4 ms·
I'm very excited for this. I have a pretty nasty love/hate relationship with my personal Thinkpad P51. It's a fantastic device on paper, and the build quality i
by jchw 8y ago
I'm very excited for this. I have a pretty nasty love/hate relationship with my personal Thinkpad P51. It's a fantastic device on paper, and the build quality is great to match, but... I try to boot Linux and I remember why Linus once gave Nvidia the finger all over again. Even on Thinkpad, issues you wouldn't see with nearly any Linux desktop system crop up when Optimus is thrown into the mix. Nouveau actually outperforms proprietary Nvidia drivers in certain circumstances, which had me extraordinarily confused.
It would be nice to boot into a laptop actually designed to use Linux from the ground up. And I don't mean what Dell does - I'm grateful for what they do, but I really want unmodified Linux to work as well on my laptop as it does on nearly any desktop I've built. System76, with both properties that they are going open with firmware and designs, AND building entirely for Linux, seems perfect to me.
I wonder a lot about their stated goal of a completely open compute platform. Sure, there's ISAs like RISC-V on the horizon, but I get the feeling many components like GPUs are quite far away from having open source equivalents that can act as drop-in replacements. There's a whole lot more than raw computation in modern CPUs and certainly more in the motherboard. Id still be moderately pleased with a "mostly" open platform, which is better than today where your choices are basically Lemote Yeeloong or something useful but nearly entirely closed off.
- shmerl 8y agoAvoid Optimus like a plague if you are using Linux. There are quite decent Thinkpads with Ryzen/Vega APUs these days (like A485) which should work fine with upstream kernel and Mesa. But of course it's still Lenovo, so various blobs like UEFI remain.
- techntoke 8y agoWhile I agree generally on most distros, it works really well with Arch and is pretty easy to setup: - https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/NVIDIA_Optimus https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/NVIDIA_Optimus - https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/PRIME https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/PRIME
- jchw 8y agoArch Linux is nearly entirely unusable with this Thinkpad, which is a shame since that's my distro of choice usually. I fiddled with drivers for a good while but was getting severe issues hanging with proprietary Nvidia, and Nouveau simply crashed on boot. I'm currently on Fedora, which is one of the few distros that seemed to work without crashing all the time.
- blacksoil 8y agoMost painless config for me is to enable Nvidia only when I really need it. Say when I need to run a graphic-heavy application I spawn up a new X11 process running atop Nvidia drivers. For daily stuffs, I stick with Intel drivers
- Shikadi 8y agoI got Arch working fine on a Thinkpad with a GTX 900m series card. I just followed the guide for bumblebee. This was a good number of years ago though, but it still works with updates and all
- shmerl 8y agoNvidia blob doesn't really support PRIME properly. You can't use integrated GPU (Intel) to run your DE, while offloading specific heavy tasks to discrete one (Nvidia) which is kind of the main point. If you want to use PRIME, stick to AMD / Mesa.
- cpburns2009 8y agoAre you sure about that? I could swear when I was running Arch the DE was using my Intel GPU. I used either optirun or primusrun to use the Nvidia GPU. Granted, it was a pain to setup and I never could figure out why HDMI connected to a monitor would not work but was fine with a TV.
- shmerl 8y ago> I used either optirun or primusrun Neither is PRIME. PRIME would mean doing something like: DRI_PRIME=1 glxinfo Which will run it on one GPU, and display through another. Bumblebee is a workaround for this mess, not a proper upstream solution.
- sricks3 8y agoWhen did support for the APUs get added to the kernel? My wife got fed up with Windows a couple of years ago, and I tried to set up a dual boot on her HP laptop, but Ubuntu wouldn't display anything above 800x600. The best I could tell was that there just wasn't support (at the time) for her AMD APU, but I can't remember which model it was. All the drivers I found on the AMD website only officially supported 14.04, but even 14.04 wouldn't recognize the proper screen resolutions. I've been meaning to try again since 18.04 was released (or at least see if anything had been added to the kernel), but I haven't gotten around to it yet. Fingers crossed...
- opencl 8y agoDepends on which APU you have and which features you need. The latest Raven Ridge APUs had stability problems until 4.17, anything older should work on 18.04 which ships 4.15. HDMI/Displayport audio support for the older models landed in 4.15 but wasn't enabled by default until 4.17, so in 4.15-4.16 you have to pass the amdgpu.dc=1 kernel parameter for it work.
- shmerl 8y agoI recommend 4.19+ if you are planning to use one with Vega. Anything lower will have problems. Don't use drivers from AMD site, use upstream kernel and latest Mesa release.
- soulnothing 8y agoI have the A485, Windows is oddly a shit show with drivers. But linux is great with Arch and proton gaming. With the fat battery, it has great battery to boot I will say Ryzen APU is very janky. The new model should be coming soon. Though it took a year and half for the first mobile apus to become obtainable.
- shmerl 8y ago> The new model should be coming soon. Do you mean ones with Zen 2 / Navi? It might take a while, CPUs and GPUs aren't even out yet.
- nickik 8y agoFor a GPU we might get something based on RISC-V but not open source. That would already be a huge improvement if that was based on the RISC-V Vector ISA. Esperanto systems will sell an IP core called ET-Graphics that should be able to handle a laptop workload. The question is just if somebody will actually build end-user computer with that product. Its designed for machine learning after all and that is their core business.
- sevensor 8y ago> And I don't mean what Dell does - I'm grateful for what they do, but I really want unmodified Linux to work as well on my laptop as it does on nearly any desktop I've built While I'm very happy to see the work System76 are doing, I don't think this characterization of Dell is quite right. I'm typing this comment on a Precision 5510 that runs Arch flawlessly. It runs Arch flawlessly because it's not burdened with NVidia graphics -- I can well imagine that would be a nightmare, as I have to deal with NVidia's terrible hardware on several workstations.
- jdiez17 8y agoI don't understand your assertion that unmodified Linux does not work "as well as on any desktop" on Dell laptops. I'm typing this on an XPS 13 9343, running the mainline Linux kernel from the Arch Linux repositories, and everything works flawlessly out of the box (WiFi, Bluetooth, touchpad, audio, OpenGL, webcam, extremely low power consumption, etc). To be fair, kernel patches were necessary to fix some issues with the behaviour of the sound card when the laptop was new, but right now everything as reliable is as you can hope for. Granted, it only has Intel's built-in GPU, but that is more than enough for what I do on this machine. Another thing I really like about Dell is that their products are designed to be repairable. The service manuals for their computers are freely available online[1] and even private customers can buy replacement parts directly from them. I've replaced the keyboard and the hinges on the screen before, and soon I will get a fresh battery to extend the life of this lovely machine even longer. [1] e.g. for my laptop: https://downloads.dell.com/manuals/all-products/esuprt_laptop/esuprt_xps_laptop/xps-13-9343-laptop_service%20manual_de-de.pdf https://downloads.dell.com/manuals/all-products/esuprt_lapto...
- jchw 8y agoMainline Linux eventually works on Dell laptops, like most vendors, but I've learned the hard way that this is far from guaranteed and out of the gate most laptops that come with Linux (not just Dell) are modified. You can see the disclaimer that Ubuntu puts on all their certifications: https://certification.ubuntu.com/hardware/201410-15913/ https://certification.ubuntu.com/hardware/201410-15913/ .. Which may well not apply to this laptop in particular, but it absolutely applies to laptops I've used. Notably absent from the certification list is the XPS 15, which is sad because personally it's the one I'd want. From what I've seen of Linux running on XPS 15, it isn't great, though it is "functional."
- sudo-i 8y agoTyping from my dell xps 15... what "isn't great" about it?
- gshulegaard 8y ago
- mcguire 8y agoSpeaking of System76, my 2011 Gazelle Pro has Nvidia graphics. It's never worked right, and is the only problem I've had. (Actually, it's a Sager Clevo.)
- bwat49 8y agoun-modified linux works fine on my xps 13 9360 I can throw basically any distro (at least anything that's fresher than debian stable) on it and all the hardware works out of the box a laptop with open firmware would certainly be nice though
- soulnothing 8y agoThis was the biggest pain point to me when looking for a new laptop. I wanted something where I could game after a day on the road lightly But no NVIDIA, It doesn't help AMD has subpar graphics performance per watt compared tt pascal. I will say all my intel thinkpads were flawless with arch. My new a485(ryzen apu) is almost there
- bachmeier 8y ago> And I don't mean what Dell does - I'm grateful for what they do, but I really want unmodified Linux to work as well on my laptop as it does on nearly any desktop I've built. Maybe I've been lucky, but over the last few years my rule has been "buy Dell" and Linux has just worked without any modifications. That includes laptops and desktops (I've replaced everything at home for everyone and at work) and I've never had problems.