11 ms·
Musk shakes up SpaceX in race to make satellite launch window: sources
- Nomentatus 8y agoInteresting comparison - how important firing (actually, relieving) high numbers of generals is in war, when the rubber has to hit the road. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxZWxxZ2JGE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxZWxxZ2JGE
- cagenut 8y agomy dad taught me a phrase from back in the bell-labs/telco-heyday that has stayed with me as timeless "eventually you have to decide its time to shoot the engineers and ship the product"
- AVTizzle 8y agoRead that at a glance as "taco bell heyday". Now I'm wondering if the phrase still applies.
- CamperBob2 8y agoI like the quote about putting Comcast out of business, but I don't know that I would have said as much publicly.
- StillBored 8y agoIt might not be comcast that dies, but rather a couple of the cell phone vendors. Those are the businesses that are making bank on what is basically low bandwidth wide area coverage. Given the transmission path is going to be going up, it seems that a lot of the existing problems with topology and buildings getting it the way will be reduced. Anyway, I'm in a town with google fiber, but can't get more than a 30Mbit uplink on spectrum (which is actually faster than AT&T) because the only places in town with competition are the areas already served by google fiber. It won't take much to kill these lumbering giants that refuse to invest in their infrastructure. Particularly given the ill will most people feel towards them.
- neuromancer2701 8y agoAmen, I am in a smaller city in Central Va. If you go more than 10 minutes outside the city no Comcast. There is a local cable company but it is 3x the Comcast price for half the speed. I can be 15 minutes outside of the city and have no internet options.
- jccooper 8y agoStarlink service will not compete with cell phones; the terminals are too large. If anything, it will complement cell service, by making tower backhaul easier. It's also unlikely to directly compete with wired ISPs in cities, as the bandwidth required for everyone to have a terminal would be high. But it could enable unwired 5G stations as micro-ISPs, which would be a similar effect. What it will kill are rural or undeveloped area ISPs (such as they are) and provide high threat to undersea cables and cross-country fiber.
- mmjaa 8y agoAll of the above is positive, in my opinion. As long as the Starlink sats somehow, eventually, fall out of corporate hands. I mean, such infinite power...
- mmjaa 8y agoWhat on earth do you mean? Everyone online, i.e. in the general public, hates on Comcast. Disclaimer: Never been a customer. Started my own ISP's instead.
- walrus01 8y agoStarlink is highly ambitious. What they're trying to do is basically a miniature version of the o3b network MEO architecture, where every CPE terminal needs to track two satellites simultaneously. The difference is that an o3b terminal starts from about $30,000 , they're trying to build something with a CPE cost under $700. This is literally a "has never been done before" satellite communications challenge. The only thing comparable for LEO based services is the Iridium architecture, which is designed around a very different use case and data rate (about 3600 bps, for the first gen stuff).
- jpatokal 8y ago...and Iridium famously resulted in the largest US bankruptcy ever, nine months after launch: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_Communications#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_Communications#History Initial investment ~$6B, sold to US gov't for $25m. Here's hoping Spacex has better luck.
- walrus01 8y agoYes, and the successor corporation of Iridium which bought it out of bankruptcy, and renamed itself to Iridium, has been wildly successful in the maritime, government, aviation, exploration/expedition, military markets. Which is where having a 2400 to 3600 baud (or voice and SMS) service that functions literally anywhere on the planet, pole to pole, is a highly desirable service. The original 1998-2000 marketing materials for Iridium are ridiculous, like a traveling executive is going to take a gargantuan expensive satellite phone with them when traveling internationally, rather than relying on GSM roaming agreements.
- jpatokal 8y agoWildly successful after $6b in debt was written off, and only in a small (but profitable) niche, not the originally envisioned mass market. I know it sounds ridiculous now, but the original plan for Iridium was to replace that traveling exec's GSM phone, with the expectation that handset size & pricing would drop as the service grew.
- nemo44x 8y agoI'm amazed how little coverage Starlink, OneWeb, etc get. It's the next revolution and the most important tech since the smart phone. Think about the great firewall of China. It's dead after this. Having a cell provider and home internet provider. Gone. Poor bandwidth anywhere on Earth - a thing of the past. This is important and huge. Buy rural property that is undeveloped. In 10 years time you'll be able to power it with solar and battery arrays and connect it with these satellites. A self driving carriage will deliver whatever goods you need the same day. Water is a well away and a septic tank isn't difficult to build.
- IBM 8y agoHow would it do anything about the great firewall? All of these services will need their regulatory approval to operate there. Also China has an anti-satellite missile program. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASAT_program_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASAT_program_of_China
- burfog 8y agoIridium didn't escape national regulations. Why would this? If this system is to be operable in China, an agreement must be reached. That might mean a firewall for all people in China, all Chinese citizens everywhere, or both. Operating without permission from China would generate a complaint to the USA. The USA is obligated to enforce international RF restrictions on satellites operated by US companies.
- jon_richards 8y agoIt's going to be pirate radio all over again. How long do you think the USA will exert complete control over a privatised space industry? I'd bet the first satellite shootings will happen over copyright violations, not national security.
- gonesilent 8y agoYup I agree, wiki from space will get it taken out first.
- bathMarm0t 8y agoMaybe this is an obvious question, but is spacex allowed to bump / not take orders from its opponents in favor of its own internet satellites? That would effectively force any competitor to launch with someone more expensive, allowing spacex to corner the space-internet market on cost, right?
- shaklee3 8y agoYes. Just like Samsung can stop selling Apple screens. But they don't, because spacex is hurting for revenue, and satellite launch forecasts have slowed substantially.
- jccooper 8y agoSpaceX can fly--or not--whomever they want. And they are, in fact, not flying their competitors. OneWeb is booked on a variety of SpaceX competitors: Arianespace (mostly Soyuz, but also optionally Ariane 6), Virgin, and Blue Origin. SpaceX certainly hopes this gives them an advantage, and it probably does, though eventually someone is bound to copy them if they prove successful. Blue Origin is already well on their way to a Falcon 9-alike. Launch is also only part of the cost of a satellite constellation.
- lorenzhs 8y agoSoyuz is Roscosmos, not Arianespace. Maybe you meant Vega? But that’s a much smaller launcher.
- shaklee3 8y agoThis headline is not as negative as the article (or reality): "Within hours of landing, Musk had fired at least seven members of the program’s senior management team at the Redmond, Washington, office, the culmination of disagreements over the pace at which the team was developing and testing its Starlink satellites" Their progress is slower than musk wanted, and of that of the competitors telesat and oneweb from what's public. He was firing because the project isn't going well.
- Animats 8y agoHow'd that approach of firing the people who said it wasn't going to happen that fast work out at Tesla?
- restalis 8y agoThis is the context in which companies end up with slick players who's primary skill is to reframe the metrics and sell the idea of progress regardless of what's going on in reality.
- dmix 8y agoThat's a bit presumptive. This assumes that the executives don't ask any hard questions and believe everything the managers tell them without ever really digging into the problems. Or that the hiring/promotion process is broken enough to let people who game the system slip through.
- soared 8y agoLooking at how they're doing right now - very well?
- Animats 8y agoWhat's worrisome is that Tesla was doing pretty well until Musk issued his edict to get the Tesla plant going too fast. Several of his manufacturing execs quit in 2016. They needed another year. It took another year, and Tesla's reputation took a big hit.