6 ms·
Very impressive demos, but unfortunately the number of apps that can make full use of the increased power is still limited. A common complaint I saw during the
by minimaxir 8y ago
Very impressive demos, but unfortunately the number of apps that can make full use of the increased power is still limited.
A common complaint I saw during the presentation was the emphasis of the A12X for gaming, but Apple is still very bad at incentivizing developers to make games with premium experiences and prices (to say nothing of the lack of an official gaming controller!)
Also, the new Apple Pencil will only work with the new iPads; it's not compatible with previous Pros: https://www.apple.com/apple-pencil/ https://www.apple.com/apple-pencil/
- vxNsr 8y ago> Also, the new Apple Pencil will only work with the new iPads; it's not compatible with previous Pros: https://www.apple.com/apple-pencil/ https://www.apple.com/apple-pencil/ Because the older pros don't have a way to charge it. Which is to me another one of those ingenious but now obvious design choices, I know the sGNote series has "wireless" charging for their stylus, but it needs to go into the device to be charged, this is so much cooler because it doesn't require that. I wish that Microsoft had thought of this for the surface pen.
- minimaxir 8y agoI figured that'd be the case, but still disappointed.
- andrewaylett 8y agoUnless the Note series has changes dramatically, which is always possible -- I just ditched my Note 3 -- they're using passive Wacom pens. No charging necessary, the internal slot is purely for storage.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThis was definitely still true through the Note 8; but the Note 9 S-Pen has an onboard battery (mostly, I think, for the remote functionality; the core stylus functionality might use the same tech as before.)
- andrewpi 8y agoThe Note9 added bluetooth to the S Pen (you can use it as a remote camera shutter now), and it charges inductively when it's inside the phone.
- dpark 8y ago> Which is to me another one of those ingenious but now obvious design choices ... I wish that Microsoft had thought of this for the surface pen. I'm kind of glad they didn't. A pen magnetically attached will likely pop off when you put the tablet in your bag. It's a nice place to dock the pen when you're using the tablet, but poor place to store it in a bag. People report up to a year of life with the Surface Pen battery. Swapping it out when it dies seems simpler than remembering to charge it regularly.
- vxNsr 8y ago> A pen magnetically attached will likely pop off when you put the tablet in your bag. The surface pen already magnetically attaches to the surface, this would just give that attachment another purpose. > Swapping it out when it dies seems simpler than remembering to charge it regularly. You don't have to remember anything, you just "redock" the stylus when you're done using it and it will charge.
- dpark 8y ago> The surface pen already magnetically attaches to the surface, this would just give that another purpose. I'm aware. But it's not "just another purpose". It's a different design. A battery that needs charging is a fundamentally different design choice than a battery that needs replacing. I'd rather a disposable battery that lasts for a year than a rechargeable battery that lasts a week. > You don't have to remember anything, you just "redock" the stylus when you're done using it and it will charge. And then you shove your tablet in your bag and the pen falls off. The pen languishes in the bottom of the bag until the next time you want to use it, when it may or may not still be holding a usable charge. A pen that needs to be stuck to the side of your device regularly is fine for a device that sits on a desk all the time. It's less clearly beneficial for a device that gets handled constantly and goes into and out of bags.
- read_if_gay_ 8y ago>I'd rather a disposable battery that lasts for a year than a rechargeable battery that lasts a week The science isn't quite there yet with those uranium batteries
- AJ007 8y agoYou are right about the prices. Expecting a $60 AAA console game for $5 is not going to happen. Free to play AAA games where you end up spending $1000 to do everything means players end up hating the game and paying for fewer games. The alternative is games with truly massive player bases like Minecraft or Fortnite, which isn't scalable either.
- ChikkaChiChi 8y agoNintendo seems to be doing quite well at this. Why would we not have the same expectation for Apple?
- jaegerpicker 8y agoBecause Nintendo only started being able to do this within the last year and even then only a few big AAA studios are really on board. AAA games on the switch are really limited to in house Nintendo based IP and Bethesda. There are a few others but not a ton. Notable exceptions include Epic with Fortnight but that's also on iOS so it doesn't really prove the point. So really Nintendo isn't quite doing it yet. Said as an absolute lover of the switch.
- ChikkaChiChi 8y agoFair point, but their SDK is allowing indie developers to fast track access to the ecosystem and hardware. If Apple had a snap on controller like the one we're seeing Microsoft leaking, it would be game over. A great controller with great support on a refreshed Apple iPad mini would clobber everything on the market and it wouldn't even be close.
- lostgame 8y ago>> (to say nothing of the lack of an official gaming controller!) Apple themselves does not publish an 'official' gaming controller, no, instead they offer a number of third-party controllers at a quite nice build quality at prices that are comparable to buying a new PS4/XBOX controller: https://www.apple.com/shop/accessories/all-accessories/toys-games?page=1#!&f=gamecontrol&fh=4684%2B45ef https://www.apple.com/shop/accessories/all-accessories/toys-...
- minimaxir 8y agoThat's true; I do have a Steelseries Nimbus, although it feels a bit jank compared to console controllers from other companies.
- woolvalley 8y agoIt's about developers having an install base to make games against. They need to ship a controller with an apple tv, otherwise gaming stays in the casual corner it usually is in iOS. These iPads are more powerful than any nintendo switch, but nintendo has them beat because they have a dedicated gaming hardware ecosystem. I wish I could use my iPhone like I would a switch, but I can't because there isn't any serious games or first party hardware. As a result, serious game devs target mobile last, if they do at all. I bought Transistor for my apple TV for example and asked for the first refund of an iOS app ever because it was an crashy mess. I played it on my PC instead.
- saturdaysaint 8y agoMaking a controller an optional peripheral means that support is an afterthought for most app makers and that games are mostly designed with touch in mind. Nintendo and Sega have showed time and again throughout their histories that optional controllers get little to no 3rd party support.
- SllX 8y agoDoubt they would do it, but their own spin on the Nintendo seal of quality, with a floor of $50-$60 USD (and their own spin on "Selects" a few years later dropping some of those prices to $20USD) with some mandates on what that seal of quality means (performance, software features, hardware support, &c.) and they might turn that gaming ship around. Among their requirements they could list: Apple TV with Controller support (allowing devs to ditch the useless support for the Remote), some online features (some rebranded version of Game Center), Mac support (for Macs that support the latest iterations of Metal). It's the little things.
- askafriend 8y agoCounterpoint: A full version of Photoshop is coming to iPad in 2019. Adobe announced it at their conference recently. I suspect they'll bring full versions of Lightroom, and all their other Pro Apps soon to iPad.
- killerdhmo 8y agoYep; here are live apps: * Lightroom CC on iPhone/iPad: https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-cc/how-to/lightroom-mobile.html https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-cc/how-to/lightroom-mobile... * Just recently announced Premier Rush: https://www.adobe.com/products/premiere-rush.html https://www.adobe.com/products/premiere-rush.html Planned/Announced: * Photoshop: https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/photoshop-ecosystem.html https://www.adobe.com/creativecloud/photoshop-ecosystem.html * Project Gemini (for drawing/painting/illustrating): https://theblog.adobe.com/introducing-project-gemini/ https://theblog.adobe.com/introducing-project-gemini/
- tardigras 8y agoIt always takes time to fully utilize a new platform's specs.
- werbel 8y agoI remember 2005 when was running Windows with Linux in a VM, Photoshop, Firefox, my Rails application and all of the other software I needed for development, music and everything else on a 1GHz AMD Athlon and 256MB SDRAM. When it comes to software that’s not games and stuff like video editing it seems to me like the most of what happens is “It takes time for new software/updates to show up that once again are able to waste the full extent of my newly acquired processing power”. I know we get more robust games now, I know we render 4K videos instead of 460p, I know we display UI on higher resolution screens but there’s really no excuse for a software with similar feature scope to take the same resources percentage of modern top of the line hardware as mid-tier 18 years old machine. Bummer ;(
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- unrealhoang 8y agoYes, my wildest dream is that they will release XCode with developer's tools (i.e. compilers), my laptop will be gone that exact second.
- jaegerpicker 8y agoditto if I could use Xcode on the iPad Pro I'd almost never use my MacBook Pro. That may be why it hasn't happed yet as many of us probably feel that way.
- akhilcacharya 8y agoI like my mouse too much for this to be possible. Selecting/moving text with a finger is more annoying.
- wlesieutre 8y ago>That may be why it hasn't happed yet as many of us probably feel that way. I don't know about that; one of Apple's hallmarks is that they aren't afraid to compete with their own products. Some companies would have said "We can't make the tablet into a powerful computer, it would cut into notebook sales. Especially with the USB-C change, these iPads are a serious competitor to Apple's laptops for pretty much anyone except developers. In a lot of ways they're better. Just not for programming because the software is still too sandboxed. Here's hoping that Xcode shows up.
- jclardy 8y agoSame here. Especially with the new hardware from this year. Apple puts a ton of engineering into these new iOS devices, a little sad that the Mac lines don't really get the same treatment. I feel we are insanely close to this reality though. We have large enough displays now (even on the small one), external display support, external keyboard support and USB-C so we can actually plug in an iPhone into the iPad itself (Though this could have been skirted with the advent of wireless debugging support in Xcode. I'd still rather have the wire though.) Only thing I really want is some kind of trackpad or trackpad replacement. Or even just mouse support and I'll drop one in my bag.
- 8y ago
- pandakar 8y agoInterestingly, one place where this race to the bottom is NOT present is in iPad music apps, synths and DAWs. Prices range from 10 to 50, and the apps are polished.
- simplify 8y ago> unfortunately the number of apps that can make full use of the increased power is still limited Isn't that a good thing? For example, wouldn't it be great if all web apps were optimized for specs lower than the machines we use?
- yborg 8y agoDoes the old Pencil work with the new iPads though?
- minimaxir 8y agoPer the site, apparently not (guess the "can't charge" rationale works both ways)