to reject it without rejecting Free Software in general.
I predict some eventual announcement that the license is "effectively closed source" and instead of accompanying that announcement with a specific supporting argument, they'll accompany it with a questionable written history of the OSI. They'll disapprove, or approve with asterisk.
edit: and, of course, what kemitchell said.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Since their primary goal is to help business, they can't help but disapprove; since they don't explicitly state this goal, they have no nominal basis to reject it without rejecting Free Software in general. Without engaging with your characterization of OSI motives, the OSI has a clear basis to reject it without rejecting Free Software in general; unlike all other existing Free Software licenses, SSPL (which might be Free Software) violates criterion 9 of the Open Source definition by restricting licensing of other software not derivative of, or part of a shared work with, the software originally distributed under the SSPL.
- bad_user 8y agoI've been a Free Software supporter for my entire carrier. Let's get one thing clear ... this change by MongoDB Inc wasn't done for preserving user freedom, but for preserving their bottom line. Spinning it into anything else is dishonest. And this is not Free Software in my book because it violates Freedom 0. And I hope the FSF never approves it, or if it does, it just goes to show that the FSF is corrupted.