4 ms·
> Allow them to secede? Is that a serious question? If a people no longer wants to be part of a country they should be allowed to secede. The Scottish tried it
by Cthulhu_ 8y ago
> Allow them to secede?
Is that a serious question? If a people no longer wants to be part of a country they should be allowed to secede. The Scottish tried it via a democratic route - which would have succeeded with a wide margin post-Brexit. Actually, the British voted to secede from the EU. The Catalans want to secede from Spain.
But that's besides the point - you're almost implying that it's OK to put people in concentration camps.
- CPLX 8y ago> Is that a serious question? If a people no longer wants to be part of a country they should be allowed to secede. While I am not defending China whatsoever in this specific case it’s worth noting that premise is highly debatable — essentially the definition of a serious question.
- toxik 8y agoThe EU is not a nation state Scotland has a very unique history in this Catalunya is not gaining independence and the central Madrid government has declared their referendum illegitimate and illegal. People cannot vote their way to secession, even in democracies.
- pjc50 8y agoSecession has pretty much always had to be fought for (US, Ireland), but peaceful (Czechslovakia) and semi-peaceful (India) secession is possible.
- int_19h 8y agoThat depends on the democracy. You mentioned Scotland already (and there's nothing particularly unique about it). Then there's Canada, where the Supreme Court has specifically outlined the rules for Quebec (or any other province) to secede - but acknowledged that there is a basic right to do so. One could argue that ability to handle peaceful secession is simply the next stage in evolution of liberal democracy, and those that allow for it are more advanced than those that do not.
- trhway 8y ago>People cannot vote their way to secession, even in democracies. Crimea people did :)