4 ms·
What a bunch of, excuse the language, paternalist fear-mongering bullshit. Of course Google wants you to enable JS, because it allows them to monitor and track
by userbinator 8y ago
What a bunch of, excuse the language, paternalist fear-mongering bullshit. Of course Google wants you to enable JS, because it allows them to monitor and track everything about you more easily. Twisting it into "this will make you safer" is sad and undeniably repugnant.
I've noticed a lot of other sites practically begging you to "enable JavaScript for a better experience", when all their content is static text and images. I fell for that once, a long time ago --- enabled JS briefly to see what the big deal was --- and was promptly bombarded with popups, slide-overs, and even more ads. No thank you, I'll keep it off.
For many years I used IE6 with JS off (and a whitelist for a very, very small number of selected and highly-trusted sites. IE has a "security zone" feature which to my knowledge no other browser comes with by default.) Not a single malware infection, and that's despite often visiting the... shadier parts of the Internet.
Browser exploits are almost all JS-based, and even the few that aren't, are in practice deployed using obfuscation involving JS, to make analysis and detection harder. Turning off JS effectively kills those risks as well as other annoyances (blocking right-click, text selection, injecting crap into copied content, etc.)
IMHO the advantages of not having JS on by default are underrated. I'd consider ~99% of the sites I come across when searching for content to not require it at all, which certainly is a stark contrast from the "you'll break the Internet!" screams of the JS-advocates and "web designers". Sites that "break" from not having JS, and which aren't specifically "appsites" but mostly content-sites, are not worth visiting anyway.
Perhaps it's time to raise a counter-movement, and add (via <script> tags, of course) "you have JavaScript turned on in your browser, this is a security risk! Click <here> (link to appropriate page with all the risks and how to turn it off) to learn more." Or "You have JavaScript enabled, please disable it for a better experience."
If a certain vocal minority managed to demonise Flash (another powerful technology that had major uses) to almost completely kill it, maybe the same can happen for JavaScript?
- throwawaymath 8y ago> Browser exploits are almost all JS-based, and even the few that aren't, are in practice deployed using obfuscation involving JS, to make analysis and detection harder. Go take a look through Pwn2Own. Most browser exploits do not involve JavaScript. JavaScript can be a delivery mechanism for a certain class of payloads, but it's not the substantial weakness in browser vulnerabilities (as opposed to web application vulnerabilities). Given that this isn't familiar to you, I'd recommend you reevaluate how confident you are in the JavaScript-focused defenses you've outlined in the rest of your comment.
- userbinator 8y agoJavaScript can be a delivery mechanism for a certain class of payloads That's exactly what I'm saying --- in the real world, exploits tend to be wrapped in JS even if they don't technically need it. but it's not the substantial weakness in browser vulnerabilities Then what is? My real-world experience also correlates.
- throwawaymath 8y ago> Then what is? My real-world experience also correlates. HTML (non-JS) parsing, memory corruption, image processing, filetype validation and process isolation/sandboxing.
- dane-pgp 8y agoThe security bugs found during Pwn2Own are usually kept under embargo, and only published later by the browser developers. Here's an article about a Chrome bug found in 2017's Pwn2Own: https://www.computerworld.com/article/3186686/web-browsers/google-patches-chrome-bug-from-fizzled-pwn2own-hack.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/3186686/web-browsers/g... and it does involve JavaScript. Could you provide some recent examples of the sort of browser exploits you mean, that don't require JavaScript? (I assume you're not including exploits in extensions/plugins like Flash or PDF viewers.)
- userbinator 8y agoThe Firefox Pwn2Own... https://www.computerworld.com/article/3183264/security/mozilla-beats-rivals-patches-firefoxs-pwn2own-bug.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/3183264/security/mozil... ...is also JavaScript-related: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1348168 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1348168
- throwawaymath 8y agoSure: https://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-1224/product_id-15031/opec-1/Google-Chrome.html https://www.cvedetails.com/vulnerability-list/vendor_id-1224.... Also look at Google Project Zero writeups, and similar CVE details for Firefox and Safari. Some are related to JavaScript (notably, it's hard to exploit V8 if the browser isn't processing any JavaScript!). But the vast majority are memory corruption and sandbox escape issues. Disabling JavaScript insulates you from a nontrivial - but nontheless minority - subset of browser vulnerabilities.
- 2RTZZSro 8y agoLook at all the replies. Everybody is ignoring the elephant in the room, instead desperately focusing on socially acceptable ridicule of OP's diatribe on security. Wake up people. > Of course Google wants you to enable JS, because it allows them to monitor and track everything about you more easily. Twisting it into "this will make you safer" is sad and undeniably repugnant. What Google is evolving into, whether consciously or not, is the equivalent of IBM punch card compatible identification tattoos that were were part of the system of Jewish identification in Nazi camps. Pretty soon your every action will be tracked throughout the Internet and you will be uniquely identified at every site you go to whether you want it or not. Intelligence agencies will know exactly what you are thinking all the time with a nice RabbitMQ feed from major internet sites that downloads your mouse movement and key stroke pattern fingerprint along with your post contents and associates it with your https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XKeyscore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XKeyscore account. You will have lost all anonymity. Online access will be increasingly restricted and major sites will only become accessible to those deemed worthy by a central social credit score rating agency. Research the consequences of China's social credit system if you want a taste of the future and don't care to learn about what the Nazis did to Jews. Downvote me at your own peril. Downvoters are useful idiots and next on the chopping block. The 21st century equivalent of Nazi concentration camp gate keepers who were just "doing their job."
- perl4ever 8y ago"Pretty soon your every action will be tracked throughout the Internet" You're saying soon the computers that make up the internet will gain the capabilities of IBM machinery of the 1930s?
- moolcool 8y agoGoogle's tracking everything you do on _their properties_ to begin with because they're a marketing company. Use DuckDuckGo if you don't like that. The pearl clutching in this thread is unreal.