5 ms·
People need to think very carefully about the consequences of any policy they propose to curb this sort of behavior. Do we really want Facebook making judgment
by andrewflnr 8y ago
People need to think very carefully about the consequences of any policy they propose to curb this sort of behavior. Do we really want Facebook making judgment calls about the content of political ads? Do they need to do thorough real-life identity verification of people buying any ads, or any ads that may be construed as political? Then the real kicker: does every ad provider need to do this, or just the ones that are too big to fail? Requiring that level of effort would quash small ad providers in the same way that onerous copyright verification laws would quash small content hosts. Not doing so has its own obvious problems.
I see no good solutions.
- RosanaAnaDana 8y agoPeople need to think very carefully So let me stop you right there...
- andrewflnr 8y agoYeah, well, I didn't say I was making a prediction. sigh
- jacobush 8y agoOr stopped to think carefully... badaboom! Try the veal.
- tracker1 8y agoHow much better would life be if there had to be an in-person verification for advertisers... along the lines of an EV cert. Man, how much crappy advertisements, scam, malware ads would just disappear if this were a requirement all around.
- andrewflnr 8y agoHmm. Maybe small players could outsource verification to specialists with economies of scale. It would let some crap through, but it might be worth it overall.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jamesrcole 8y ago> Then the real kicker: does every ad provider need to do this, or just the ones that are too big to fail? Requiring that level of effort would quash small ad providers in the same way that onerous copyright verification laws would quash small content hosts. It comes down to what you think is more important. Lessening false advertising that manipulates the democratic process (and of course the big question is to what extent this can be lessened by such policies) or having an environment conducive to small advertising companies.
- kodablah 8y ago> or having an environment conducive to small advertising companies. Should change to "or having an environment conducive to businesses that might want to advertise." A big difference in terms of scope of the affected.
- jamesrcole 8y agoYou're talking about secondary consequences, and if you want to keep the comparison fair then you also need to talk about the secondary consequences of the manipulation of the democratic process.
- kodablah 8y agoI was talking about the primary consequence if you want put a banner after being given money, you don't necessarily have to be an advertising company. I think you are assuming everyone uses advertising companies to advertise, but that's not true even though this is how we'd get there.
- jamesrcole 8y agoWhat I said applies to that. I said "It comes down to what you think is more important. Lessening false advertising that manipulates the democratic process (and of course the big question is to what extent this can be lessened by such policies) or having an environment conducive to small advertising companies." Change 'companies' to 'provider' (or whatever word you want to use) and that choice still applies.