10 ms·
There are two possible outcomes from Article 11. Either it will backfire and large Internet networks like Google or Facebook will start removing links to news s
by elorant 8y ago
There are two possible outcomes from Article 11. Either it will backfire and large Internet networks like Google or Facebook will start removing links to news sites which will have the opposite result from what the latter where hopping when they were lobbying for a new copyright law, or it will kill the web as we know it at least in Europe. I'd put my money on the first scenario.
- mrweasel 8y agoWorst case is adding a little more bureaucracy. Google will stop listing news sites, or at least summaries. The number of visitors will crash and the news sites will be forced to give Google (and others) a free license to link to their content. It not going to be an issue, some newspapers already allow to access to articles for free is you come directly from a search engine. The part I find troubling is filtering user uploaded content, that's simply not going to work.
- Vinnl 8y agoI also wonder about your "(and others)" parenthesis - I don't immediately have reason to believe that that would be the case.
- Sebb767 8y agoWe had the exact same situation in Germany already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancillary_copyright_for_press_publishers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancillary_copyright_for_press_... In the end Google said "ok, then we'll stop listing you" and suddenly the publishers that wanted this law gave Google permission to link to them without cost. Sounds okay in theory, but every minor search engine or news aggregator which doesn't have the defacto monopoly of Google still suffers from it.
- ru999gol 8y agowhich then had the interesting effect of actually being great for Google, it will effectively prevent any competition of google news forever. Politicians are all corrupt/payed for, they have absolutely no concept of what they are doing and could not care less about its collateral damage.
- dexen 8y ago>the news sites will be forced to give Google (and others) a free license to link to their content. The insidious thing - a free license can't even be offered under the law. I presume it's meant to preclude both the repeat of the case you mention, and prevent "race to the bottom", i.e., news providers competing with each other on price on resource that has near-zero marginal cost (an article being linked to/snippeted from). From TFA: >Recital 32 suggests that (1) anyone who wants to link to the news has to have a separate, commercial license; >and (2) news companies can't waive this right, (...)
- kansface 8y agoThey could charge $1, no?