6 ms·
Expedia, Travelocity say Google has crossed the "creepy line"
- goatforce5 16y agoSo if ITA is so damn important to their business, why aren't Expedia, Travelocity, et al forming a consortium to go and buy ITA?
- ojbyrne 16y agoBecause Google have already bought it?
- borism 16y agoand because ITA itself is not important for them. Losing control of the information that goes from ITA to consumers is why they make a fuss out of this.
- alecco 16y agoTheir GDSs are crap sometimes still running on mainframes. Also the airline fares scam comes from the same groups. They purposely keept alternatives out for decades. Karma.
- fraserharris 16y agoSearch engines are expanding from web searches to information searches. Since search users were really after information in the first place, it's hard to argue Google isn't providing better search results.
- yanw 16y agoCompanies like Expedia worry that the acquisition could lead Google to present a matrix of actual fares on its search results page How is that not consumer positive?
- bobf 16y agoThat seems to be the crux of the issue. Consumer positive is apparently not in Expedia/Travelocity's best interests. Dredging up old Stanford-days quotes of Google's founders seems a bit disingenuous.
- alecco 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabre_(computer_system)#Controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabre_(computer_system)#Controv...
- mkramlich 16y agoTo the extent it's not consumer positive it's like Windows and IE, vs Netscape, et al. Windows and Word, vs other word processors, etc. By Google integrating and promoting their own information service at the top of search results it's very similar to Microsoft bundling, promoting and defaulting to their own in-house equivalents to what would otherwise be third-party apps sold by separate businesses. Is that a net win for consumers? Not sure. It's both good and bad. But it's definitely a chilling effect for those other vendors -- assuming they don't get a juicy buyout or licensing deal in order to be adapted into the very thing they would otherwise fear. In this case, an integrated travel search promoted by Google.
- ceejayoz 16y ago> By Google integrating and promoting their own information service at the top of search results it's very similar to Microsoft bundling, promoting and defaulting to their own in-house equivalents to what would otherwise be third-party apps sold by separate businesses. Sort of, but it's as if Microsoft is still stuck on the IE3 release and grumping about Mozilla Firefox 4 being better. The Expedia quote basically says "dear God, Google might actually make a usable fare finder instead of presenting users with a useless interface designed to make it hard to find the actual low fares we promote!"
- exit 16y agodo reference librarians have an anticompetitive practices case against google?
- ZeroMinx 16y agoI just want a good web search for finding and booking flights. Expedia and friends could work on improving their websites instead of complaining.. Just tried Expedia now, flying London - Stockholm in December. Next screen I could choose "specific dates" or "flexible". Clicking flexible, page reloaded, saying "This route doesn't support that". So then I clicked "specific dates". This threw me back to the front page, with the flight search form empty. They won't find much sympathy from me..
- Retric 16y agoIf Expedia was worth using then people would go back to it vs. praying that Google will come up with something better. I want a travel site that gives Google style search results based on my preferred time of day, start and end locations, and price. If it's 200 dollars cheaper to use a less convenient airport or an evening flight then show it to me but I would rather use the local airport etc. Yet, the only option for most people is to use all these crappy search systems to build such a list by hand. PS: Expedia does not even provide suggestions when someone has a typo EX: 'Washinton DC'. It then asks which one of several local airports to use (you can't pick more than one). No wonder they are afraid of Google.
- benologist 16y agoThe article raises a pretty good point regardless of what fixable usability issue some site has: "Companies like Expedia worry that the acquisition could lead Google to present a matrix of actual fares on its search results page, above all of the other sites that sell tickets. At that point, the key question becomes: which sites will Google's results link to, and what (if anything) will be the cost of those links?" This affects more than just entrenched guys, it means newcomers will also have to buy their way to the top as well.
- lmkg 16y agoNot to defend Expedia, but if Google puts their own travel results on the front page, improving Expedia's website wouldn't help them. It could be made of gold-plated strippers, but no one would ever find out because they'd just use Google's flight search, even if Google's flight search sucked. Not that Google would make a crappy flight search (especially with ITA), but the point is that even if other companies did innovate and did make a better flight search that is theoretically better for the consumer, that still wouldn't be able to beat Google putting their own thingy on the front SERP. Don't get me wrong, Google's move is probably better for the consumer and Expedia does suck and deserves to get crushed on its own merit (or lack thereof), but despite that, "just do a better job" is not a viable option, and Expedia's complaints that Google has an anticompetitive advantage are legitimate.
- eljaco 16y agohipmunk.com and bing.com/travel are doing an awesome job with making it easier for all of us. Hopefully Google can do the same or (hopefully) better.
- bemmu 16y agoNow that you mention Hipmunk, I just became convinced that Google will acquire them. A market they are interested in with a small team of talented hackers with a product with proven traction, who probably wouldn't mind working for Google on their own project (since the lead dev already worked in a similar arrangement before) if the price is right.
- kn0thing 16y agoBemmu, we're gonna have to pay you a commission soon ;) thanks, dude.
- jfb 16y agoEverybody draws their own creepy line. Expedia & Travelocity draw theirs up at the edge of their shitty, consumer-hostile business models.
- rjett 16y agoThis is just a last-ditch effort by these sites to retain their only competitive advantage: privileged access to ITA data. I don't see anything "creepy" about this merger though...classic fear-mongering.
- sprout 16y agoThe last time I tried to buy a ticket, I failed to find anyone among them who recognized + as a valid character to have in an email address. I'm not sure whether their engineers are incompetent, or just looking to spam me. Well, I know the latter is true, but the former is up for debate. In any case, I'm looking forward to people selling tickets that won't require me to give them my root email address, and probably won't even want to spam me.
- netaustin 16y agoI have long wondered why airlines don't put considerably more pressure on online brokers than they do, and I think this debate is missing their perspective. They would probably agree that airfares on the first page of search results would benefit consumers. Look at the about page on FairSearch.org. No airlines!
- ghurlman 16y agoAlso no Orbitz - owned by airlines.
- khandelwal 16y agoI believe Orbitz is no longer owned by the airlines. It started off that way, though.
- chrisaycock 16y agoOrbitz is a publicly traded company whose largest shareholder is Blackstone. It is NOT owned by the airlines: http://moneycentral.msn.com/ownership?Holding=Institutional+Ownership&Symbol=OWW http://moneycentral.msn.com/ownership?Holding=Institutional+...
- binarymax 16y agoStrange. At these companies inception they presumably had no issue shoving 'middleman' travel agents out of the picture. They are now the middleman. Innovate or be disrupted.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoStill, its a short step to Google putting their own travel results at the top of every travel-related search. Its got to improve Google ticket-sales conversions and hurt others. Its a bit (a lot) anticompetitive, for sure. But the alternative is, nationalize Google like the post office, and regulate them.
- bonzoesc 16y agoFlight searching/booking services are such a circlejerk already; some of them even provide ways to comparison-shop with other search services, a meta-meta-economy of sorts. That said, I just use ITA + southwest.com because all the other aggregators are too marketing-driven, and Southwest doesn't "do" aggregators but I like them.
- hyperbovine 16y agoThis is why we don't build our entire business on the back of a third-party vendor.
- alecco 16y agoOld GDS-backed oligopolistic portals with their deals under the table deserve this and 1000x more. Come on Google/Ita!
- chrisaycock 16y agoThe list of companies supporting Fair Search is a bit disingenuous. There's a lot of double-counting to make it look like more firms are against the Google move. Expedia owns both TripAdvisor and Hotwire. Sabre Holdings owns Travelocity (and is a direct competitor to ITA). Kayak owns SideStep.
- nhashem 16y agoFor what it's worth, Expedia actually uses its own fare search and pricing engine, called Best Fare Search. http://www.tnooz.com/2010/05/10/news/if-google-reins-in-ita-software-would-expedia-ride-to-metasearch-rescue/ http://www.tnooz.com/2010/05/10/news/if-google-reins-in-ita-... If anything if Google acquires ITA and exercises tyrannical control over the data, it could open a door for Expedia to license their data to companies like Kayak and TripAdvisor.
- chc 16y agoSounds more like Expedia and Travelocity have crossed the "afraid of competition line." There's nothing creepy about Google providing flight info. These companies are just repeating any negative things they've heard said about Google, and they're not even being subtle about it. This definitely makes me like Orbitz more.