4 ms·
Javascript ist also required for the vast majority of web-based exploits. I find it somewhat strange that you ask me to make my system less secure so you can be
by xg15 8y ago
Javascript ist also required for the vast majority of web-based exploits. I find it somewhat strange that you ask me to make my system less secure so you can better secure my account.
- whack 8y agoLike the blog post mentioned, 99.9% of users already have JS enabled, and this number is only going to go up as websites rely more and more on JS. For them, this is a purely beneficial change, with no downsides. It's somewhat selfish for you to ask that your system be made more secure, even at the cost of security for 99.9% of other users.
- knieveltech 8y agoAn error only becomes a mistake when you refuse to correct it.
- z3t4 8y agoI'm hijacking this thread to say we need a better ID system for the web! That preferably work without JS. Something built into browsers, that also allow you to create as many identities you want. When a id-signup header is detected, the user see a signup button, and can chose what information is sent to the web site/app. The user can login to any site with the push of a button, or even automatically. With a built in public-private key ID solution your friends will have the same ID-public-key on both site A and site B. The contact list can even be inside the browser, and web site's can ask for it, allowing for example white-listing in messenger apps, or let the user pick who are allowed to see their family pictures, etc. And web sites/app no longer have to store, username/password/keys, they only have to make a "challenge" where the browser automatically proves the ID. The private key should be exportable and standardized, and it should be possible to also use smart-cards and second factor logins. Having ID built into the browser means every site/app no longer have to build and manage all this functionality independently.
- plankers 8y agoThis is brilliant! Has the IETF put out any proposals for a standard of this sort or is this just an idea you had?
- mikepurvis 8y agoUnsure if sarcasm, but OpenID has been a thing for over ten years, and the only place it's ever gained significant traction is with Facebook and Google as the providers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenID#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenID#History Other than StackExchange, I can think of no other major site who looked at the over-engineered protocol, the implementation headaches, the confusing user experience (nascar board of provider logos), and said "yes, that is definitely what we want to have rather than a validated user email address."
- pas 8y agoChrome supports U2F and that is basically a client cert based ID. But yes, the browser should be able to manage identities on a per domain basis.
- mrep 8y ago> The contact list can even be inside the browser, and web site's can ask for it, allowing for example white-listing in messenger apps, or let the user pick who are allowed to see their family pictures, etc. How would that work for sites like Hacker news, reddit, and twitter? Does every single user have to preview and approve every single other user on the website? That doesn't scale at all.
- z3t4 8y agoIt would work the same, except you can sign up with one click, login with one click, and the server wouldn't store any password/key. But it also allows for additional functionality, for example in a photo sharing app/site you could tell it that only those with these ID's should be able to see the picture, without the site/app needing to know who those people are, they don't even need to have an account on that site.
- admax88q 8y agoOne of the reasons that the percentage of users who have JS enabled continually goes up is because web developers make their sites non-functional when JS is disabled.
- ihuman 8y agoThen just turn Javascript on to log in, then turn it back off again. You just need Javascript for the sign-on page.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 8y agoThen just get your wallet out to use the ATM in the dodgy neighbourhood and put it away again. You just need your wallet for the ATM in the dodgy neighbourhood.
- dwild 8y ago> the vast majority of web-based exploits Do you have a source for that? As far as I know, most web based exploit came from any external plugin such as flash, pdf, videos, etc...
- nova22033 8y ago> Javascript ist also required for the vast majority of web-based exploits. So are browsers...