3 ms·
Jailbreaking will never be mainstream when people worry about the warranty on their 1k-2k+ devices. If you want people to own their own devices you will have t
by michaelmrose 8y ago
Jailbreaking will never be mainstream when people worry about the warranty on their 1k-2k+ devices. If you want people to own their own devices you will have to write it into law presumably in a more consumer friendly jurisdiction than the US which cares about business first last and only.
- selectodude 8y agoJailbreaking has never violated the warranty. Apple just doesn’t support it so they won’t service your device until you update it to the latest software, which is completely reasonable.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI.e. violates half of your warranty, because any but the most obviously mechanical problem can be blamed on messing with software.
- selectodude 8y agoAnd as far as I’ve seen when it comes to jailbreaks, anything but the most obviously mechanical problem is caused by the jailbreak.
- jedieaston 8y agoBut the first thing they'd do even if you didn't jailbreak would be to restore your device and pull a backup from iCloud. If you want to keep your jailbreak, then they can't help you, because who knows if the latest version of iOS included a patch for your problem, a tweak you installed borked the phone, or if Apple borked it?
- michaelmrose 8y agoIt's completely reasonable that upgrading your phone and maintaining administrator access shouldn't be a challenge.
- abecedarius 8y agoFurther, there’s no theorem that jailbreaking will always be possible. I get the impression it’s becoming harder over time.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoI'm aware the jailbreak community often felt Apple was targeting them specifically, and perhaps they were, but every jailbreak was also exposing a security flaw. Personally, I've never been worried about jailbreaking voiding my warranty -- I just never got sufficient value from it to make it worth the drawbacks. (Both value and drawbacks are subjective measures, obviously.) While I understand the "you must own your own device" line, that's more of a rallying cry than a useful description. (I have a similar pedantic complaint with "if you're not the customer, you're the product," for what it's worth.) It's interesting to think about a regulatory framework that mandates companies build software-driven devices with the ability for end users to do their own software loads, but figuring out how to do that in a way that doesn't let companies wiggle out of it and doesn't essentially mandate insecure back doors in all "smart" consumer electronic devices seems to me to be a non-trivial problem.
- michaelmrose 8y agoLetting the user control the device inevitably means letting the user hurt themselves that is inevitable and impossible to fix. The least intrusive method is too allow users to add additional software sources and either opt out of sandboxing wholly or totally for select vetted apps. This isnt hard it would just hurt Apples ability to get a 30% cut as third party stores would spring up. User owned personal computing devices have been a thing for decades can we not pretend this is uncharted territory?
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoThe comment of yours that I replied to explicitly mentioned jailbreaking, which is not the same thing as "additional software sources." I'd like to see Apple allow users to install signed apps from places other than the App Store, and I suspect that protecting revenue is the main reason they don't. But I'm not particularly interested in jailbreaking, even though I'd like to see functionality that iOS doesn't currently allow.
- lstroud 8y agoWell technically you can do that. Download code, build in Xcode, and install to your device. Probably not what you meant, but it does enable some side loading.