5 ms·
CRISPR holds way more promise than silly fantasies of human genetic enhancement. The most exciting and practical uses for it apply to challenging everyday probl
by chongli 8y ago
CRISPR holds way more promise than silly fantasies of human genetic enhancement. The most exciting and practical uses for it apply to challenging everyday problems: food, energy, invasive species, biodiversity.
Besides, the ethical problems with experimenting on human beings are extremely intractable.
- nserrino 8y agoHow is a CRISPR trial on a terminal patient any different than another experimental medical trial on that same terminal patient?
- whatshisface 8y agoBecause you don't modify the genetics of terminal, living adults, you want to modify the genetics of single-cell healthy zygotes (who will, you hope, later develop into healthy adults).
- mbreese 8y agoSure you do. A lot of the promise of CRISPR therapies were for modifying cells in an adult or child. Using CRISPR/cas9 to “fix” a genetic issue in someone who was already born. For example for adding back a good copy of the gene that causes cistic fibrosis or sickle cell anemia. There were also potential cancer therapies based on the technique. In these cases, the presence of cas9 antibodies is a severe limit to many of the techniques that these companies were working towards.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI agree. My father has terminal cancer and has been practically banging down doors to try to get onto medical trials for new experimental treatments. If other people in his position want to do the same thing then who are we to judge?
- jamesrcole 8y ago> CRISPR holds way more promise than silly fantasies of human genetic enhancement I really dislike pandering, dismissive statements like this. What's so inherently wrong with the entire category of genetic "enhancements" (changes for a perceived positive benefit)? You can't respond to this by just pointing out some proposed enhancements or motivations that are silly. I'm asking why you object to the very idea of any enhancements. What about changes to make the following at some point in the future (these are just to give the general idea of positive changes, I'm not saying CRISPR could necessarily be used for them). These are things that in principle could be addressed by genetic "enhancements". - stop people from getting diseases like celiac disease - lessen our evolutionary desire for fatty and sugary foods (that no longer makes sense in the modern world, and which causes great harm) - address some of the more egregious cognitive biases that cause so many problems in the world
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y ago> address some of the more egregious cognitive biases that cause so many problems in the world I'm not sure how to interpret this - are you saying we should use CRISPR to make people think a certain way? If so this seems like a pretty horrific suggestion.
- jamesrcole 8y agoHumans are, for example, very poor at making risk assessments. Evolution has "programmed" our brains to focus too much on certain things and not enough on others. These heuristics might have made sense in ancestral environments bit are quite harmful in today's world. Evolution has already "made us think a certain way". Why would it be so horrific to, for example, lessen certain of those tendancies, if they are harmful?
- wgjordan 8y agoIn order to consolidate the consensus needed to genetically alter specific 'cognitive biases' that are 'harmful' to 'humans' in 'today's world', you'll probably first need to establish a global totalitarian dictatorship ('take over the world'). That adds an extra technical challenge beyond CRISPR itself, but you can always shoot for the moon and land among the stars.