4 ms·
Something similar happened to Racket a few years ago with AVG. IIRC I just send an email to one or two of the antivirus companies and they fixed the problem in
by gus_massa 8y ago
Something similar happened to Racket a few years ago with AVG. IIRC I just send an email to one or two of the antivirus companies and they fixed the problem in a few days.
Anyone can send the report of the false positive to the AV companies. I don't understand why nobody took a few minutes to solve this.
- smt88 8y agoDoes it just mean very few D devs use Windows?
- gus_massa 8y agoI decided to try to solve it myself. I don't get any warning with Windows Defender (Win10). With VirusTotal I got only one report https://www.virustotal.com/#/file/e02d6aff4b59b2f66ed21fb74e7d5688ec0a552df6a156df78937140a08f6293/detection https://www.virustotal.com/#/file/e02d6aff4b59b2f66ed21fb74e... by Tencent . I went to the webpage of Tencent but I can't find the correct way to report a false positive. Most of the contact page is in Chinese, but I don't speak Chinese (Hi from Argentina!) I'm in doubt if I will send the report to whoever looks more relevant, or just forget about this.
- destructionator 8y agoI just whitelisted the entire directory for windows defender, and I know a lot of other D devs do the same. (Without that, even my own programs I compile will have startup lag - it doesn't flag them, but it takes an extra half second to run the program, presumably scanning it first, which is infuriating for an edit/compile/test cycle.) So for us who are already in, it is a "solved" problem. I recognize it doesn't help first timers though.
- WalterBright 8y agoDevs learn pretty quick to turn off AV. It's nigh impossible to run a test suite with AV on, for example, because it tries to scan/flag every executable built during the tests. After hearing "Wolf! Wolf!" a few thousand times, one is done with AV.
- smt88 8y agoIs there a reason this happens with D, but not with Rust, C++, or C#? I think if I had to turn Windows Defender off, it'd be better to just switch to *nix (which I assume doesn't have similar false positive problems for whatever reason).
- trothamel 8y agoIt's one of those things where it's a few minutes per company per release. And then you make a new release, and have to do it again. And again. And again. As a volunteer, it's hard to do that for software that seems to be financially motivated to report false positives, so the users can pretend the money they give antivirus companies is worthwhile.
- gus_massa 8y agoIn my case it was only one or two companies in only one release. It was not necessary to resubmit it in every release. Also, I understand that this is not top priority and that is a nice small task to be delegated to one of the newest contributors, specially the one that have the problem and are using the obscure AV. But after a few months, it's time to say "whatever" and try to solve it. [Anyway, I tried an hour ago, it's not so easy. See my other comment.]