5 ms·
That's probably one of the only people they could actually be sure wasn't buying Facebook ads. Whereas a senator buying Facebook ads is, in itself, quite likely
by andrewflnr 8y ago
That's probably one of the only people they could actually be sure wasn't buying Facebook ads. Whereas a senator buying Facebook ads is, in itself, quite likely. Not really a fair comparison.
- SilasX 8y agoWhy wouldn't Zuckerberg ever buy Facebook ads? I doubt they'd let him run personal stuff for free, and I doubt they'd be sure he'd never want to run personal stuff.
- andrewflnr 8y agoThe simplest way would be for him to say, "hey, I'm never going to buy ads on my own site, so don't let anyone impersonate me." If Zuck wants to tell us something on Facebook, he'll just put a banner at the top of our feed. Or if he does want to run ads as himself, he'll pull some other founder-fiat move. Keep in mind the engineering motto of the company we're talking about. They don't need to stick to the rules.
- SilasX 8y agoCorporate boards usually have controls against appropriating company resources for personal use.
- jimnotgym 8y agoPresumably there is a tax implication too? In the UK this would probably be a benefit-in-kind and taxed say it's market value as income.
- jjeaff 8y agoYes. Same in the US. Things like private jet use are applied as income. However, I'm not sure you would have to do so at retail rates. For example, you would have to pay taxes on the cost of the private jet use. The marginal cost of something like running your personal ads on the favebook platform is so low as to probably not be considered "material" by the tax man.
- briandear 8y agoConsidering he controls 60% of the company, such controls are meaningless.
- SilasX 8y agoThe controls would be something agreee to as part of taking the company public or some stage of auditing. Owning a controlling stake doesn’t mean you can fiddle around with every corporate asset at your whim.
- yayana 8y agoYes, and it's also always been more important for a publisher to defend more carefully against any misrepresentation relating to their own endorsement or trademarks on their own medium, while punting to take down processes for misuse of other's trademarks, etc is mostly allowed.
- eridius 8y agoSo what you're saying is, because a senator could conceivably be running ads, then any ad that claims to be by a senator should be approved without scrutiny? Besides being preposterous, that same argument applies to literally anybody in the world except, I guess, Mark Zuckerberg. So it sounds like Facebook's algorithm for detecting abuse is `if submitter == "Mark Zuckerberg" { reject(); }`
- sebcat 8y ago> So what you're saying is, because a senator could conceivably be running ads, then any ad that claims to be by a senator should be approved without scrutiny? That was not said in the message you replied to.
- narzu 8y agoPlease respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eridius 8y agoNo. "Iron manning" is stupid, it's just an excuse to dismiss a response because they weren't charitable enough towards your flawed argument. Strawmanning is bad too of course. But responding to a reasonable interpretation (which is distinct from "iron manning"'s demand of responding to the strongest possible interpretation) is how discourse normally works. If someone's reasonable interpretation of your argument doesn't match what you were trying to convey, then that means you fucked up your argument. In this particular case, the parent's argument is literally that Facebook is justified in not rejecting the political ads because senators are likely to buy ads. So that's what I responded to.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoTreating names as unique identifiers? Quadruple ouch.
- gregcrv 8y agoWhy? I am sure many other humans are named Mark Zuckerberg as well. Their life is probably very complicated now...
- illiac_1962 8y agoFound the Facebook employee. This clearly demonstrates their priorities and applied technical competence around the matter.
- criddell 8y agoMaybe they need to flip their process. Rather than default accept, maybe they should have default reject.