2 ms·
> ignores limits to growth (e.g. energy, rare materials, food, etc.) Lots and lots of people have tried to discredit Malthus and his reasoning in the last 200
by paganel 8y ago
> ignores limits to growth (e.g. energy, rare materials, food, etc.)
Lots and lots of people have tried to discredit Malthus and his reasoning in the last 200 years but we keep going back to him, he must of have been right in a way (if it matters, I think he was). The same way idealist political thinkers tried to discredit the writings of Hobbes and Machiavelli but it turns out human nature is closer to the writings of those two great political minds compared to whatever is fashionable at any given.
- SamPatt 8y agoJust because people go back to discredited ideas doesn't mean they weren't discredited. Malthus - and later Ehrlich - made specific predictions about the sustainability of population increase, and they were proven flat out wrong. Extrapolating a trend and showing disaster looming is much easier (and gets more attention) than recognizing that humans are adaptable and we shouldn't be so negative about humanity's future.
- paganel 8y ago> Extrapolating a trend and showing disaster looming is much easier (and gets more attention) than recognizing that humans are adaptable and we shouldn't be so negative about humanity's future. Just yesterday there was an article saying that we've managed to wipe out 60% of the animal populations since 1970, the collapse of the insect bio-mass is also a relatively recent man-made phenomenon and it also looks like man-caused climate change is almost irreversible at this point. Disaster is indeed looming and imho has already started. This is not being "negative" about the future, these are facts happening right now.