13 ms·
"The new Liquid Retina display goes from edge to edge" I've never owned an iPad, perhaps I'm missing something here. How does the above statement reconcile wi
by tyingq 8y ago
"The new Liquid Retina display goes from edge to edge"
I've never owned an iPad, perhaps I'm missing something here. How does the above statement reconcile with the pictures I see on the page where there's clearly a black bezel?
Do they just mean there's not an area at the bottom with a physical button?
- rpeden 8y agoWell, I guess you could say the display is edge-to-edge because it goes from the edge of one bezel to the edge of the opposite bezel... :)
- nicebill8 8y agoI think this essentially means the bezels are the same width the entire way round.
- ziftface 8y agoYeah pretty much. The bezels are smaller than on current ipads, but yeah "edge to edge" is definitely a stretch.
- slavak 8y agoYou mean a "lie." Calling a notched iPhone "all-screen" is a bit of a stretch. This is just straight upfalse.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoForgive the humor in a HN comment, but because of you I shall add "upfalse" to my working lexicon.
- Sharlin 8y agoIt's a plusgood word.
- sricks3 8y ago"edge to edge" is definitely a stretch. Ha!
- antpol 8y agoThere should be room for "infinity screen" down the line too
- mcintyre1994 8y agoI guess Android phones were "edge to edge" when they first got onscreen buttons :)
- balladeer 8y agoBut they were not "magical".
- DiabloD3 8y agoYeah, no ugly "chin". Problem is, the iPhone X family got rid of the chin... but have the dreaded notch, and not even the mostly acceptable teardrop everyone else standardized on. At least the iPad Pro adopted chinless and also notchless design. First time in years Apple has made a product that isn't weirdly ugly.
- ghostly_s 8y ago"mostly acceptable teardrop everyone else standardized on."?
- dpark 8y agoYeah, that's pretty delusional. I don't think anyone has created a phone with a notch that would accurately be characterized as a teardrop shape. The closest was probably Essential (which inexplicably had a notch and a chin). The Pixel 3 notch is a V shape. The OnePlus notch pretty much looks like an iPhone notch. There's no "standard" and certainly no "standard teardrop shape".
- metafizikal 8y agoWhat if I have really weirdly shaped tears?
- screye 8y agoI don't blame you. The one plus 6T released yesterday with the teardrop notch. It is trend among chinese phones (Huawei,Oppo, Vivo, OP ..basically BBK electronics) OP 6T is the first phone popular in the west with this style, and I find it to be amazing. Still like the MiMix 3 the most, with no notch. But, the OP 6T is the first one that's not egregious.
- lozf 8y agoLooks more like a "condensation drip about to fall" than a tear drop... Not very catchy though, perhaps "innovative CDATF notch - uses 66% less screen space" would sound hype enough for the Marketing department?
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoIt's like saying 'lightning fast', when in reality it could be faster or slower than lightning, it's a metaphor that does well in marketing and doesn't leave you open to legal challenges as much as a more technical reference (e.g. 'zero bezels) would, but gets the point across that bezels are thinner than usual.
- badestrand 8y ago> it's a metaphor No, "from edge to edge" and "all-screen design" are not metaphors but as concrete as it gets, and obviously wrong. This iPad may be great but these marketing texts are just straight lies.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoYou don't seem to understand what a metaphor means. If I say it's fast as lightning, I'm not saying it's exactly that fast. It's a metaphor for fast. The fact the speed of lightning is measurable and 'as concrete as it gets' doesn't change the fact that people use it as a metaphor. You may feel the use of 'edge to edge' is an inappropriate metaphor that's fine, not every metaphor is fitting and, hell I'd even agree with you if you said that. If you ask me, you can start saying edge-to-edge when the edge is at least 50-80% thinner than what it is now. But it's a metaphor nonetheless, and I'd feel fine applying it to extremely thin bezels which are not actually edge to edge. If you'd have said such a thin bezel was 'razor-thin' or 'paper-thin' when it really wasn't, I'd say it's still a perfectly fine metaphor.
- mLuby 8y agoAgreed that 'fast as lightning' rarely refers to the literal speed of electricity in atmosphere; it's commonly understood to mean 'very fast'. However, there is no such common understanding of the phrase 'edge to edge' meaning almost edge to edge. Edge to edge in English means it goes from the edge of one side to the edge of the other, literally. It's not a metaphor. Only Jobs had a powerful enough reality warp to make that fly…
- calgoo 8y agoAm I the only one who actually like to have an edge on my devices so they dont break by looking at them? At least if there is a metal edge it can take some of the force and you have a chance of not breaking the screen. I dont understand why metal is bad and glass is somehow good? Also, I need to grab my ipad, move it around, spin it, grab it with the other hand etc. I see the edges / bezel's as very useful in these cases.
- dpark 8y ago"Edge to edge glass" doesn't mean there's literally no physical edge banding around the screen. The iPhone X models with their "all-screen design" still have a stainless steel edge band. The iPad pro clearly still has a metal edge. The device you seem to be imagining where the glass runs all the way to the edge with no edge banding doesn't exist, and would be an ugly and unpleasant device if it did, as the edges would reveal the electronic innards (and heaps of glue).
- threatofrain 8y agoDon’t some high end Android or Samsung models have edge to edge phone displays?
- dpark 8y agoSure. They still have an edge band (or a back that comes around to act as an edge band). There are no phones with screens that simply stop in a raw cut edge.
- adamweld 8y agoYou're not the only one. I also like a bit of a bezel or "chin" on my phones, because it makes holding the device with one hand for e.g. taking photos much more secure.
- appleiigs 8y agoMy 75 year old mom has real trouble trying to use her ipad mini, especially with taking pictures. Inevitably the left hand trying to hold the ipad has a thumb on the touch screen. Then when she tries to do anything else with right hand it is registered as a pinch. She also had a career in graphic design and now teaches oil/acrylic painting. I know from her, the art world likes frames. A bezel is not a bad thing.
- djrogers 8y agoBezels are smaller, and consistent all the way around, with no ‘chin’ or ‘forehead’ bars.
- leoc 8y agoYes, in this case it seems to be a euphemism for “we junked the Back button”.
- kllrnohj 8y agoBut they aren't even small bezels. There are still rather large bezels all around the "edge to edge" screen. This is just a blatant lie by Apple's marketing.
- sjwright 8y agoTheir marketing begins and ends with large, high quality photographs of the product which clearly shows the bezel size. Nobody is going to be misled. Reserve your criticism for companies like LG who actually lied about their monitors: https://www.flatpanelshd.com/news.php?subaction=showfull&id=1344853042 https://www.flatpanelshd.com/news.php?subaction=showfull&id=...
- kllrnohj 8y agoThere's not a limit for criticism. Just because LG was worse in a particular instances doesn't mean Apple gets a free pass.
- sjwright 8y agoMy point is nobody is being deceived and Apple clearly isn't trying to be deceptive. "Edge to edge" as a term has been used to describe many things, and never the mythical 0.00mm bezel that only a pedant would assume. But sure, there's no limit to criticism. Everything is horrible. Buy nothing.
- 8y ago
- zeroname 8y agoIt isn't liquid either. False advertising!
- bch 8y agoIndeed. People do just love hearing words... Presenter: “This display goes from its start...” (Audience gasps) Presenter: “...all the way until it ends! We call this ‘entire’.” Audience: <mad applause> Audience Member 1: (whispering) “I can’t wait until I can get a device with an entire display. I’ll have to put in some OT at the job to save up, though.” Audience Member 2: “What do you do?” AM1: “I work at a company that specializes in digging half-holes.”
- gowld 8y ago"I have wit. I have charm. I have brains. I have legs that go all the way down to the floor, my friend."
- tyingq 8y agoThis is my favorite response so far. I don't really have much interest in the bezel or not debate. I just didn't get "edge to edge screen" as a good description of what was being sold. By that definition, all displays are edge to edge unless you deliberately obscure some portion of the screen.
- plainOldText 8y agoI own many Apple products, and I like Apple as a company a lot; but I would have to agree with your observation. The reality does not agree with their marketing. I understand marketing can be employed as a tool to favorably present reality, but still, the edge-to-edge statement is quite a stretch.
- timcederman 8y agoThis is because the glass is edge to edge, even if the pixels aren't. (so 'technically' correct, but certainly misleading)
- munk-a 8y agoPretty much all iPads ever had had this feature, but I find this advancement super innovative!