2 ms·
So yeah, with respect to your distinction of "ML research" and "applied ML". "NO." Interesting. I don't see anything in the story above that supports that po
by mindcrime 8y ago
So yeah, with respect to your distinction of "ML research" and "applied ML". "NO."
Interesting. I don't see anything in the story above that supports that position. There's nothing about the scenario you described that would be affected by having, or not having, a Phd in CS. If anything, as somebody else pointed out, this is more of question of philosophy or ethics.
It's also a pretty niche example, which is not representative of the kinds of things that ML can be used for. If you want somebody who work on pricing optimization or a recommender system for your e-commerce site, you really don't need somebody who's doing cutting edge ML research.
- paulgrant999 8y ago> There's nothing about the scenario you described that would be affected by having, or not having, a Phd in CS. For starters, understanding there is a basic feedback cycle, where your ML in rejecting claims, directly affects patient treatment, wouldn't escape the attention of a PHD. Part of doing research, is anticipating questions you might not ordinarily think of, in connection with your research i.e. to examine the literature for known unknowns. Guess what? You think he looked, even after being directly apprised in VERY clear terminology? > It's also a pretty niche example, which is not representative of the kinds of things that ML can be used for. Fraud detection, niche? Thats what he is doing. Looking for "patterns" of fraud. He's just lazy and doesn't actually want to look at his data. Which again, means he shouldn't be running ML++. ML trains bias built in; and doesn't handle drift particularly well (isn't robust). You can do all sorts of things to try and address it. But thats only if you know about it (and care to pay for it). Some things, ML isn't suited for. Its like that woman diabetic who died, because some bureacrat cut off her foodstamps, even though they knew it was a bureacratic error; or that police officer, who let a man with cardiac arythmia die in the back of his car, because he had to "follow procedure". Except, worse. At least these people can be dragged out into the light, and fired. ML? who keeps track of that? ++ actually it means he shouldn't be running an insurance claims "fraud detection" company. but is a larger point outside the topic.