4 ms·
Testing Privacy-Preserving Telemetry with Prio
- oedmarap 8y agoGreat strategy here to aggregate results by splitting and distributing the data to different nodes. As for them vetting third-parties as mentioned in the article, I'd actually prefer Mozilla to host different telemetry collection nodes itself and just route them round-robin anonymously within their own network. IMO having to extend intermediary trust might be taking one step forward two steps back here if who collects the data != who analyzes it.
- xcodevn 8y agoYou don't need to trust all third-parties. Crypto magic guarantees that what you need is at least ONE server being honest. If you trust Mozilla, then you have nothing to worry about, except the proof or program may be wrong ;) Third-parties are for someone who doesn't trust Mozilla. Or that Mozilla could be compromised by an unknown adversary.
- betterunix2 8y agoThe security model of the Prio protocol requires two or more non-colluding servers, so having Mozilla control both would be pretty questionable.
- rhelmer 8y agoPart of the threat model is that individual orgs can be compelled in various ways to turn over individual user data, and having different orgs holding their own private keys helps to mitigate this.
- a_imho 8y agoIt is probable me but I don't understand what are the advantages here or what that picture supposed to convey. Data is transmitted and aggregated, albeit in a fancier way. What does it have over Telemetry?
- callahad 8y agoTelemetry is reported centrally to Mozilla, so we could theoretically observe individual responses as they came in, even if we only wanted to analyze the data in aggregate. Prio uses cryptography to ensure that no one, not even the receiving servers, can see individual responses; the only way to view the data is in aggregate. We need telemetry to make competitive products, but we also want to ensure that we don't see any of your personal data that you don't explicitly opt-in to us seeing. Similarly, we store all Firefox Sync data in a way that makes it impossible for us to decrypt: your data is your data. In contrast, Chrome defaults to allowing Google to read your synced browsing data, which Google explicitly uses to profile you for targeted advertisements. Edit: If you're interested, you can find Mozilla's Data Collection policies and procedures at https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/Data_Collection https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/Data_Collection
- a_imho 8y agoeven if we only wanted to analyze the data in aggregate. Does moz://a do this? Analyze data in aggregate exclusively? Otherwise I understand Prio is inferior in granularity to Telemetry? How should one interpret data aggregation of Category 4 “Highly sensitive data”? Put it in another way, is it possible to trace back data to individuals from aggregations or any other way? We need telemetry to make competitive products Personally I disagree with this. I consider privacy and the lack of bundled (spy|mal|ad|telemetry)ware a competitive edge.
- callahad 8y agoNot exclusively, but quoting the article, "for most purposes we don’t need to collect individual data, but rather only aggregates. [...] Once we’ve validated that [Prio]’s working as expected and provides the privacy guarantees we require, we can move forward in applying it where it is needed most." So we'll be able to apply Prio where it makes sense, but stick with the current Telemetry pipeline where it doesn't. I'm not a cryptographer, but from skimming the paper and slides at https://www.henrycg.com/pubs/nsdi17prio/ https://www.henrycg.com/pubs/nsdi17prio/, my naive understanding is that it would be practically impossible to trace back individual data from those aggregations as long as TLS works and at least one of the receiving servers is operating honestly.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agowhy the fuck is mozilla receiving packets period?
- rhelmer 8y agoI worked on the Firefox integration (per the article) if anyone has specific questions. If you want more detail on Prio itself, I'd suggest http://blog.ezyang.com/2017/03/prio-private-robust-and-scalable-computation-of-aggregate-statistics/ http://blog.ezyang.com/2017/03/prio-private-robust-and-scala... as a more gentle introduction than the research paper.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]