3 ms·
On a slightly related note, I am highly disappointed with the Spectrum boxes and really miss my Comcast X1 box. Spectrum and Comcast both rely on the same thir
by whalesalad 8y ago
On a slightly related note, I am highly disappointed with the Spectrum boxes and really miss my Comcast X1 box.
Spectrum and Comcast both rely on the same third-parties to supply their gear but Comcast works with partners like Arris to build their own custom boxes. They have their own custom OS running on the box. They're really fast and have a very modern UI. For instance it'll open sidebars to show current sports games with realtime scores. They also have their voice remote feature which, at first was a total gimmick to me, but ultimately became really helpful. You rarely know what channel # you want but to say "go to TLC" or "go to the world series" is really handy. They also have a remote control with an accelerometer that will glow when it jiggles, unlike any competitor. This is very useful at night.
Meanwhile my Spectrum box is virtually a thin client. For things like on-demand it's piping commands across the network to a remote host that is rendering what is displayed on your screen. The latency is horrible.
I've cut the cord once or twice with services like Playstation TV and Sling... but none of them really shake a stick to a proper cable plan. I'm disappointed with this price hike and Spectrum's hardware but for folks (my wife and I) who grew up in the generation of cable TV it's a difficult habit to break.
- josefresco 8y agoI had X1, was very nice. We have one "mommy" box and a couple of the slimmer boxes (don't know what they call it) The mobile apps were very good as well. We have YouTubeTV now, but if I had, or wanted to spend the $ I'd go with X1 again.
- howard941 8y agoDo you have Spectrum on fibre? I have their Arris (Arriss?) box on coax in Largo FL and find it a lot snappier than Comcast's Scientific Atlanta box was in Sarasota. For me an even worse experience than either has been the Arris box Verizon/Frontier deployed to Sarasota. It performs like the thin client you don't like. It's slow as the 90s-vintage SciAtl Comcast box and doesn't have knobs to increase program information font size (amongst other UI negatives). I'm biding my 6 months on Frontier before I bounce back to Comcast despite the former's far greater program selection.
- HankB99 8y agoI have the Comcast "X1 Infinity Entertainment System" and IMO it stinks. It's a bad sign when the instructions tell you to restart it to solve problems. And at best, the delay from button press to response is nearly intolerable. I think basic UI guidelines suggest something on the order of 1/4 second and this box usually takes over a second. At times I sit there wondering if I need to press the button again. Usually I don't. I just need to be patient. At other times it simply does not respond. I can see a green LED light on the box when I press a button on the remote but other than that, nothing happens. That's when I know it is time to pull the plug. In a competitive market products like this would not be tolerated.
- rconti 8y agoWhen I saw X1, it looked nice, and now Comcast is pushing the Plume pods (or something that looks like them) as repeaters. They're doing generally slick things with individual device blocking and such. That is to say, offering services that are actually harder to do on your own. The slow button press is how I feel about DirecTV. I could simply never use it because I find the 1 second delay absolutely intolerable.