4 ms·
The statement of the Jackson's team can be read as constructive skepticism or it can be read as FUD. In both cases they can use the same polite tone. It's diffi
by gus_massa 8y ago
The statement of the Jackson's team can be read as constructive skepticism or it can be read as FUD. In both cases they can use the same polite tone. It's difficult to distinguish them without reading carefully the technical objections to understand if they have some specific criticism or just generic concern.
My guess is that the easiest way to solve the controversy is to build three or four more detectors, and try to build a second team to make an independent analysis of the data. (But this is not cheap.)
(This is similar to the Atlas/CMS teams at CERN. They share the accelerator but they have independent detectors and analysis.)
- sleavey 8y agoThree or four more detectors is definitely not easy. The current ones were built, tuned and retuned over 25 years, and with approximately $1B spending on the US side alone (ignoring efforts in Europe, Japan, Australia, Brazil, Malaysia, etc). There are early plans for new detectors but to surpass the sensitivity of the existing network they will need even larger, more expensive facilities and equipment - unfortunately pushing the boundaries of human understanding is expensive.