4 ms·

Ask HN: What is your relationship with Imageboards?

5 points by lainon 8y ago

4chan, 8chan etc.

warent 8y ago
Far in the rear-view mirror
krapp 8y ago
I think more sites, particularly forums and social media sites, should allow for "anonymous by default" engagement and autokilling threads. I like that I can just show up, participate and leave and not have to sell my soul for the privilege. Other than that... meh. The memes, piss-taking and toxicity make them all but worthless for anyone who wants to have an intelligent conversation.
Vaskivo 8y ago
4chan is my guilty pleasure. I don't use social media. So 4chan is my "scrolling while waiting for the bus". I mostly lurk. And It's mostly for "the lulz". But once in a while you get big nuggets of wisdom and insight. It's "a thousand monkeys in typewriters" in practice.
enkiv2 8y ago
I was only ever a regular on the (small, now-defunct) irreality.me imageboard. The most activity I ever performed on 4chan was that time I wrote a bot that responded to every post on /pol/ with a random section of Society of the Spectacle (in an arguably successful attempt to improve the quality of discussion there). I find imageboards to be interesting from a media-studies perspective, though. They're a clear case (even clearer than twitter) of design influencing user behavior in a way that eventually generalizes outside of the platform. Three countries have shockingly similar & arguably totally distinct right-wing authoritarian populist movements that sprung up from totally distinct popular imageboards during the same period, & there are probably more that I'm simply not aware of. So, serious study of the kinds of behaviors imageboards encourage & highlight (and serious study of under what conditions those behaviors generalize) is potentially really interesting. It's one of those things that makes me wish I was a real social scientist instead of just a programmer with hobbies.
rc-1140 8y ago
Love 'em, hate 'em, miss 'em. 4chan was amazing for years, somewhere until about 2011 where things started going downhill. 2012 was the last year where the "good" content outweighed the bad. There were some cool/niche/offshoot boards that were fun in their own ways, like 7chan, 420chan, Krautchan, Fighting Amphibians. That's where I learned all sorts of power user and computer stuff over the years. Even got to play in a site-famous tournament at one point. I still keep in contact with the people I've met on some of those imageboards. I lurk a few boards that are worth tolerating these days on 4chan, and use other ones merely as resource/content aggregation, like /mu/ for new music. Places like 8chan, Lainchan, Postbox, etc. are awful. 8chan was cool for like 6 months because it had all of the tinges of old 4chan, but it got co-opted by different groups until it became the alt-right hugbox. Lainchan is just filled with a few different caricatures of previously-underage or mentally unsound 4chan /g/ posters. One thing they all seem to have in common is pretentiousness and a burning need to constantly participate in actual - not humorous - one-upsmanship; they must always be better than the "normies" (an irony here being that they use the new-school "politically correct" version of the parent word) and even the people they deem "worthy" of participating in discussion. They often make spinoff after spinoff, IRC channel after IRC channel, and then cry about having no place to discuss what they want despite having a wasteland of dead spinoff boards and IRC channels. Point out that they're free to discuss their topic on $theLatestSpinoff, and they'll cry about whoever isn't part of their in-group "ruining" their space. It's tiresome and they're not worth any nuggets of information they may hold. There are one or two up-and-coming imageboards that actually have amicable content and decent users, though.
- potta_coffee 8y ago
  What are the up-and-coming boards? Lainchan seemed ok for a while but users are exactly as you described. Also, it's pretty much dead.
  - lainon 8y ago
    Where can I msg you? There's one Imageboard which currently stands out

5 points by lainon 8y ago

4chan, 8chan etc.

warent 8y ago

Far in the rear-view mirror

krapp 8y ago

I think more sites, particularly forums and social media sites, should allow for "anonymous by default" engagement and autokilling threads. I like that I can just show up, participate and leave and not have to sell my soul for the privilege. Other than that... meh. The memes, piss-taking and toxicity make them all but worthless for anyone who wants to have an intelligent conversation.

Vaskivo 8y ago

4chan is my guilty pleasure. I don't use social media. So 4chan is my "scrolling while waiting for the bus". I mostly lurk. And It's mostly for "the lulz". But once in a while you get big nuggets of wisdom and insight. It's "a thousand monkeys in typewriters" in practice.

enkiv2 8y ago

I was only ever a regular on the (small, now-defunct) irreality.me imageboard. The most activity I ever performed on 4chan was that time I wrote a bot that responded to every post on /pol/ with a random section of Society of the Spectacle (in an arguably successful attempt to improve the quality of discussion there). I find imageboards to be interesting from a media-studies perspective, though. They're a clear case (even clearer than twitter) of design influencing user behavior in a way that eventually generalizes outside of the platform. Three countries have shockingly similar & arguably totally distinct right-wing authoritarian populist movements that sprung up from totally distinct popular imageboards during the same period, & there are probably more that I'm simply not aware of. So, serious study of the kinds of behaviors imageboards encourage & highlight (and serious study of under what conditions those behaviors generalize) is potentially really interesting. It's one of those things that makes me wish I was a real social scientist instead of just a programmer with hobbies.

rc-1140 8y ago

Love 'em, hate 'em, miss 'em. 4chan was amazing for years, somewhere until about 2011 where things started going downhill. 2012 was the last year where the "good" content outweighed the bad. There were some cool/niche/offshoot boards that were fun in their own ways, like 7chan, 420chan, Krautchan, Fighting Amphibians. That's where I learned all sorts of power user and computer stuff over the years. Even got to play in a site-famous tournament at one point. I still keep in contact with the people I've met on some of those imageboards. I lurk a few boards that are worth tolerating these days on 4chan, and use other ones merely as resource/content aggregation, like /mu/ for new music. Places like 8chan, Lainchan, Postbox, etc. are awful. 8chan was cool for like 6 months because it had all of the tinges of old 4chan, but it got co-opted by different groups until it became the alt-right hugbox. Lainchan is just filled with a few different caricatures of previously-underage or mentally unsound 4chan /g/ posters. One thing they all seem to have in common is pretentiousness and a burning need to constantly participate in actual - not humorous - one-upsmanship; they must always be better than the "normies" (an irony here being that they use the new-school "politically correct" version of the parent word) and even the people they deem "worthy" of participating in discussion. They often make spinoff after spinoff, IRC channel after IRC channel, and then cry about having no place to discuss what they want despite having a wasteland of dead spinoff boards and IRC channels. Point out that they're free to discuss their topic on $theLatestSpinoff, and they'll cry about whoever isn't part of their in-group "ruining" their space. It's tiresome and they're not worth any nuggets of information they may hold. There are one or two up-and-coming imageboards that actually have amicable content and decent users, though.

potta_coffee 8y ago
What are the up-and-coming boards? Lainchan seemed ok for a while but users are exactly as you described. Also, it's pretty much dead.
- lainon 8y ago
  Where can I msg you? There's one Imageboard which currently stands out