3 ms·
>Like Redis Labs before it, MongoDB has concluded that this license allows a bit too much. In particular, cloud providers are offering access to MongoDB instanc
by weinzierl 8y ago
>Like Redis Labs before it, MongoDB has concluded that this license allows a bit too much. In particular, cloud providers are offering access to MongoDB instances without cutting the company in on the resulting revenue stream, and that doesn't feel right. In response, MongoDB has just announced an immediate shift to its brand-new Server Side Public License (SSPL).
This paragraph conflates Redis' application of the Commons Clause [1] to its add-ons with the switch of the license for MongoDB from AGPL to its own license called SSPL[2].
This are in my eyes two very different things.
The Commons Clause is a commercial restriction and its creators are very clear about the fact that it is not an Open Source license.
The SSPL, on the other hand is, in my opinion, an adaption of the GPL to new distribution channels that goes even further than the AGPL. I see this as very much in line with the original spirit of the GPL, regardless whether MogoDB's motivation might be primarily commercial or not. These are just my 2 ct from a curious glance and I'd be very much interested how RMS sees this, I hope we will get a statement from him or the GNU project.
>There is a lesson here for contributors as well. The request for license approval notes that: "As of this writing, the MongoDB GITHUB repository shows over 43,000 commits, 680 releases, and over 350 contributors." To become one of those contributors, a developer must first sign MongoDB's contributor agreement, which assigns copyright ownership to MongoDB. Those contributors all gave MongoDB the right to relicense their code in this manner [...]
CLAs are pretty common nowadays and they can be a problem for potential contributors but pointing at MongoDB, for just doing what many other large OpenSource projects do, isn't fair.
[1] https://commonsclause.com/ https://commonsclause.com/
[2] https://www.mongodb.com/licensing/server-side-public-license https://www.mongodb.com/licensing/server-side-public-license
- cyphar 8y ago> I see this as very much in line with the original spirit of the GPL, regardless whether MogoDB's motivation might be primarily commercial or not. I disagree. GPL was never about relicensing other people's software. The SSPL basically requires this if you read Section 13. > CLAs are pretty common nowadays and they can be a problem for potential contributors but pointing at MongoDB, for just doing what many other large OpenSource projects do, isn't fair. Just because many projects do this doesn't mean it's a good thing to do -- the FSF CLA is the only CLA I would find acceptable because it's purpose is to ensure they can relicense to later GPL versions as well as have litigation rights in the US. Several other "CLAs" (like Apache's) are actually just beefed up versions of the DCO. But unconditional and asymmetric CLAs are the reason that OpenSolaris could become proprietary under Oracle, as well as many other horror stories in the history of free software. Many people use them, but that doesn't justify it.
- bad_user 8y agoYes, the difference is that Redis' application of the Commons Clause isn't hypocritical.