4 ms·
True enough in the general case as you say, but in this specific case, the data in question was (reportedly) a good fit for a pre-existing model. They made a p
by CamperBob2 8y ago
True enough in the general case as you say, but in this specific case, the data in question was (reportedly) a good fit for a pre-existing model. They made a prediction, ran an experiment, observed the predicted effect, drew a conclusion, and got a Nobel for their trouble.
So the burden of proof is decisively on the accuser here, I'd think.